Forum Topic: Punk vrs. Goth (which is better?)

(1,842 views • 151 replies)

This topic is 6 pages long. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 ]

<< < > >>
None

Synthpappa

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/17/06 11:29 PM

Synthpappa EVIL LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 11/21/04

Posts: 3,339

At 3/17/06 10:53 PM, Vicious_Demise wrote: they are into TOTALLY different things. They listen to different music, like different books, different art etc. That just doesn't make sense to me. And goths do not like Slipknot. Goths like the Bauhaus, Joy Division, Torri Amos, The Sisters of Mercy, Sixiouse and the Banshees(I can never spell that right.)..

Finally! You come to speak truth. It's Siouxsie and the Banshees, btw.


None

zag

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/17/06 11:30 PM

zag FAB LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 02/01/04

Posts: 406

At 3/17/06 10:47 PM, H3P4717US wrote: real punks are all fat turds that chill around in the their S&M pants and their ugly ass zip up leather jackets. talkin about how anarchy rules man and fuck the system. sorry to break it to ya buddy but anarchy is the dumbest thing ive ever heard of. u should go fuck urself for sayin u support anarchy. u r the reason bands like good charlotte havent jumped off a bridge yet. also goths are just as bad if not worse than punks but i wont go into that...

just because people listen to punk or metal doesnt classify them. i listen to punk indie emo hardcore screamo metal rap hip-hop what does that make me? i doubt u even know what real punk is. go home and listen to ur anthem by less than jake or ur simple plan. dont come to the bbs

alright first of all if ne of u kno who jello biafra (lead singer of the dead kennedys) is he has the right idea. anarchy is a great idea...but humans just arent ready for it. wut i mean is authority pretty much sucks. look at all the cops who abuse there title. its kind of sad that we need cops around not to kill each other in the first place. we realy should be able to dictate our selves but most people today seem to have no conscience(sorry if i spelled it wrong idk)

now to the stereotypes and that shit. i say we should be able to listen to what ever the fuck we want and wear what ever the fuck we want without being labeled punk,goth,nerd,emo or whatever bullshit people have come up with. say some one listens to and is wearing a ....alright i cant think of ne band in paticular lol but ok a "gothic music band" lol and wearing the big baggy hot topic pants. all of a sudden they are a goth. (to others i float around as a goth/punk because i wear hot topic pants and band shirts usualy with bands like the sexpistols,iron maiden etc u get the idea) i think if there was no bs like that at all people would wear wut they want,listen to what they want,hang out with who they want instead of 100 look alikes, and act how they like instead of someone asking themself if it is "ok" for a "goth" to do that. but thats all just what i think. any opinions (by the way im sorry if theres alot of "aim" talk in here im trying to phase it out because of you assholes who wont stop complaining about my grammar and its easier just to try to fix it than listen to you all bitch lol.


None

WawaneesA

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/17/06 11:32 PM

WawaneesA LIGHT LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 01/11/06

Posts: 1,464

Actually, they're pretty different but similar at the same time.

Think of it


None

monkyboy29

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/17/06 11:35 PM

monkyboy29 EVIL LEVEL 13

Sign-Up: 09/20/05

Posts: 2,119

At 3/17/06 11:29 PM, Synthpappa wrote:
At 3/17/06 10:53 PM, Vicious_Demise wrote: they are into TOTALLY different things. They listen to different music, like different books, different art etc. That just doesn't make sense to me. And goths do not like Slipknot. Goths like the Bauhaus, Joy Division, Torri Amos, The Sisters of Mercy, Sixiouse and the Banshees(I can never spell that right.)..
Finally! You come to speak truth. It's Siouxsie and the Banshees, btw.

actually.... yes they do. goths like mudvayne too....

man you people are all so narrow minded.


None

Synthpappa

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:37 AM

Synthpappa EVIL LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 11/21/04

Posts: 3,339

At 3/17/06 11:35 PM, monkyboy29 wrote: actually.... yes they do. goths like mudvayne too....

man you people are all so narrow minded.

