I got Black Clouds & Silver Linings on Monday. I would have posted my thoughts then, but I thought the album needed a chance before giving a final verdict. I'm on my 8th listen through the whole album (i.e. 3CD special) and what are my thoughts on it?
The main disc: It's another good album from Dream Theater, but there are some flaws. Firstly, as great as The Shattered Fortress is, couldn't they have added more new material and less recycling from their previous AA tracks? I don't mind them reusing material from them, but the problem is it covered around 75% of the whole track.
Another thing I wasn't too fond of was the placing of the mellow part in The Count of Tuscany. To me, it seemed more of something you'd play at the start of the track rather than in the middle of it. Maybe I'll eventually adapt to this? Despite that, it's still a good song.
As for my last complaint, maybe it's just me but I felt three of the tracks in this album sounded like album closing tracks. The endings to A Nightmare to Remember, The Shattered Fortress and of course, the actual album closer The Count of Tuscany all seemed like album closing tracks. o_O
Second disc: All good covers, even the two tracks I wasn't familiar with. The choices of covered tracks were pretty original, most especially how out of all the Queen songs they chose an overlooked medley from Sheer Heart Attack.
Third disc: The album without James LaBrie, but this bonus disc was an interesting "What if the whole album was instrumental?" thought. I thought the best track as an instrumental was The Shattered Fortress.