At 2/4/05 01:13 AM, Fuel2Fire wrote: So after 3 days with a 5 rating and people downloading my song very fast 1 other vote of 0 put me to a 2.50 rating and halfway or less down the chart. Since then the # of downloads of the song maybe went to like 3 more in about a month. I doubt this is coincidence.
No, it's not. And it IS frustrating to be stuck in that limbo land with basically no chance of recovery.
The two important points to be drawn from this (IMO) are:
a) 70 downloads, but only ONE vote? Why? I'm guessing it's mostly because users don't get the 'virtual bonus' of the audio equivalent of a BP point. It's a sad situation, but without some kind of reward, the incentive to take 1 extra second to vote just isn't there.
b) A vote of 0...? There are very few clips on the AP that deserve a zero, yet there are plenty of 0's being thrown about. Why? Well, my theory is this: virtually everybody who takes time to vote on audio submissions is a musician/audio submitter... and as anybody who has attempted to break into the 'music biz' knows, the whole fiasco is based on promoting yourself whilst subtly stamping on the competition... and unfortunately the Audio Portal lends itself perfectly to this strategy.
It seems an automatic reaction when seeing a 5 on the AP to 'balance it out' (I hasten to add that I DON'T do this myself, but have seen it happen both on my own and other users' stuff) by voting 0. And there's not even any way to check whether the voter actually listened to the music....
So my idea is that all songs newly added should have a 5 rating till at least 5 people have rated the song. This way it is more fair to the artist and people will take that extra few seconds to actually rate music.
I think (for the reason mentioned in my last paragraph) that showing a score of 5 would be a bad idea. It would probably result in five consecutive votes of 0 or 1. It would be better to have an Under Judgement section, and simply hide the score - like the Flash Portal. I think it would also be nice to show how many votes have been cast on audio submissions.
Just a thought of mine to end some of my own, and other audio portal atrists, frustration.
Thanks for the comments, they helped me put some of my thoughts into words