Forum Topic: Cats have 3 Tails

(734 views • 35 replies)

This topic is 2 pages long. [ 1 | 2 ]

<< < > >>
Angry

Dry-Ice

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:00 PM

Dry-Ice LIGHT LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 04/09/03

Posts: 9,481

Here you go - Riddle me this:

No cat as 2 tails, right?
A cat has 1 more tail than no cat, right?

Therefore, A cat has 3 tails

BBS Rules, Clarified.
Forum Moderator. Abuse on the BBS? PM me.

BBS Signature

None

HotActionYiffFur

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:00 PM

HotActionYiffFur LIGHT LEVEL 02

Sign-Up: 09/08/05

Posts: 11,779

My brain hurts :[

°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°
8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8 °8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°8°
8°8°8°8

BBS Signature

None

Faille

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:01 PM

Faille NEUTRAL LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 02/06/04

Posts: 5,684

Thats flawed, there must be some cats with two tails

Just here to pass the time :)
http://www.faille.deviantart.com

BBS Signature

None

Ben

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:03 PM

Ben DARK LEVEL 13

Sign-Up: 12/02/04

Posts: 8,115

At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote:
No cat as 2 tails, right?

LIAR

Minds shall break and bring a clear sky.

BBS Signature

None

ShadyReptile

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:08 PM

ShadyReptile NEUTRAL LEVEL 15

Sign-Up: 01/30/05

Posts: 377

At 9/21/06 05:03 PM, Ben wrote:
At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote:
No cat as 2 tails, right?
LIAR

aha! I knew it had to be true!


None

Dry-Ice

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:09 PM

Dry-Ice LIGHT LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 04/09/03

Posts: 9,481

Fuckin' hell, I wasn't expecting that.

Okay let's just rephrase it then -

No Human has 2 hearts, right?
A Human has 1 more heart than no human, right?

Therefore Humans have 3 Hearts.

Riddle me that.

BBS Rules, Clarified.
Forum Moderator. Abuse on the BBS? PM me.

BBS Signature

None

Lucy

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:12 PM

Lucy FAB LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 05/09/05

Posts: 8,742

I'm confused. But, I think I get it.

Does the person create the journey; or the journey create the person...

BBS Signature

None

Dry-Ice

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:16 PM

Dry-Ice LIGHT LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 04/09/03

Posts: 9,481

At 9/21/06 05:12 PM, Lucy wrote: I'm confused. But, I think I get it.

Care to explain?

Come on people, it's not that difficult, just find the flaw in the logic!

BBS Rules, Clarified.
Forum Moderator. Abuse on the BBS? PM me.

BBS Signature

None

Light80

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:17 PM

Light80 FAB LEVEL 15

Sign-Up: 02/21/06

Posts: 464


None

Folio1

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:19 PM

Folio1 FAB LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 06/05/05

Posts: 235

At 9/21/06 05:03 PM, Ben wrote:
At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote:
No cat as 2 tails, right?
LIAR

i want one now

a fat one

None

Paradox

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:20 PM

Paradox LIGHT LEVEL 29

Sign-Up: 01/28/06

Posts: 9,852

At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote: Here you go - Riddle me this:

All it takes is a little re-phrasing:

There isn't a cat with two tails.
A cat has one more tail than a non-existent cat.


None

I-Skot-I

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:21 PM

I-Skot-I NEUTRAL LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 10/30/05

Posts: 550

At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote: Here you go - Riddle me this:

No cat as 2 tails, right?
A cat has 1 more tail than no cat, right?

Therefore, A cat has 3 tails

What?!?!?!?!?!?!

This man is a genius!

None

Dry-Ice

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:24 PM

Dry-Ice LIGHT LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 04/09/03

Posts: 9,481

At 9/21/06 05:20 PM, Paradox wrote:
At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote: Here you go - Riddle me this:
All it takes is a little re-phrasing:

There isn't a cat with two tails.
A cat has one more tail than a non-existent cat.

