At 2/13/10 12:12 PM, Supersteph54 wrote:
Reviewed Kirbyfemur's piece above me, so I guess I'm entitled to posting a WiP here, right?
It's Epic Classical by the way, so I expect praise :P.
Mostly for length. lol
Yes it does have that epic feel to it, but maybe a little too much? It feels like a lot of people are trying to write "Epic" classical pieces, but missing out on a lot of the subtleness of a lot of other kinds of classical types of songs.
at :15 one of the samples sounds like it ends to abruptly, and it feels like a hiccup when it goes with the other sounds that are being held out. After that i like the building of sounds with the snare starting up, but maybe come in with a single instrument playing a variation of the melody before bringing in the whole symphony.
Also the instruments carrying the melody sound like they're doing this weird thing of being just slightly out of sync with the other instruments.
It's nice, it has the epicness, but it needs way more substance in order to be a more listenable piece,I mean a song that can be heard multiple times and still be interesting, and able to heard different things with each listen, since most of the instruments are carrying the same melody/harmony.
I'll pm you this review just in case you don't get to see it in here =3