Tom, you know I've been a fan for a long time. I love the site, I admire you guys, we ate $7 sandwiches. The design is awesome, I love the subtle color changes, the rounded edges. It makes the site a little softer on the eyes without taking away the "hardcore" image. Pico popping out behind the "NG Features" draws you there so you don't miss it.
However, the code is crappy. I can't even tell what version of HTML it is. There's no DOCTYPE or meta data. There's too many nested tables. There's invalid HTML code (like FONT and EMBED tags). Linking to an external style sheet and cutting down on some of the code can save download time for users.
To sum it up? Look = good. Code = bad.