Well, I kinda see your point even though I'm a HUGE fan. I can understand why you and some others don't like them, but some of us have a liking for that kind of thing. I am also a guitarist, so I know where you come from, but I really like Herman's guitar playing, it may be just a fast flurry of fucking fast notes (now that was fun wasnt it) to some people, but some of us understand it, or try to understand it.
Sam Totman, the rythm guitarist I could see less people liking, because he doesn't stand out as much as lead, but I don't think you should bring him into this, because the music would be much worse without him, or if he were playing exactly like Herman.
As for your comments aout being out of key or in the wrong scale, who the hell cares, is it written that music can only be played one way and can't be changed.
Your comments on the singer, well I have the same argument as above for the key comment, but as for your comments on his singing not being too good... I like it, it's melodic, not just screaming or grunting like some of these bands like C. of a Bodom or whatever the hell else crappy metal bands are out there now.
Bass, well it isn't a big part of the music, I think mainly because the bassist is almost always only temorary, personally I don't think the music needs to be any more bassy.
Ok, now here's the part where I agree with you 100%, the drummer, I don't like the fast double pedal stuff all the time, it would be ok if he changed it up a bit, but he has the exact same sound every song, so there I agree.
To end this discussion, I'd like to say that I completely understand you opinion, but can you understand mine, without agreeing to it? Here's another question, what is better Dragonforce or Tupac or 50 Cent? Obviously we all have our own opinions on what good music is, my favorite bands are Van Halen, Steve Vai, Buckethead, and Dragonforce, but that doesn't mean my picks are better than yours, just bare with it, Dragonforce will probably only be a fad, and the true fans will continue to like them, but others will eventually forget, and people like you will have a new band to bitch about, and hey I might be with you next time, but just for the time being, drop the topic, you can't change most peoples opinions, only the weakminded ones, anyway, HOLY RUN-ON SENTENCE BATMAN!