Forum Topic: Review Request Club

(109,263 views • 6,552 replies)

New Topic Post Reply

This topic is 219 pages long. [ 1107213 | 214 | 215 | 216 | 217 | 218 | 219 ]

<< < > >>
None

amador10

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/30/09 09:39 AM

amador10 DARK LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 02/26/07

Posts: 297

Can you give some critique to one of my works?

BBS Signature

None

Sawdust

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/30/09 11:24 AM

Sawdust FAB LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 03/09/07

Posts: 7,469

A piece to review

Baby can't you see, you belong with me

BBS Signature

None

XwaynecoltX

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/30/09 04:11 PM

XwaynecoltX EVIL LEVEL 43

Sign-Up: 01/17/01

Posts: 17,645

At 3/29/09 10:49 PM, tomocles wrote: I know that I did get 39 reviews, but will anyone here give more advanced critique of my tutorials? If you arent good at that, another review would be fine, too. :P
http://www.newgrounds.com/portal/view/47 8487

I think i could work one in.

~X~

[~X~ ~X~ ~X~] They Call me ~X~
[Request a Review] << Request a review and i will be glad to review it

BBS Signature

None

tomocles

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/30/09 06:34 PM

tomocles DARK LEVEL 04

Sign-Up: 12/02/08

Posts: 191

thanks, I appreciate it. :)

To keep up to date on The Blood Throne, just contact me through pm or email!

BBS Signature

Elated

Apeirophobiac

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/30/09 09:02 PM

Apeirophobiac DARK LEVEL 04

Sign-Up: 01/29/09

Posts: 12

I feel bad about shoving more work on you guys, so just a thumbs up or thumbs down will suffice. I just am proud of this piece (as short as it is) and want it to be noticed for once. Thanks in advance!


Happy

BiPass

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/31/09 07:03 PM

BiPass NEUTRAL LEVEL 01

Sign-Up: 03/29/09

Posts: 1

We need some reviews, this is our first collab track on this account, and right now we aren't receiving a lot reviews right now.

So any constructive criticism or just some good thoughts about it are totally acceptable. Take your time.


None

ForNoReason

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/2/09 11:34 AM

ForNoReason LIGHT LEVEL 24

Sign-Up: 06/01/03

Posts: 5,458

CLUB INFO
...............................

General Rules for Requesters:
If you are planning on requesting reviews, please:
- Post a direct link to the submission(s) you want reviewed.
- Make no more than 3 requests within one week.
- Do us a favour and respond to our reviews.
- Be patient. Due to the points system, you may not see reviews until up to two weeks after you request.
- Do NOT request without posting a link.
- Do NOT just say "Review everything" or just link to your profile.
- Do NOT request reviews for the same submission more than once.

General Rules for New Reviewers:
If you are planning on completing requests, please do the following:
- Post in this thread to let us know you'd like to join.
- Understand the points system and keep track of your own score. You will only be added to the list if you post your own score within the first week.

Points:
**Please also keep track of your own points. If you see something missing, it's probably a mistake**
**To be on the list, you must make at least one review, posters only will not be counted**

5 points for a review on a requested movie/game
7 points for a review on a requested audio
+1 point for putting "Review Request Club" at the bottom of a requested review
3 points for posting at least once throughout the week
5 points for referring a new member (must mention you in first post)
7 points for reviewing all requests/recommendations for that week

Club updates
Each Sunday or Monday, Shanus or Haggard currently create a list of all the members, counting up their points, calculating various stats and posting a list of requested submissions. Assuming you review the submissions listed, you will get points for them on the following members' update, 6 or 7 days later.

On Thursday, perfect-insanity creates a list of all requests and recommendations made since the previous Thursday. This can be considered a 'preview' of the list that will accompany the following members' update on Sunday/Monday. The points for these are tallied 10 days later.

Requests made between the 'preview list' and the 'members' update' carry over to the next preview list. So you will always have over 9 days to finish the reviews. (Feel free to review submissions as soon as they are requested!)

FAQ
Should I link to the club in my sig?
There's no obligation to do so, but it's certainly appreciated. Remember that you can put a high number in place of the page number in the url and if that page doesn't exist yet, NG will take you to the latest page, whatever it is.

So if you link to: http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic/4834 48/999
then anyone following that link will always see the latest page.