Hehe. lol. You're a funny boy.


None

King

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:37 AM

King FAB LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 02/05/04

Posts: 4,128

Punks!

A real goth, not an emo in disguise, is scary, depressing, and smelly.

Bleh.


None

HarmonyClock

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:39 AM

HarmonyClock NEUTRAL LEVEL 11

Sign-Up: 06/08/04

Posts: 119

Punk sucks anus in every way.

Goth chicks are hot (if theyre not ugly as hell that is)
However Goth music is a nausience


None

ForNoReason

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:40 AM

ForNoReason NEUTRAL LEVEL 17

Sign-Up: 06/01/03

Posts: 3,157

No one knows what ither one IS anymore... I go for punk... flame me if you will because I like Green Day. But my roots are in the Clash and the Ramones.


None

King

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:42 AM

King FAB LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 02/05/04

Posts: 4,128

At 3/18/06 01:39 AM, HarmonyClock wrote: Punk sucks anus in every way.

Goth chicks are hot (if theyre not ugly as hell that is)
However Goth music is a nausience

*sniff sniff* I smell a noob! Call a mod!

Bleh.


None

Synthpappa

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:46 AM

Synthpappa EVIL LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 11/21/04

Posts: 3,339

At 3/18/06 01:37 AM, Wes_is_king wrote: Punks!

A real goth, not an emo in disguise, is scary, depressing, and smelly.

You can't say that they all smell one way. Some stink. Most smell great.


None

King

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:48 AM

King FAB LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 02/05/04

Posts: 4,128

At 3/18/06 01:46 AM, Synthpappa wrote:
At 3/18/06 01:37 AM, Wes_is_king wrote:
You can't say that they all smell one way. Some stink. Most smell great.

They smell like broken dreams and the blood of 1000 virgins.

I'm just kidding, click my sig to understand me in a way that not even Jesus could comprihend.
I have/had goth friends :P

Bleh.


None

technonavey

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:49 AM

technonavey NEUTRAL LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 03/07/06

Posts: 29

Punks because my cousin is a goth and she slits her wrists when the doctors are not looking.


None

Miigga

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 01:52 AM

Miigga EVIL LEVEL 17

Sign-Up: 08/05/04

Posts: 2,574

Punk & Goth = Same shit


None

Synthpappa

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:03 AM

Synthpappa EVIL LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 11/21/04

Posts: 3,339

At 3/18/06 01:49 AM, technonavey wrote: Punks because my cousin is a goth and she slits her wrists when the doctors are not looking.

She's just an emo.


None

<deleted>

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:10 AM

At 3/17/06 09:47 PM, Mozis wrote: your right REAL goths dont exist... but if you came to my town........ well buddy you yould be in for the ride of you LIFE

I think you need to read SomethingAwful's "How to spot a real punk" article. It's VERY informative.


None

batman64

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:11 AM

batman64 NEUTRAL LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 08/20/04

Posts: 1,874

Cripes, neither is better it's just a matter of opinion. I've been into punk since the 60's with the Mc5, Iggy and the Stooges and the like. Also liked the 70's and early 80's bands like Dead Kennedys, Exploited, The Damned, Battalion of Saints, 999, Black Flag, Suicidal Tendencies, etc, etc. Also liked early Goth like Bauhaus, Alien Sex Fiend, Fields of The Nephilim and others. I have a son who likes and dresses Goth, so fuckin what, he also likes Slipknot cause I turned him onto it. My daughter likes goth, punk, and other types and also dresses goth and punk. My youngest son is a skate punk who likes Black Flag as well as classic rock from the 60's and 70's and has very long hair like an old school hippie. My goth son has dyed black hair and he wears makeup when hanging out with friends, SFW, he is still a good kid who does well in school and at least isn't messing with drugs. My daughter has a punk cut dyed burgundy. Myself I have a mohawk. Some family huh? Funny thing is we get along great and can listen to each others music without a problem. Just a normal family with different styles and tastes in music. Just wish others can be as open minded as we are and from what I read here some of you are too. All in all it just comes down to a matter of taste, no style is "Better" then the next, it's just different. Why not try something new some time, you just might find something you like. OK, this old punk is dome rambling. Peace.


