Newgrounds.com — Everything, By Everyone.

I'm trying to get better at writing Dubstep and was going to ask whether anyone here who listens to dubstep would mind reviewing my music Speedy Bass. I could use all the help I can get with this so if you wouldn't mind reviewing I would be extremely happy.

review my song. It's R&B.

Hey Bez, whats the most amount of "Vacation Time" You'd be able to have?

At 3/22/08 06:04 PM, Imacow wrote: Hey Bez, whats the most amount of "Vacation Time" You'd be able to have?

It was just meant to be the discussion! I'm not exactly the top dog here...

What do YOU think is a reasonable max. length of vacation? I hadn't thought of that, so why not discuss?

Maybe there'd be a little stat to keep track of how many weeks you've been on holiday in your 'club lifetime', so to speak. Maybe after a holiday of X length you're just forced to start losing %? Or maybe if it's long enough, then people who're on holiday for longer than that are presumably not coming back so would be booted?

Actually, the latter's probably not a good idea...

Also, if the holiday system is accepted, maybe folk who've not reviewed in 2 weeks should be put on 'holiday' as presumably they're away and never mentioned it...

Oh and I just thought of another con to the whole idea:
- it makes the club rules more complicated. Is this bad? Too complicated? Complications distract from the focus - the reviewing

I could really use some constructive reviews for this audio i did. Thank you

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1 32190

I don't know if I'm supposed to ask to join or what.... seemed so at the beginning of the thread and then it all but disappeared on page 133 or whatever this is lol. Anyway, reviews on the following song would be greatly appreciated.

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1 29353

At 3/22/08 11:38 PM, CineGoryP wrote: I don't know if I'm supposed to ask to join or what.... seemed so at the beginning of the thread and then it all but disappeared on page 133 or whatever this is lol. Anyway, reviews on the following song would be greatly appreciated.

http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1 29353

You don't have to join, don't worry. Your submission will be reviewed next week though.

I'll try to finish all the requests tonight and tomorrow morning :D

Could I get some feedback on my Ode to ZZ Top, please?
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/1 31921

=)

People who give this song a review will forever be my heroes. :D

All reviews completed, just in time :)
Flash With RRC - 18
Spotlight Submission With RRC - 6
Audio With RRC - 48
1 Post - 3
All Reviews - 7
Total for this week - 82
All Time = 369
:Correct me if i'm wrong ^_^:

At 3/21/08 09:13 PM, Bezman wrote:

At 3/21/08 05:06 PM, Haggard wrote:

At 3/21/08 02:30 PM, mac2130 wrote: and and quick question, if im going to be away from my comp. for a while can i tell you i will not be able to participate and it wont count against me or is it just to bad and i lose a few percent?

I guess you have to to grin and bear it and lose a few percent. But don't let that discourage you. As you can see there are only 2 users in the top 10 with a 100% completion rate ;) . So don't worry if you miss one week of requests.

Though up until now you've had to just 'grin and bear it' I personally think a system for announcing an 'NG holiday' might be cool.

Given that the world is in a state of flux and stuff can always be changed, what do you guys think?

Might be cool, but personally I don't think it would work too well. I can see too many people just announcing a holiday so that they can keep their 100%, but in reality they just don't want to review for a few weeks or so...
Also, it's very hard work to keep the 100% for so long (I think Little-Rena will agree with me here ;) ) and the "holidays" would make this too easy. It's just like depositing Experience. It's quite hard sometimes to keep on depositing and not missing deposits and stuff like that... you can't just announce a holiday from depositing and keep your perfect exp this way ^^.

for this week
audio-30 flash-15 the signature and post in forum aproximatively =60 points

Sorry could'nt review more this week

Done.....

2 requests this week:

32 Changes by Jurian
Cm JazzlyJam by Jurian

6 tracks reviewed = 42
1 flash reviewed = 5
6 RRC Lines = 6
Posting here = 3
Total = 56 points

Sorry guys, I'm unable to review flash movies =/

I have a request for this week, even though I'm not very confident in it.

.:Failure of the Heart WIP:.

ive just been nosing in this thread for new tunes, and i was wondering,
anyone fancy reviewing these?

messpionage

dolphinrescuesquad!

these where the first songs i wrote on reason 4, they got lost for months due to making a changeover from mac to pc, and i found them today

all kinds a criticism welcome!

I just like to inform everyone that I did do the request this week, about a day and a half early this week. So I wasn't the last one to finish. And I'd really like to comment the quality of the stuff we're getting to review. It's excellent. Anyway, I'll comment on the list when it's out, till then :D

Ok, I have a feeling I may have missed some people's reviews, so make sure I didn't.

General Rules for New Reviewers
If you are planning on completing requests, please do the following:
-Post in this thread to let us know you plan on reviewing.
-Understand the points system and keep track of your own score. From now on, I will only add you to the list if you post your own score after the first week.