I don't understand what recommendations are all about!
As mentioned under this section in each list, 'You may make a recommendation if you reviewed 100% of the previous weeks requests and recommendations. It should be over 3 days old and have under 50 reviews.'

As long as your name is on the last 'All requests completed' list, feel free to recommend something you've enjoyed from the portal.

You could use this to let us know about something you think is specially awesome, yet overlooked. If there aren't many game or movie requests, maybe you could make a recommendation so we have something to review.

Does the Review Request Club review stuff for non-NG stuff?
Short answer: no.

Long answer: Milinko used to include youtube requests in the list of requests, but the introduction of a points system didn't leave room for such things. You can request reviews here, but some of us may not have accounts on Myspace/Youtube/whatever or may simply be disinclined to review things outside NG. It wouldn't get nearly as much attention compared to if it were a NG submission.

I'd suggest putting songs on the AP, then making a request that way. It lets us give feedback whilst staying on our favourite site. ;-)

...............................

If a new page hase begun and this info has not been posted yet, please copy the plaintext version and post it, thus keeping this info at the top of each page.


Happy

ixintro

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/2/09 03:13 PM

ixintro EVIL LEVEL 22

Sign-Up: 12/30/06

Posts: 2,192

Hey guys, glad to finally have an oppurtunity to come back here! Could you guys review this?

Thanks.

Thanks for already getting to it Corky!
BBS Signature

None

XwaynecoltX

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/2/09 09:51 PM

XwaynecoltX EVIL LEVEL 43

Sign-Up: 01/17/01

Posts: 17,645

At 3/31/09 07:03 PM, BiPass wrote: So any constructive criticism or just some good thoughts about it are totally acceptable. Take your time.

I will get to this tonight.

~X~

[~X~ ~X~ ~X~] They Call me ~X~
[Request a Review] << Request a review and i will be glad to review it

BBS Signature

None

The-Great-One

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 05:49 AM

The-Great-One DARK LEVEL 26

Sign-Up: 09/02/06

Posts: 5,348

At 5/11/06 09:00 PM, Guitardude wrote: This seems like a pretty cool idea. I'd like to join.

As for requests, you can rate my last flash movie.

http://newgrounds.com/portal/view/244328

Please keep in mind that it's my first flash.

I too reviewed it a long time ago. Never got a response.


None

Cooliam

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 08:01 AM

Cooliam FAB LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 05/05/08

Posts: 278

could u review thisplease, thanks

Woo yeah bring it on sucka

BBS Signature

None

DJ-Tonic

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 08:49 AM

DJ-Tonic NEUTRAL LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 06/20/08

Posts: 110

Hey guys, I uploaded this a little while ago. Could I get a review?

Much appreciated!

BBS Signature

Elated

FunkmasterCatking

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 02:46 PM

FunkmasterCatking LIGHT LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 09/03/07

Posts: 187


None

SimCorder

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 07:52 PM

SimCorder NEUTRAL LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 09/30/07

Posts: 404

Can anyone here give me some advice on being a good critic? I want to be able to give a low score without it being useless or abusive


None

InnerChild548

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 10:12 PM

InnerChild548 FAB LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 08/10/07

Posts: 2,489

At 4/4/09 07:52 PM, SimCorder wrote: Can anyone here give me some advice on being a good critic? I want to be able to give a low score without it being useless or abusive

Always includes the negative and the positive: Tell the creator what was bad, then tell them how they can improve. Remind them of what they did good to encourage them.

You also can create sections like this:
For Games

~Concept~
~Coding~
~Graphics~
~Sound~
~Other~

For Movies

~Animation~
~Art~
~Plot~
~Sound~
~Other~

See quality examples of top-notch reviewers such as AnalPenguinFarming or Corky52.

THIS IS THE ORIGINAL SIG. FUCK YOU.
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv

BBS Signature

None

InnerChild548

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 10:14 PM

InnerChild548 FAB LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 08/10/07

Posts: 2,489

At 4/4/09 07:52 PM, SimCorder wrote: Can anyone here give me some advice on being a good critic? I want to be able to give a low score without it being useless or abusive

I'm sorry, to make it easier, just check out Corky52's Guide to Writing Helpful Reviews. It's an excellent tutorial.

