So, tomorrow, I have $60 bucks, so I'm going to buy either Halo 3, The Orange Box, or Bioshock for the Xbox 360. They're all great games, and all first person shooters (my favorite genre), but which one does Newgrounds think would be the better choice?

What are you looking for in the game?

The Orange Box or Bioshock.

I'd go with Orange Box on the PC.

Personally, I'd go with the Orange Box, simply because it nets you a total of four games, as opposed to getting only one with the other two choices.

IMO Bioshock was a waste of 60$ for me, Halo3 is good, but only for multiplayer, orange box is 5 games in 1 though.

Halo 3 is the best for Live play. If you want single player action, go for Bioshock. If you want a little bit of both, go for the Orange Box. Trust me, I have all of them.

Hands down Orange Box.

i didnt even know that the orange box was out yet...is it for ps3???

Three great titles. Bioshock was great, but way too simple. Half Life was good, and might even stand a chance against Halo. But when it comes down to full popularity, Halo takes the title. All of them are great, though most original was Bioshock. But you have to remeber, those aren't the only great shoot em up/ action games that we should think about.

At 10/16/07 09:26 PM, Twone wrote: Halo 3 is the best for Live play. If you want single player action, go for Bioshock. If you want a little bit of both, go for the Orange Box. Trust me, I have all of them.

Sounds reasonable. On another note, I'm a fan of both Halo and Half-Life (although I think Half-Life is better), although I've already beaten Hl2, and I don't have Xbox Live.

Orabge box. I'm crying myself to sleep at night until I have enough money to buy it.

Orange box no competition halo 3 is only good for mutiplayer and bioshock sucks to me

Be an American and buy all three of them. Triple the fun.

At 10/16/07 09:30 PM, CapnCrunchDaPimp wrote:

Sounds reasonable. On another note, I'm a fan of both Halo and Half-Life (although I think Half-Life is better), although I've already beaten Hl2, and I don't have Xbox Live.

Definitely get orange box then.

Halo 3. Bioshock didnt get a very good rating

Erm... I'd have to go with Halo 3.

At 10/16/07 09:29 PM, KAG8893 wrote: i didnt even know that the orange box was out yet...is it for ps3???

omfg.... go kill yourself

Orange box come with the best fps ever made Half life 2 and its expansions (biased opininion I know) Portal, and one of the best Multiplayer games ever made (Team Fortress 2)

It out on PC and 360 now, PS3 later (it will be crap though the port is done by EA)

I highly reccomend you get it for PC because it costs less, you don't have to pay for online, and you can have more players in TF2. Also I hear the xbox version has lag issues.

So yeah get Orange box, 5 games in all

Half life 2 - Great fps, if you think otherwise you play too much halo.
Half life 2 Episode 1
HL2 Ep2
Team fortress 2 - Really awesome multiplayer shooter, I stopped playing Halo 3 because of it.
Portal - Neat little First person puzzle game

Halo 3 for online play with other people

BioShock for AMAZING story and replay value

Orange Box if you want to try something completely different and unique

Get halo 3, everyone's on it on friend list on live, that's the only reason why I bought it.

At 10/16/07 09:30 PM, CapnCrunchDaPimp wrote: Sounds reasonable. On another note, I'm a fan of both Halo and Half-Life (although I think Half-Life is better), although I've already beaten Hl2, and I don't have Xbox Live.

If you aren't getting live any time soon, you should go for Bioshock. Unless you want to see the ending of Halo 3.

At 10/16/07 09:31 PM, cheesehead12 wrote: Halo 3. Bioshock didnt get a very good rating

Wait, are you kidding? It got 10/10 in a million magazines and websites!

Playing Live go for Halo 3(can play with the NG crew,yeye). If not go for Bioshock. I think The Orange Box will be easier to find used then Bioshock.

Orange.

At 10/16/07 09:36 PM, MetalDart wrote: Halo 3 for online play with other people

BioShock for AMAZING story and replay value

Orange Box if you want to try something completely different and unique

Go with what he said.
If I had to chose I would pick Orange Box. You get so many great games for so little, and it will keep you entertained for a long time.

At 10/16/07 09:30 PM, CapnCrunchDaPimp wrote:

Sounds reasonable. On another note, I'm a fan of both Halo and Half-Life (although I think Half-Life is better), although I've already beaten Hl2, and I don't have Xbox Live.

Orange box For pc, so you can play online.

At 10/16/07 09:30 PM, CapnCrunchDaPimp wrote:

At 10/16/07 09:26 PM, Twone wrote: Halo 3 is the best for Live play. If you want single player action, go for Bioshock. If you want a little bit of both, go for the Orange Box. Trust me, I have all of them.

Sounds reasonable. On another note, I'm a fan of both Halo and Half-Life (although I think Half-Life is better), although I've already beaten Hl2, and I don't have Xbox Live.

The Orange Box is your best bet then, because there are 4 single player games in there (HL2, HL2: EP1 and EP2, and Portal.)

Bioshock - Good Points - Great story , amazing graphics and incredible gameplay and choice
Bad Points - Quite short , endings are sort of disappointing , No Online multiplayer or co-op

Orange Box - Good Points - 5 AMAZING GAMES , team fortress keeps you coming back
- Bad Points - Portal is extremely short , half life 2 sometimes glitches a lot.

Halo 3 - Good Points - Excellent ending to finish the fight , xbox live co-op , and the amazing online play
- Bad Points - Short campaign mode , a lot of faggots on xbox live

Orange Box, you get a bunch of games in one package.

Halo 3 - only mildly entertaining online.

Bioshock - boring.

Orange box = yes.