At 3/15/08 11:26 PM, someONEgood wrote:
... though I'm sure there'd be haters crying "zOMG anime GTFO weeaboo"...
Yeah me. It's the same thing with Transformers changing the robots. It's about style, and don't get me wrong I love some Anime: Lain, the aforementioned Cowboy Bebop, Ghost in the Shell (the movie), Princess Mononoke, The Wolf Brigade, Grave of the Fireflies, Memories, Blood (too short though) etc. I'm not an irrational hater. However if I saw a Metal Movie where the breasts and the eyes were approximately the same size I would aggresively vomit at the screen. I hated some of the Classics of Anime. Vampire Hunter D? Gag me with a valley girl. That sucked.
I don't get this 'style' anyway. Anime. I love that Anime helped to bend the limits of cartoons as film. Some of them do it exceedingly well. But the style. Why does everything look like it was made by the same guy in varying stages of Maturity. Huge fuckin eyes. No noses on girls to speak of. Inappropriate overly simplified and exaggerated facial expressions counterbalanced by no expression whatsoever. And they're all playing off Astroboy which is took it's cues from Disney. It's an exaggeration of an exaggeration that (when the better ones try) is reigned back into a formal approach to the figure.
Again I don't think it's bad in small doses. But god dammit. Look at american Comic Books. There are hundreds of individual styles all breaking ground and expanding upon the simplified human figure.
Again to regain some credibility I read Runaways which is drawn by Micheal Ryan in Anime style. I don't hate it irrationally, it just gets more credit than it deserves as a style.