THIS IS THE ORIGINAL SIG. FUCK YOU.
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv

BBS Signature

None

Sealander

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/4/09 10:34 PM

Sealander DARK LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 12/17/08

Posts: 1,029

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/2 26874

I am not a really popular guy here on newgrounds, and I think I make pretty good stuff with fl, others think that as well. Since there are 0 voters attracted to my page, I don't get a lot of reviews, or that much attention.

Please review. It would really help =)

Any kind of constructive criticism is good.


None

Flash-MX

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/5/09 12:51 AM

Flash-MX EVIL LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 10/08/05

Posts: 157

Review club whooo!

If you could, please resucitate my track lol

i spent so much time making it and i get like 3 votes and no reviews...
such justice :(

thanks in advance!!!


None

Bob-Music

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/6/09 07:59 AM

Bob-Music LIGHT LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 06/14/08

Posts: 32

Could you please review my latest submission?

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/2 27127

Thank you


None

Cooliam

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/6/09 10:47 AM

Cooliam FAB LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 05/05/08

Posts: 278

can u review this also please

Woo yeah bring it on sucka

BBS Signature

None

LightKeeper

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/6/09 01:22 PM

LightKeeper NEUTRAL LEVEL 11

Sign-Up: 12/05/08

Posts: 180

Newest song: Empire Resurrection

Take a look and leave a review, it's like a Classical song mixed with DNB elements.


Elated

Imacow

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/6/09 11:00 PM

Imacow NEUTRAL LEVEL 25

Sign-Up: 05/04/06

Posts: 4,459

Hey guys, whats up?

So I've been thinking of finally rejoining this fine establishment after my "break".

So count on me sitting down and getting some reviews done tomorrow :D

BBS Signature

None

InnerChild548

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/7/09 04:57 PM

InnerChild548 FAB LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 08/10/07

Posts: 2,489

At 4/6/09 10:47 AM, Cooliam wrote: can u review this also please

Ah, look who it is.

This should be fun >:)

THIS IS THE ORIGINAL SIG. FUCK YOU.
vvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvvv

BBS Signature

None

Jeffaro

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/7/09 10:27 PM

Jeffaro EVIL LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 10/14/05

Posts: 1,910

Hey..

Me and Twilightnecrosis have collaborated.We covered a Death song called Pull the plug.

You can check out our cover here.


None

Cooliam

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/8/09 04:28 AM

Cooliam FAB LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 05/05/08

Posts: 278

At 4/7/09 04:57 PM, InnerChild548 wrote:
At 4/6/09 10:47 AM, Cooliam wrote: can u review this also please
Ah, look who it is.

This should be fun >:)

won't it just, its not even mine

Woo yeah bring it on sucka

BBS Signature

None

SymbolCymbal

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/8/09 12:11 PM

SymbolCymbal FAB LEVEL 21

Sign-Up: 05/14/08

Posts: 4,130


Elated

FunkmasterCatking

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/8/09 04:56 PM

FunkmasterCatking LIGHT LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 09/03/07

Posts: 187


None

Pedochu

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/8/09 07:05 PM

Pedochu FAB LEVEL 02

Sign-Up: 05/15/07

Posts: 655

I would really like to join this club. I read the rules on the previous page and think I have an understanding of how everything works now. I really enjoy reviewing as well, and if needed, my signature is blank, so I can easily include a link.


Crying

Box-Killa

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/8/09 11:04 PM

Box-Killa LIGHT LEVEL 07

Sign-Up: 01/29/09

Posts: 505

can you review me can you can you can you???!!!


None

Nitr0gen

Reply to Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 4/9/09 12:09 PM

Nitr0gen NEUTRAL LEVEL 02

Sign-Up: 08/19/07

Posts: 20

This is a piece for my GCSE music integrated assignment. Everything is written, played and recorded by me. It had to fit the description of a pop song with changes of tempo and/or style. If i could get some feedback on it then that would be nice.

It starts as alternative pop, moves onto 90's grungy rock and ends with a slow outro.

it would be great if someone could review it


All times are Eastern Standard Time (GMT -5) | Current Time: 09:56 PM

<< Back

This topic is 219 pages long. [ 1107213 | 214 | 215 | 216 | 217 | 218 | 219 ]

<< < > >>
You need a Grounds Gold Account to post on the NG BBS! If you don't have one, click here to sign up now! It's fast, free, and easy — and opens up tons of great NG features!