I do like action movies, but The Dark Knight Rises lacks an intriguing story and I got quite bored especially because Batman wasn't in the movie much at all. It was interesting to see more of Bruce Wayne I suppose, but why was he such a pussy in the beginning. Seriously, that's not the Batman I thought I knew (I realize I sound really corny right now). There a bunch of questionable things that turned me off of it too; mostly a bunch of small things, for example, the TV with cable being in that prison. One big issue was "you should use your real name: Robin." What the hell? It's cool that he's Robin, but that was a shitty reveal, and why is his first name Robin? I thought of writing up a long review of it, but then I realized it would be a waste of time. There are already some negative reviews that share my thoughts on the film. I think I just really hate Nolan's Batman. I want the franchise rebooted already even though people will complain. It doesn't need to start from Batman's origins. Directed by Darren Aronofsky, starring someone who isn't Christian Bale.
Well those are some pretty good points actually. The TV one is probably just an assumption that if Bane was such a powerful crime lord than he could probably afford cable (but not Direct TV!). Should have had more of an explanation. Even the reveal of Robin (instead of Dick Grayson) was a little forced, admittedly. I mean, obviously he couldn't be Dick Grayson since there were too many differences in the origin. Blah blah blah, continuity, I know that you don't want that talk.
So you are completely right when discussing the flaws of the films. The thing I couldn't stand was Marion Cotillard (Talia Al Ghul) because although she's an Oscar winner, she's a terrible actress. And true, Anne Hathaway spent most of her time posing, but she was the best Catwoman in my opinion, I couldn't stand the Tim Burton version. This film was certainly the worst of the three, but in the same way that Return of the King or Prisoner of Azkaban were for Lord of the Rings and Harry Potter. So much could have gone wrong, and to get so much right in a movie this large is impressive. Will it ever be considered a classic? Probably not, although altogether they are among the the greatest trilogies of all time. As for Aronofsky as the director of the sequel/reboot, I'm not sure. I've never actually seen any films of his, but as far as I know, he hasn't done any work that could make him a good choice. Honestly, I don't know who could possibly do it now that Nolan has left. I would love to direct a Batman movie myself, but so would everyone else.
Although I agree there hasn't been much released this year, we've still had The Avengers and The Amazing Spider-Man, which are thought were two superior comic book films. I think I may have overrated Spider-Man a bit, but for some reason I just loved that movie. It didn't have a broken plot (although there were a couple things a little out of place) and the action was enjoyable. Spider-Man was actually in that movie too. The Avengers was just incredible and I don't know how a fan of comics could dislike it.
Now that's what I'm talking about. I liked Dark Knight Rises slightly more only because there's only so much popcorn action I can take. That isn't to say that Avengers and Spidey sucked, far from it. They were second and third of the movies this year to me, but not by much. Avengers got everything right that movies like "Transformers" got so wrong, and it had just the right amount of action and humor. Spidey, on the other hand, had the best romance that I've seen in a while, and I normally hate that sort of stuff. Plus there was funnier lines and better action in some places, though The Lizard wasn't the best Spidey villain to choose from (Doctor Octopus is still the best one so far, when it comes to Spidey bad guys). I still like the originals more, because of nostalgia, but the reboot was far superior to all others but Batman Begins.
On a side note, I really hope "Iron Man 3" is good. The original was so funny and so creative, and the sequel just didn't cut it for me...
But hey, we actually had a reasonable discussion about our opinions without argument. I think that's pretty impressive.