At 11/28/09 09:55 PM, Patton3 wrote:
Well... considering it was posted here, I thought that it was obvious the topic. Anyway, thanks for the points. It's been an e-mail back and forth for a while. and yes, Griffin, you're right in the regard that he likes to take an emotional point of view.
However, a point that the only logical explanation for the universe's existence is god... Any points anyone here would like to make on this.
No, God, has the IBE, the inference of the best explanation, which means that it is the simplest way of explaining the fundimental logic of the universe. That does not necessarily mean that he is the best explanation for the universe. Has he ever watched the matrix!
Also watch out for this trap, it's called the arguement for irruducable complexity. The simple answer to that is science can explain everything. Without science there would be no fundimental logic to anything.
Here is some copypasta from something I wrote a long time ago, put it into context.
The commonly accepted answer before the 19th century was that God created the universe, all that is present was crafted by an almighty hand, somehow transcendent to the people we are today. Now this answer is rejected, and over the fluctuation of time and space mankind has evolved and unveiled countless findings; science does not attempt to disprove God, as it is commonly perceived, but only wishes to unravel the mysteries that have boggled our minds for practically countless years.
There is the argument for irreducible complexity, which suggests something like, the human eye is so complex that it must have been created, because it has been created perfectly and functions co-existentially with the human body; blahblahblah.
As far as I'm concerned, this argument is invalid, it simply claims that you do not understand the eye comprehensibly enough. You'll have to phrase that in your own words if it comes up, but basically; 1/2 does not = irreducible complexity. No, 1/2 = 0.5 / 2 = 0.25 .etc Its our understanding which defines the complexity of a structure.
Um. Just tell me what he says and I'll start pulling the guns out of my hat.