I will be reviewing everything on page 10 because I feel like giving back to the community. Merry Christmas everyone!
At 11/28/11 01:04 AM, lhavf wrote:
Here is a song that I am working on, please give your advice and criticism about basically anything.
I love the airy feel I get from this song, it feels like I'm soaring above the clouds. Or at the very least strolling through a town at night time. The harp is too aggressive, if you sub your guitar make sure it's very legato and smooth. You wight want to consider cutting out some repetition, adding a few melodies in would make it a more interesting track.
At 11/28/11 11:14 PM, Cleverhill wrote:
Any suggestions how I shall continue this one?
I imagine a countryside in medieval times when I hear this song. I think you should continue the pattern you built up to near the end for a bit. But then fade out and have a solo flute play the pattern with light percussion to give a little more emotion that way. Overall I like the track, the beginning was jagged and rough but I have a feeling you were going for that.
At 11/30/11 02:32 AM, Muesical-Pope wrote:
Here be my WIP please give me some direction suggestions if u can -_- im just doodling so far.
I like the upbeat feel of this track. It's kind of a little crazy, and unfocused. The notes sound good though, and the match the bassline. Maybe have a drum or bass break somewhere in there then build up to a next part. But basically focus your notes and you'll have a polished piece.
At 11/30/11 02:36 AM, ChimeraNoise wrote:
At 11/30/11 07:38 AM, Xyresic wrote:
These tracks were deleted, sorry!
At 11/30/11 09:25 PM, Tc572 wrote:
Near the beginning, the melody seems to be taking a back seat to the bass, then fades in so much it drowns the bass out. I like the melodies they're very catchy, but unfortunately also repetitive. There is a lot of repetition in the song. But, the song sounds nice, I could see clubs playing it as the dring kick and bass would sound great with a large sub-woofer.
At 12/1/11 12:12 PM, Kirbyfemur wrote:
Just curious if there is anything that someone else thinks i can do with this, i have some ideas, but just curious
There's nothing really to say, the melody, bass, drums and rhythms are well fleshed out and the repetition is far apart and hard to notice. The instruments go well over each, nice track!
At 12/3/11 11:03 PM, Computer112 wrote:
Anyone has criticism and suggestions. Thanks.
Sounds like a Halloween track mixed with a Battlefield track. It sounds really cool. The orchestra really defines the mood and the timpani adds that nice backbone to the whole thing. Hmm, I couldn't think of how to continue it, maybe add a solo timpani with the orchestra building up behind it? But it sounds really good.
At 12/4/11 07:48 AM, Frazmaster wrote:
Kind of Ambient/Instrumental Hip-Hop/Electronica
I don't get "By the River" from this song. I get more of an abandoned town or factory. I like the ambiance of this track, it uplifts the ears and takes me away. The drums were kind of abrupt, I think an intro transition would sound clearer. The melody is simple, but it makes the track even better. Some of the synth breaks need to be fleshed out a bit.
At 12/5/11 04:21 AM, trabajaba7 wrote:
Deleted , sorry!
At 12/9/11 10:20 PM, SpaceWhale wrote:
Could some of you review this? I would love some critique.
The build up with the violins is good, the bass doesn't really have depth to it. The low end needs a little more "umph", however the track really comes together, and the drop is clean and focused. I think a melody in the violin would add more flavour to the song and maybe some more variety in the basses? Overall good job.
At 12/9/11 11:41 PM, Toxicks wrote:
Just started working this one, looking to see if anyone likes it,
The bass, goes through some funky notes. It sounds odd, and the glockenspiel (?) transition was very awkward. It felt like two different songs being spliced together. The idea was good by the execution needs some fine tuning. You'll be a great musician yet!
At 12/13/11 09:22 PM, Tabu112 wrote:
I'm going to do all three tracks at once here.
Hardstyle in progress
Very bouncy, and that's good for hardstyle. The melody was cool and very spacey. The whole track had a cool overtone to it. To add to it, make a build up with just synth and let the drums and bass just come in and make the track just dance worthy. The potential is huge here.
More work on to hard trance
It's the same as the first one? I'm not sure what you added, haha.
Very soft, like it's whispering into my ears gently. I love the waves and the gentleness of the track. It's calm and collect which complement the vocals. There's lots to listen to, but it doesn't overpower my ears to take away from the centerpiece vocals. Very good track.
At 12/14/11 02:51 AM, ModuleMusic wrote:
Would love some outside opinion on the song itself and mix :)
Nice, I like when remix start of with the original so I can compare the two. I like the touch of Navi in the background. The track has a very focused touch to it. The build up was a little odd, I've never really heard it go up and down. I like how the tracks original identity is still intact in the track. My complaint is that the bass is very drowned, and dubstep being a bass driven genre, I think the bass should get more justice.
At 12/18/11 10:37 AM, DdottodD wrote:
SONG! Can someone please review this?!
The piano is very strong and piercing. It overpowers a lot of the instruments. The bass has a nice growl to it, and the melody sounds nice over top of it. I like the synth break, the drums come back in nicely and cleanly. The bass is kind of repetitive but the melody covers it and makes the track sound nice. My only suggestion would be to add more flavour and variety.
At 12/21/11 02:24 AM, Herdunculus wrote:
Hey! I've finally started working on making another track again, and this time, I would like someone other than me, who has listened to the same thing over and over, to hear it and give me feedback.
The the staccato synths sound a little weird to me at least. The bass sounds nice, kind of a mix between talking and growling. The end was very abrupt, i'm not sure if that was just for the WIP or not though. Good track, very refined.
At 12/21/11 02:56 PM, ModsSukCock wrote:
Kirby super star- save theme
This is a wip that I need help with.
Very repetitive, I have a feeling you gave up on adding the little extras to the song. However the base song sounds nice and very true to the original. It just needs a bit more effort and it could be great.
And that's it! Merry Christmas Audio forum. I didn't realize how many talented people I never heard of there were. But it goes to show that I didn't look aha. Probably the longest post I've ever made, but it was for the good of the musicians! Good luck to the final projects of all these people!