Maybe stolen stuff

[Deflektor]

Here's the stuff :

Here's a song made by RoboX, Silence Road:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/view.php?id=1 696327&sub=65517

And here's a song made by Dj-Rec0il, the Journey of Life:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/view.php?id=7 43162&sub=64499

I may be mistaken, but i do think there is something fishy in one of these song.

[GhostmanPat]

At 2/6/07 05:25 PM, Deflektor wrote: Here's the stuff :

Here's a song made by RoboX, Silence Road:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/view.php?id=1 696327&sub=65517

And here's a song made by Dj-Rec0il, the Journey of Life:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/view.php?id=7 43162&sub=64499

I may be mistaken, but i do think there is something fishy in one of these song.

I hear nothing in them that would suggest that they are stolen, both ok tracks really.

[Deflektor]

Oh, well. I should have stated that the stolen stuff is just in ONE part. Not a whole song.
Listen again.

[Khuskan]

At 2/6/07 06:03 PM, Deflektor wrote: Oh, well. I should have stated that the stolen stuff is just in ONE part. Not a whole song.
Listen again.

Times would help.

[Stealth-Emergence]

well, maybe looking at the waveforms for them and comparing them that way might help, I had a listen to them and couldn't hear much of a similarity

[Deflektor]

At 2/6/07 06:05 PM, Khuskan wrote:

At 2/6/07 06:03 PM, Deflektor wrote: Oh, well. I should have stated that the stolen stuff is just in ONE part. Not a whole song.
Listen again.

Times would help.

Well, listen to RoboX. You hear that sound, the main sound, at the beginning.
In Recoil's, there is also that sound AND the exact notes. Only the effect has been changed. At the beginning too.

[Khuskan]

At 2/6/07 06:11 PM, Deflektor wrote: Well, listen to RoboX. You hear that sound, the main sound, at the beginning.
In Recoil's, there is also that sound AND the exact notes. Only the effect has been changed. At the beginning too.

Sounds to me like E-jay or something of similar usage.

Not technically stolen, but still pretty fucking cheap. I'm basing this off the notes being the same but the tempo not, also the 'silence road' track with the comment 'this took me about 20-30 minutes' which to be fair, to produce something like that (even though it isn't -that- great) was way too quick.

[bladerunner627]

There seriously needs to be a rule so that people can't just submit shit made in Ejay. It makes alot of us hard working producers look like shit sometimes. Music isn't about slapping a bunch of pre-fabricated loops together.

I HATE THAT SHIT!

[Blizzard7]

Wow. They are REALLY similar. I only seem to recognize that they used the same melody for the beginning.

[TheAmateurAnimator]

Don't forget this fucker.
Sometimes he outright steals, sometimes he puts in crappy effects on a pre-existing song and calls it his own. I already PMed Denvish about him, now flag his stolen audio while it's hot!

Blow My Whistle Baby!

[Spikrodd]

this has been debated previously...

the notes do sound the same, but that does not mean that it is stolen.

[Striker028]

At 2/6/07 08:56 PM, TheAmateurAnimator wrote: Don't forget this fucker.
Sometimes he outright steals, sometimes he puts in crappy effects on a pre-existing song and calls it his own. I already PMed Denvish about him, now flag his stolen audio while it's hot!

Blow My Whistle Baby!

funny how he steals stuff and still gets very few downloads

remember though, with the infinite amount of songs out there, it's hard not to accidentally get some identical notes sometimes. plus, sometimes you use something you've already heard unconsciously, maybe it's not exactly right but it's not intentional either. isn't the majority of his song original anyway?

[Deflektor]

Well, ok, then. Let's close this topic. Let's say it's pure coincidence (after all, that's why i said MAYBE stolen). Mods, do your job!