Well done.

Look at it this way -

NO CAT has 2 tails
One cat has One more tail than NO CAT

Basically, the words 'No Cat' on the second line are ambiguous in the way that I could just be implying that 'No Cat' is the name of a cat with 2 tails.

BBS Rules, Clarified.
Forum Moderator. Abuse on the BBS? PM me.

BBS Signature

None

Paradox

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:25 PM

Paradox LIGHT LEVEL 29

Sign-Up: 01/28/06

Posts: 9,852

At 9/21/06 05:24 PM, Dry-Ice wrote: Basically, the words 'No Cat' on the second line are ambiguous in the way that I could just be implying that 'No Cat' is the name of a cat with 2 tails.

It's just a mind-trick really, "no cat" could be used in a lot of situations.


None

deadlock32

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:27 PM

deadlock32 NEUTRAL LEVEL 18

Sign-Up: 04/28/01

Posts: 2,496

At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote: Here you go - Riddle me this:

No cat as 2 tails, right?
A cat has 1 more tail than no cat, right?

Therefore, A cat has 3 tails

A cat has 1 more tail than no cat.

no cat = 0 tail
1+0 = 1
A cat = 1 tail.

and to check.
Cat tail != 2
A cat = 1 tail
1 tail != 2 tail


Angry

LolSatan

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:28 PM

LolSatan EVIL LEVEL 06

Sign-Up: 11/12/05

Posts: 734

Go pick up a cat, then tell me how many tails it has.


None

Black-Flame

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:28 PM

Black-Flame LIGHT LEVEL 35

Sign-Up: 12/13/05

Posts: 5,816

He said that cats dont have 2 tails, it doesnt matter how many it has altogether aslong as its not 2.

Gamertag: BlackFlameNG Xbox 360 Club
Gamerscore: 25,275- last updated 23/February/09
Steam ID: BlackFlameNG

BBS Signature

None

deadlock32

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:29 PM

deadlock32 NEUTRAL LEVEL 18

Sign-Up: 04/28/01

Posts: 2,496

At 9/21/06 05:27 PM, Deadlock32 wrote:
At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote: Here you go - Riddle me this:

No cat as 2 tails, right?
A cat has 1 more tail than no cat, right?

Therefore, A cat has 3 tails
A cat has 1 more tail than no cat.

no cat = 0 tail
1+0 = 1
A cat = 1 tail.

and to check.
Cat tail != 2
A cat = 1 tail
1 tail != 2 tail

and to clarify

the initial statement is
!(cat = 2 tail)
or 'no' cat = 2 tail
aka cats do not have 2 tails

(even though they can in real life)


None

Black-Flame

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:30 PM

Black-Flame LIGHT LEVEL 35

Sign-Up: 12/13/05

Posts: 5,816

At 9/21/06 05:24 PM, Dry-Ice wrote:
At 9/21/06 05:20 PM, Paradox wrote:
At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote:
NO CAT has 2 tails
One cat has One more tail than NO CAT

Basically, the words 'No Cat' on the second line are ambiguous in the way that I could just be implying that 'No Cat' is the name of a cat with 2 tails.

Damnit!

Gamertag: BlackFlameNG Xbox 360 Club
Gamerscore: 25,275- last updated 23/February/09
Steam ID: BlackFlameNG

BBS Signature

None

Dry-lce

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:30 PM

Dry-lce LIGHT LEVEL 02

Sign-Up: 01/18/06

Posts: 241

At 9/21/06 05:27 PM, Deadlock32 wrote: 1. No cat as 2 tails, right?
2. A cat has 1 more tail than no cat, right?
A cat has 1 more tail than no cat.
no cat = 0 tail
1+0 = 1
A cat = 1 tail.

Wrong. You said "no cat = 0 tail" where in the first line of my text it clearly says "No cat has 2 tails".


