At 8/4/07 01:56 PM, Raguel wrote:
Again, I don't even get a mention :(
Any chance on some criticism of my Atma weapon on page 9 Stamper?
I only ask because I honestly thought that I was in with a chance of at least a T-shirt for that one.
Don't worry, I read your following message too.
Your submission was good, the attention to detail was accurate, but unfortunately in translating to hi-def you missed some of the original details from the sprite you were embellishing upon. It seemed more like a traced reinterpretation (I know that sounds bad but I'm only trying to give what you did a name) than it did an all-out redefining of what was already there. Maybe your only fault was in picking a complicated sprite, because I did like the end result of your efforts. I guess what was missing outweighed what was there?
Like I'm one to talk. My submission was practically invented, but I guess the guys weren't REQUIRING entries to be 'traced' as it were. Har har.