General Rules for Requesters
If you are planning on requesting review, please do the following:
-I will post no more than 3 requests from a single user in one week.
-Due to the points system, you may not see reviews until up to two weeks after you request.
-Post a direct link to the submission(s) you want reviewed.
-DO NOT request without putting a link, I don't have the time or patience to get the links myself.
-DO NOT say "Review everything" for the same reason above.
-DO NOT request the same submission more than once.
-Please do us a favor and respond to reviews if you request them.

Flash Requests:
Freddy by ShortMonkey
Presentation de La France by Hashnoerej
TV Rules the Nation by Jimtopia
Imagination Ep. 3 by VegetarianMeat

Audio Requests:
Melting Snow by SBB
Red Sunday by FullyClothedMike
Grand Chase by DragonsGrief
Three Little Worlds by IzofOz
Speedy Bass by Jimbobsthebest
The Street Life by AfroShine
Nightmare's by djconnect
Wicked Spiral CineGoryP
Bearded Gentlemen from Texas by OctaneVein
Solus- She by SolusLunes
32 Changes by Jurian
Cm JazzlyJam by Jurian
Failure of the Heart by GronmonSE
messpionage by spamwangler
Dolphin Resque Squad by spamwangler

Points:
**Please also keep track of your own points. If you see something missing, I probably made a mistake**
**To be on the list, you must make at least one review, posters only will not be counted**
5 points for a review on a requested movie/game
7 points for a review on a requested audio
+1 point for putting "Review Request Club" at the bottom of a requested review
3 points for posting at least once throughout the week
5 points for referring a new member (must mention you in first post)
7 points for reviewing all requests for that week

Points/Completion Rate/Weekly Completion/User
1. 3897 | 530/604 | 87.75% | 10/10 | Coop83
2. 3360 | 493/639 | 77.15% | 0/10 | milinko959
3. 2180 | 282/282 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Little-Rena
4. 1958 | 264/264 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Haggard
5. 1768 | 244/260 | 93.85% | 10/10 | Shanus
6. 1672 | 234/256 | 91.40% | 0/10 | NintendoMadness
7. 1433 | 203/644 | 31.52% | 0/10 | Bezman
8. 1222 | 172/636 | 27.04% | 0/10 | Imacow
9. 1190 | 185/209 | 88.52% | 0/10 | Cyberdevil
10. 971 | 130/154 | 84.42% | 0/9 | WritersBlock
11. 901 | 115/173 | 66.47% | 8/8 | Jurian
12. 612 | 80/229 | 34.93% | 10/10 | AnalPenguinFarming
13. 531 | 72/246 | 29.27% | 2/10 | Sir-Nuts
14. 488 | 57/227 | 25.11% | 10/10 | aldlv
15. 405 | 50/173 | 28.90% | 1/10 | LilFugitive
16. 349 | 43/99 | 43.43% | 0/10 | Suspended-3rd-Chord
17. 325 | 46/471 | 9.77% | 1/10 | Auz
18. 368 | 47/47 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Shadow-1409
19. 212 | 27/159 | 16.98% | 0/10 | Ragnarokia
20. 163 | 22/143 | 15.38% | 0/10 | Phantox
21. 207 | 24/61 | 39.34% | 7/10 | GronmonSE
22. 175 | 24/25 | 96.00% | 9/10 | mac2130
23. 75 | 12/64 | 18.75% | 0/10 | yoshi77777
24. 68 | 11/65 | 16.93% | 0/10 | Bearkillr
25. 65 | 9/25 | 36.00% | 5/10 | cristianedu
26. 60 | 8/9 | 88.88% | 8/9| PicosGhost

Requests this week: 10
Total all time: 644
Review this Week: 111
Average per member: 4.3
Average per movie: 11.1

New To the List
none

Leaving the List
none

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Jurian, AnalPenguinFarming, aldlv, Shadow-1409

Erm not to nitpick but i should be higher up on the list. :-S i have higher points than the 2 above me

At 3/23/08 08:46 PM, milinko959 wrote:

Thanks for the update milinko :D

Ok, I have a feeling I may have missed some people's reviews, so make sure I didn't.

Seems alright on mine :D

Flash Requests:

Only a few, should be easy enough

Audio Requests:

Ok lots there, timeto download and listen to them alot :D

Points/Completion Rate/Weekly Completion/User
1. 3897 | 530/604 | 87.75% | 10/10 | Coop83
2. 3360 | 493/639 | 77.15% | 0/10 | milinko959
3. 2180 | 282/282 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Little-Rena
4. 1958 | 264/264 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Haggard
5. 1768 | 244/260 | 93.85% | 10/10 | Shanus
6. 1672 | 234/256 | 91.40% | 0/10 | NintendoMadness

I'm getting use to this top 5 thing, there will not be any movement in a long time :(

18. 368 | 47/47 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Shadow-1409

I see you should be 16th :P

Requests this week: 10
Total all time: 644
Review this Week: 111
Average per member: 4.3
Average per movie: 11.1

Nice average this week, but a lot of people are reviewing I suppose :D

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Jurian, AnalPenguinFarming, aldlv, Shadow-1409

The party just gets bigger and bigger

Hey guys just to let you know that I'm quitting this club. I had a great time with you guys but I rarely review anymore so I see no point in being in this club.