None

Edd360

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:31 PM

Edd360 EVIL LEVEL 28

Sign-Up: 02/07/05

Posts: 1,988

I understand, but i cant explain it :s

BBS Signature

None

amoeba-man

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:31 PM

amoeba-man LIGHT LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 12/17/05

Posts: 839

Here's one:
A Hamburger > Nothing
Nothing > Steak
Therefore
A Hamburger > Steak

(Hamburger > Nothing > Steak)


None

kLyy

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:31 PM

kLyy EVIL LEVEL 26

Sign-Up: 05/16/06

Posts: 1,264

oh jeez i'm confused.
What kinda cat are you talking about
- drifts off in a daydream-
* Comes back*
oh jeez,


None

elkrobber

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:33 PM

elkrobber LIGHT LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 06/15/04

Posts: 4,675

At 9/21/06 05:09 PM, Dry-Ice wrote:
No Human has 2 hearts, right?
A Human has 1 more heart than no human, right?

Therefore Humans have 3 Hearts.

And so 1 heart plus no hearts equals 1 heart. Not three.


None

deadlock32

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:34 PM

deadlock32 NEUTRAL LEVEL 18

Sign-Up: 04/28/01

Posts: 2,496

At 9/21/06 05:00 PM, Dry-Ice wrote: Here you go - Riddle me this:

No cat as 2 tails, right?
A cat has 1 more tail than no cat, right?

Therefore, A cat has 3 tails

oh an finally

No_cat != an animal cat

subbing out every thing with vars

!x = 2
x = !x + 1
x = 3

Cat can be used in to replace X and tail can be used to replace Numbers, but Cat doesnt have to represent an animal in your senerio.


None

Dry-lce

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:35 PM

Dry-lce LIGHT LEVEL 02

Sign-Up: 01/18/06

Posts: 241

At 9/21/06 05:33 PM, elkrobber wrote: And so 1 heart plus no hearts equals 1 heart. Not three.

I didn't say '1 heart plus no hearts'.
Read the top line.


None

Ben

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:37 PM

Ben DARK LEVEL 13

Sign-Up: 12/02/04

Posts: 8,115

Your mother has 2 Breasts,
A woman who has had mastectomy has 1 more breast than no woman right?

Therefor I slept with your mother.

Minds shall break and bring a clear sky.

BBS Signature

None

Dry-Ice

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:42 PM

Dry-Ice LIGHT LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 04/09/03

Posts: 9,481

At 9/21/06 05:37 PM, Ben wrote: Your mother has 2 Breasts,
A woman who has had mastectomy has 1 more breast than no woman right?

Therefor I slept with your mother.

Rofl, win.

BBS Rules, Clarified.
Forum Moderator. Abuse on the BBS? PM me.

BBS Signature

None

elkrobber

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:42 PM

elkrobber LIGHT LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 06/15/04

Posts: 4,675

At 9/21/06 05:35 PM, Dry-lce wrote:
At 9/21/06 05:33 PM, elkrobber wrote: And so 1 heart plus no hearts equals 1 heart. Not three.
I didn't say '1 heart plus no hearts'.
Read the top line.

Sure, I don't know the answer to the laterally thinking way, but it isn't an incorrect answer as such, it's just a different one.


None

Dry-Ice

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 9/21/06 05:44 PM

Dry-Ice LIGHT LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 04/09/03

Posts: 9,481

At 9/21/06 05:42 PM, elkrobber wrote: Sure, I don't know the answer to the laterally thinking way, but it isn't an incorrect answer as such, it's just a different one.

Don't worry, it's formed on a bunch of dodgy premises anyway, it's just a cute little logic trap I picked up in Critical Thinking.

BBS Rules, Clarified.
Forum Moderator. Abuse on the BBS? PM me.

BBS Signature

All times are Eastern Standard Time (GMT -5) | Current Time: 05:14 PM

<< Back

This topic is 2 pages long. [ 1 | 2 ]

<< < > >>
You need a Grounds Gold Account to post on the NG BBS! If you don't have one, click here to sign up now! It's fast, free, and easy — and opens up tons of great NG features!