Well it all depends if they get the look right. I know some emo girls who a lot of people would like to do, yet I know some wannabes who try too hard and end up looking like they just walked through a carwash.
Goth girls aren't very plentiful around here, one girl I know I'd definitely call a goth is pretty ugle, spotty and slightly overweight. Others I have seen around the capital are very hot and have minimal piercings (I generally find that piercings take away points for hotness unless it's just one lip ring or something).