- Phantox

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Jurian, AnalPenguinFarming, aldlv, Shadow-1409

Oh man it's been a looooooooooong time since I was on that list. I might as well just review everything tonight and see if I can make it one more time!

Hey, I'm just letting everyone know, those of you who reviewed my flash, first off, thank you. And I've responded to all reviews, so you can check out my responses! :P.

At 3/23/08 10:26 PM, Phantox wrote: Hey guys just to let you know that I'm quitting this club. I had a great time with you guys but I rarely review anymore so I see no point in being in this club.

- Phantox

Oh well, bid you farewell.

Thanks for the update, Mil. I should be a position higher as well though :P

14 audio requests this time, fair enough. I'm leaving the country from Thursday to Monday, so I'll see if I can review some before I leave.

Another song.
+Astronaut's Waltz+
I'm in a compositional high at the moment, and I don't want it to go to waste, so I've been putting my efforts to my music, rather than reviews... sorry to those who request reviews and I don't deliver, but I think I've already done a couple from this week, so, better than nothing...

At 3/23/08 08:46 PM, milinko959 wrote:

ohh.. nice... another uptade =D

Flash Requests:

Audio Requests:

Lot of audio request this time... yay

14. 488 | 57/227 | 25.11% | 10/10 | aldlv

nice...

Requests this week: 10
Total all time: 644
Review this Week: 111
Average per member: 4.3
Average per movie: 11.1

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Jurian, AnalPenguinFarming, aldlv, Shadow-1409

wow... is the first I appear here... & it feels cool
congrats to all here

At 3/22/08 08:13 PM, Bezman wrote:

What do YOU think is a reasonable max. length of vacation? I hadn't thought of that, so why not discuss?

well personaly i take about 3 weeks of vacation off a year (away from my comp anyway, being a student i get several weeks of per year) im thinking that mabye there should not be a full week pass but mabye a set # of flashes pass, so you can at least review part of the requests before you leave.

At 3/23/08 08:46 PM, milinko959 wrote: 22. 175 | 24/25 | 96.00% | 9/10 | mac2130

wait, i missed one? HOW THE FU** DID I MANAGE TO MISS ONE? GOD FU***NG DA** IT!!! Oh, well once ive gotten around 200 reviews that little speck of a mess up will only count for .5%. and by the way keep up the good work milinko at what your doing (until you leave) and i must compliment you for all the work youve put in to make the RRC what it is today, ive only been here two weeks but i still will dread the day you leave, and congrats on doing what none of us NG people have had the courage to do, get a life. (lol)

Wow, this lobby is nice!

Anyways, to business.

I was wondering whether one of you fine chaps would consent to giving your opinion of an audio submission of mine.

A direct passage to the aforementioned audio.

Thank you and good day!

Hey, I've got a new flash that I'd like some new reviews form after I've editted the sound of it, and I'd like to get an updated opinion.
Link

Thanks in advance.

At 3/23/08 08:46 PM, milinko959 wrote: Flash Requests:
Audio Requests:

4 flash and 15 audio requests. A fair amount of requests, so I guess I have to work a bit harder than last week to get them all done in time.

Points/Completion Rate/Weekly Completion/User
1. 3897 | 530/604 | 87.75% | 10/10 | Coop83
2. 3360 | 493/639 | 77.15% | 0/10 | milinko959
3. 2180 | 282/282 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Little-Rena
4. 1958 | 264/264 | 100.00% | 10/10 | Haggard
5. 1768 | 244/260 | 93.85% | 10/10 | Shanus

Seems like the top 5 is written in stone for quite some time now ^^.

Review this Week: 111
Average per member: 4.3
Average per movie: 11.1

Again, nice numbers. 11.1 per movie is outstanding!

All Requests Completed
Coop83, Little-Rena, Haggard, Shanus, Jurian, AnalPenguinFarming, aldlv, Shadow-1409

Congrats to all that made it on this list! :)

At 3/23/08 09:09 PM, Shadow-1409 wrote: Erm not to nitpick but i should be higher up on the list. :-S i have higher points than the 2 above me

Yes you should be :P .
Don't worry, I'm sure this will be corrected in the next update. ;)

At 3/23/08 10:26 PM, Phantox wrote: Hey guys just to let you know that I'm quitting this club. I had a great time with you guys but I rarely review anymore so I see no point in being in this club.

- Phantox

Pity. But farewell to you!

At 3/23/08 10:55 PM, PicosGhost wrote: Hey, I'm just letting everyone know, those of you who reviewed my flash, first off, thank you.

You're welcome! :)

And I've responded to all reviews, so you can check out my responses! :P.

Hey, thanks!

At 3/23/08 11:08 PM, GronmonSE wrote: Thanks for the update, Mil. I should be a position higher as well though :P

Yes, you should be one spot higher, too ^^.