None

Dark-Phire

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:12 AM

Dark-Phire DARK LEVEL 07

Sign-Up: 03/03/05

Posts: 5,734

So much stereotypes in this thread.

BBS Signature

None

WawaneesA

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:13 AM

WawaneesA LIGHT LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 01/11/06

Posts: 1,464

At 3/18/06 01:39 AM, HarmonyClock wrote: Punk sucks anus in every way.

Goth chicks are hot (if theyre not ugly as hell that is)
However Goth music is a nausience

?
Are that all your interests?
Noob


None

Lord-Zed

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:31 AM

Lord-Zed NEUTRAL LEVEL 21

Sign-Up: 11/05/05

Posts: 2,098

At 3/18/06 02:11 AM, batman64 wrote: stuff

Thnkyou, dear Lord!

BTW, heard the Coloured Balls?
BBS Signature

None

Lagrance

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:42 AM

Lagrance FAB LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 01/08/04

Posts: 897

estonia has em both, but i have to say that goths suck, they listen to shitty darkwawe and are like white pride world wide and shit.
Ahh, gotta love punk bands here one received airplay in 1989 in FINLAND!=! O_O
Cause its a big long story how he got a cd out, the KGB was holding all punks down, the bands guitarist got his college degree taken and stuff.
But now they're still succesful. And great, their setup is 1xguitarvocal 1xbass 1xdrums 2xbacking female singers.
And boy do they fuck up everything, their show live on tv got the audience that the mainman went to his homeplace where theres a lot of punks and they all were drunk so he loaded em into a car and took em to the concert.


None

batman64

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:46 AM

batman64 NEUTRAL LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 08/20/04

Posts: 1,874

At 3/18/06 02:31 AM, Zigoxonus wrote:
At 3/18/06 02:11 AM, batman64 wrote: stuff
Thnkyou, dear Lord!

BTW, heard the Coloured Balls?

Will definitely have to check em out, I see that Billy Thorpe jammed with em. Children of The Sun is still a great song.


Thinking

Zackrrior

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 03:44 AM

Zackrrior EVIL LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 03/15/06

Posts: 96

(to answer the threds question im with the goths)

But i don't let the music, or fads and sterio types define who i am, i where black, love hot topic, but there just clothes, there not going to pay my rent or make my like any easyer , im not in school anymore, all that shit you guys think is so important, fiting in or presure from your friends to do or not do something, after your not in school anymore, it's all gona fade away, yea you may or may not stay around some of the guys you went to school with but its not gona last, they'll move, you'll move...
me my self ive move 14 times last year alone, ive been to :george west-texas, pensacola-florida, datona-florida, Jacksonvill-northcarolina, Holly ridge-north carolina, Bay city-Michagain, Flint-michagain, Mt.morris-michagain, memphis, southcarolina, jersy, georga, ohio, bango-main now im living on bace in FT.knox Kentucky, you know it really dosn't matter what people think of you at this point, as long as your rents paid and you got food up in the crib, get some beer... you can say im the queen of england, and i whouldn't give a shit. but to me im a goth... i've sufferd my entire school life from K-10, got 4 of my classes droped cuzz i had 1 to many absentsass so i went to join the army, had a siesure when they took my blood, pissed my pants, woke up had no idea where i was... now im about to party my ass off, get drunk, hang out with my brother and my 2 nephews 1 last time befor i bounce out again to like alaska or somthen...

