At 3/11/06 06:22 PM, -MuTe_EcHo- wrote:
Yes she could have been a threat.the soldiers should have been suspicious up to the point when the backpack was shot off her with a powerful gun,AND the girl was making all efforts to LEAVE the perimeter.how can you shoot someone when they are moving away from your direction?
As I said, if she really was heading away from the place which she shouldn't have gotten to, without leaving the bag there, she wouldn't have been shot. I do not know how barbaric you think we are, but the thing is that in the Israeli army the discipline is very tight. Soldiers are not being forgiven easily. Believe me that the army court is completely neutral and if it found that the soldier is innocent, he is probably is innocent. They have investigated it for months, much much more than the info you have gotten from the silly article.
Ok sure It would be fine to kill a Nazi who actually killed Jews,But what If there was a guy who simply liked Nazis ALOT.If he was charged in an Israeli court he could be killed.I know the Nazis did terrible things,but theres no reason for Israelis to behave the same way towards the Palestinians who live right next door.
As I said, you do not know what you are talking about. We can kill a nazi which killed a lot of people in WW2, but we cannot kill just an anti-semite or a neo-nazi just for being anti semites or neo-nazis. Do you think there are no Israel haters in this country? Do you think we kill them?
Dont get angry Lidov It prevents you from debating right.I know that I don't know how a soldier feels in WAR,but then again Israeli sodliers arent fighting an all out War.they are fighting an uprising which has actually subsided very much.Suicide bombers rarely attack,the Palestinians now are trying to make progress with peace.But I do know when any soldier not just an Israeli Soldier has made a mistake.You have to use common sense and moral thinking to decide if what this man did is wrong.to me He is wrong because even soldiers in his unit dexribed the girl as scared.
Wow, this is a bunch of bullshit. I suggest that you read the papers a little more to know a bit about the current situation. Also, keep in mind that the soldier shot the girl a long time ago. At the time the soldier shot the girl, the suicide bombers were NOT a rare thing. The Palastinians are not currently in the progress of peace, and they also pretty much weren't while this occurance occured.
And the thing that made me angry is that saying of yours in which you said that Israeli soldiers just wish they had the chance to kill many Palastinians.
"Hey, you don't know the American soldiers, they just wish they had the chance to shoot each and every iraqi dead".