At 10/7/09 09:50 PM, sir5000 wrote:
So...what makes art and what makes it porn?
Ok I think I have an answer for this that will hopefully satisfy you. There are going to be a lot of generalities but hopefully you get the idea.
It can be argued that all porn is art. And on an essential level it is. Whether its drawn, painted, photographed, filmed, its art. Because those are artistic mediums.
However for the sake of the art portal we say Porn is not allowed. What we mean by that is if the sole intention is masturbation and arousal of the viewer then its porn. Like I've said before if it can be used as whacking material, but that wasn't the only goal of the artist then chances are we will leave it alone.
If you are asking because you are planning on submitting something that you are unsure what it will be viewed as, you can either PM a preview of it to a mod, or post it in the porn art thread and ask there (because its probably the only thread will really really adult stuff is allowed currently).
If you are asking because you want to flag certain pieces, but don't want to look like an idiot if you get it wrong, then its best to just not bother and leave the piece alone. Currently I don't think whistle points are gained or lost when flagging stuff (correct me anyone who knows otherwise) so the worst case scenario if you do flag something and its not rule breaking is you look a bit foolish for a second and that's it, the piece will be kept and no harm done.
Hopefully that will put an end to this discussion at least for a little bit.