basicly... nobody can define who you are, without your permision, its up to you to make up your own dam mind, or let everybody else tell you who you are...
Drugs like pot, X. shrooms, elcahaul, speed, there fun, big fun, i've done them all, there a good way to go if you like everybody else living your life for you, that and if you don't like having any money... choises choises choises, i choose to where black, drink beer, sit in my bacement trancen out sing'en im an oscer myier weiner... good time... im stepen out for a square. laters


None

hellsorb

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 04:25 AM

hellsorb NEUTRAL LEVEL 05

Sign-Up: 10/22/05

Posts: 710

Both I pride myself on being a little bit of everything, and for the most part keeping an open mind. I like about every type of music but rap, its just not singing to me. (gives me a headache><)

If everyone thinks you are the devil... Why not play it up?

BBS Signature

None

Elvis666

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 04:27 AM

Elvis666 EVIL LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 07/13/05

Posts: 19

Goth any day. Punk doesn´t suck, but it is too simple.


None

hellsorb

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 04:34 AM

hellsorb NEUTRAL LEVEL 05

Sign-Up: 10/22/05

Posts: 710

At 3/18/06 03:44 AM, Zackrrior wrote: (to answer the threds question im with the goths)

But i don't let the music, or fads and sterio types define who i am, i where black, love hot topic, but there just clothes, there not going to pay my rent or make my like any easyer , im not in school anymore, all that shit you guys think is so important, fiting in or presure from your friends to do or not do something, after your not in school anymore, it's all gona fade away, yea you may or may not stay around some of the guys you went to school with but its not gona last, they'll move, you'll move...

I agree I am me. there are some good qualities in any style really I love to mix and match its just part of my style. I don't care who knows I get a chuckle out of listening to the Inspector Gadget theme. (Go gadget Go!) ;D I enjoy myself I don't care what anyone thinks as long as I'm not hurting anyone, who cares?

If everyone thinks you are the devil... Why not play it up?

BBS Signature

None

Treszka

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 05:01 AM

Treszka EVIL LEVEL 11

Sign-Up: 11/10/02

Posts: 535

Honestly, people who even use labels to define themselves aren't the real deal. 90% of the people who think they're 'goth' or 'emo' are rich, angsty teenagers who go around complaining about how horrible their lives are because mommy or daddy took away their credit cards and now they can't shop at Hot Topic. Boo hoo. So then they sit and cry in their rooms, using something sharp to slighty scratch their arms for show and tell at school the next day. See why I hate modern teenagers?

Me? I like way too many different things to even be 'labeled.' I am who I am.


Angry

dapperdan1

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 07:15 AM

dapperdan1 EVIL LEVEL 11

Sign-Up: 02/13/05

Posts: 987

I personally prefer goths as they have 219 exp points and the summoning sword of a'koth.

Classifications are for faggots.
BBS Signature

None

1Dizmal1

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 07:42 AM

1Dizmal1 NEUTRAL LEVEL 14

Sign-Up: 11/27/05

Posts: 1,863

Some goth girls are hawt.


None

Vicious-Demise

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:07 PM

Vicious-Demise EVIL LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 12/29/05

Posts: 593

At 3/17/06 11:29 PM, Synthpappa wrote:

Finally! You come to speak truth. It's Siouxsie and the Banshees, btw.

Hi XD Oh thanks I mess up on a lot of band names, but I shall try and remember that's how you spell it. Yep.. Most of the people on this thread don't even know what goth is.


None

Black-Chaos

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 3/18/06 02:08 PM

Black-Chaos FAB LEVEL 18

Sign-Up: 01/25/06

Posts: 1,950

Punk is way better.

My site is down... and it'll stay down until I do something about it... :3

BBS Signature

All times are Eastern Standard Time (GMT -5) | Current Time: 01:00 PM

<< Back

This topic is 6 pages long. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 ]

<< < > >>
You need a Grounds Gold Account to post on the NG BBS! If you don't have one, click here to sign up now! It's fast, free, and easy — and opens up tons of great NG features!