100 greatest guitarists of all time

[ArmorAll]

http://www.rollingstone.com/news/story/5 937559/the_100_greatest_guitarists_of_al l_time/
My oppinion is that this list ist the best they could have done
where the hell is dimebag darrell?
why is angus young so far down?
theres a couple other problems, but does anyone think this isnt the greatest list they could have done. also how do they figure out this list?

[AngryBanana]

Excuse me but....what the hell is so amazing about Jimi Hendrix?

[Gergaloth]

Where the fuck is Yngwie Malmsteen?!

[MickTheChampion]

No Rory Gallagher? No Paul Weller?

Also, Kurt Cobain over Tom Morello and David Gilmour? lolno

Rolling Stone lists are always shite.

[reviewer-general]

Where the fuck is SLASH???

=O

L'outrage!

[CryogenChaos]

So I suppose Buckethead would be too much to ask for.

[Hijck32]

Wow that list is so wrong in my eyes
first of all where's herman lee

[Sabotage]

At 1/8/08 09:44 PM, ArmorAll wrote: http://www.rollingstone.com/news/story/5 937559/the_100_greatest_guitarists_of_al l_time/
My oppinion is that this list ist the best they could have done

Yeah, there's a lot of criticisms like how there isn't many female guitarists and whatnot on the list. I don't think they should call it the greatest of all time, just the greatest to Rolling Stones Magazine heh.

where the hell is dimebag darrell?

The list was made Aug 27, 2003. Dimebag didn't die till 2004, so maybe they didn't consider giving him recognition for his talents before he died.

Posted Aug 27, 2003 12:00 AM

why is angus young so far down?

Because AC/DC is overrated.

[Gergaloth]

At 1/8/08 09:49 PM, Hijck32 wrote: Wow that list is so wrong in my eyes
first of all where's herman lee

Where's Kyle Gass?

oh wait....nevermind him

[not-an-alt-at-all]

I see two things on that list that are definetly wrong, first, Angus Young is actually on it, second, there is absolutely no mention of Axel Rudi Pell

[MickTheChampion]

At 1/8/08 09:50 PM, Gergaloth wrote:

At 1/8/08 09:49 PM, Hijck32 wrote: Wow that list is so wrong in my eyes
first of all where's herman lee

Where's Kyle Gass?

oh wait....nevermind him

Shut yo mouth.

[greensucksbluerules]

At 1/8/08 09:47 PM, reviewer-general wrote: Where the fuck is SLASH???

=O

L'outrage!

Un-fucking-belivable.

[JesterCo]

david gilmour shud be WAY ahead than jack white!
u shud also check there 500 best albums
i mean i love the beatles but that list is bad as hell...........

[ArmorAll]

... you really dont like angus young? i thought he was pretty good, have a drink on me was a good song...

[SCTE3]

At 1/8/08 09:46 PM, AngryBanana wrote: Excuse me but....what the hell is so amazing about Jimi Hendrix?

Jimi Hendrix was the youngest guitarists and inspired ppl with the many bands he became part of.
His life ended tragically because of drugs at the age of 28.

[reviewer-general]

At 1/8/08 09:55 PM, shadowchaotailsevil3 wrote: His life ended tragically because of drugs at the age of 28.

So did Sid Vicious, but he was HORRIBLE.

[Luxury-Yacht]

The day Kurt Cobain is better at guitar then Santana is the day that "guitar" means shooting yourself in the face.

[Azutom]

Kirk Hammett is on the list? W00t, what a credible list.
No Zakk Wylde, Dimebag, and Hendrix on top? Sure he was a great musician, but he couldn't play for shit.

[Slayer3751]

slash

nuff said about the best guitarist

[Luxury-Yacht]

Also, no Steven Vai.

Je suis apeshit.

[MickTheChampion]

At 1/8/08 09:57 PM, Luxury-Yacht wrote: The day Kurt Cobain is better at guitar then Santana is the day that "guitar" means shooting yourself in the face.

That's actually the best summary of that list possible.

You should seriously consider writing to Rolling Stone with that.

[Gergaloth]

At 1/8/08 10:00 PM, MickTheChampion wrote:

At 1/8/08 09:57 PM, Luxury-Yacht wrote: The day Kurt Cobain is better at guitar then Santana is the day that "guitar" means shooting yourself in the face.

That's actually the best summary of that list possible.

You should seriously consider writing to Rolling Stone with that.

agreed

[Slayer3751]

At 1/8/08 09:57 PM, reviewer-general wrote:

At 1/8/08 09:55 PM, shadowchaotailsevil3 wrote: His life ended tragically because of drugs at the age of 28.

So did Sid Vicious, but he was HORRIBLE.

so did elvis

[NimbleElephant]

At 1/8/08 09:52 PM, JesterCo wrote: david gilmour shud be WAY ahead than jack white!
u shud also check there 500 best albums
i mean i love the beatles but that list is bad as hell...........

Pretty much every Beatle's album is on it. As well as most of Dylan's early stuff.

[Luxury-Yacht]

At 1/8/08 10:00 PM, MickTheChampion wrote:

At 1/8/08 09:57 PM, Luxury-Yacht wrote: The day Kurt Cobain is better at guitar then Santana is the day that "guitar" means shooting yourself in the face.

That's actually the best summary of that list possible.

You should seriously consider writing to Rolling Stone with that.

RE: 100 Greatest Guitarist of All Time

The day Kurt Cobain is better at guitar then Santana is the day that "guitar" means shooting yourself in the face.

P.S. Stop putting Kanye on the cover of your shit magazine. He is NOT the "Black Bono". Not that I like Bono, but even I think he deserves more credit than that.

[Azutom]

At 1/8/08 09:59 PM, Luxury-Yacht wrote: Also, no Steven Vai.

Je suis apeshit.

No Satriani either. :x

[chris4322]

no kyle gass...i saw them in concert..should at least be in 80s on list :(

[Cheese-on-toast]

funny, i thought Page and Clapton would be higher... otherwise i have no objections to it

[Suntime]

Oh I'm happy David Gilmour made it on there. He's my favorite.

[Rozner]

I like Santana.