If anything, I'm borderline Christian. I would say I'm sitting on the fence with Agnosticism on the other side, but I really don't have a name for my beliefs. I share beliefs from multiple religions, with a hint of my own.
I think I've decided that when people ask what religion I am, I'll just say, "I don't know, religion is too much to worry about for me. I am what you want me to be."
And walk away with them being confused. If I called myself a Christian, or Catholic, or Jew, or Muslim, or Buddhist, or Atheist, or Agnostic, or Nihilist, or anything else, there would still be too much from that religion (or lack thereof) that I find too hard to accept or believe, and therefore I don't have a title for my beliefs.
Religion just doesn't affect me how it affects others, and I'm fine with that. No one can change what I believe, and they are truly out of their minds if they try.