So I think it's time to go ahead and give credit where credit is due. Since the regular season is winding down, I'm going to go ahead and list the players I think made the biggest strides this year, team-style (as in, 1 per position, not counting pitchers & OFs).
C - Close runnings to Pablo Sandoval and Miguel Montero, but this one has to go Joe Mauer. Yes, he was already a stud player before this year, but no one could have forecasted a season like the one he is in the middle of this year. Despite missing the first month, he has not hit under .305 at any point this season, and is more or less singlehandedly leading the Twins towards a postseason berth.
Final Line: TBD, but as of now, .367 AVG/.444 OBP/.602 SLG/1.047 OPS, 28 HRs, 92 RBI, 88 R, 4 SBs
1B - Deserved credit here goes to Billy Butler and Russell Branyan, but this award has to go to Kendy Morales for his breakout year. Having the tall order of replacing Mark Teixeira after his departure for New York, Morales also has had the task of covering in the lineup for the injured Torii Hunter as well as Vlad Gurerro's lost season. Despite all of this, he has propelled the Angels with a monster second half of the season (.325/.368/.608/.976, 18 2Bs, 18 HRs, 56 RBI, 44 R, 1 SB), helping them clinch the AL West.
Final Line - TBD, but currently .303 AVG/.352 OBP/.565 SLG/.917 OPS, 42 2Bs, 33 HRs, 105 RBIs, 83 R, 2 SBs
2B - Props to Ben Zobrist, Alberto Callaspo and Casey McGeehee on breakout years, but this one HAS to go to Blue Jays two-bagger Aaron Hill for his monstrous season. There are no doubts in my mind that Aaron Hill deserves to be called one of the top-5 second baseman in the game after a year like this. All the more incredible is that this comes after a 2008 that was shortened by a fairly severe concussion that knocked him out after 55 games. Combine that with solid defense, and I would slot Hill behind the likes of Chase Utley, Brian Roberts and Ian Kinsler, ahead of fellow AL East 2B such as Robby Cano and Ben Zobrist and tied with Dustin Pedroia.
Final Line - TBD, but currently .287 AVG/.328 OBP/.499 SLG/.827 OPS, 35 2Bs, 36 HRs, 105 RBI, 101 R, 5 SBs
3B - No doubt here, this award has to go to Mark Reynolds for his all-around improvement. Of course, Reynolds still strikes out plenty (record-setting amounts, in fact), but despite that, he has improved across the board, despite playing in a more anemic offense than last year. His defense has improved much as well, leaving the D'Backs with yet another future star on their hands, and he may have not hit his ceiling yet; I wouldn't count out 50 HRs a year or two from now with his prodigious power. Reynolds has hit the longest HR this year as measured by true distance, a 481' bomb against who else but Brad Lidge on July 28th (vid here). Not just that, but he has hit 2 of the 5 longest HRs as measured by standard distance, that one and a 470' monster against the Giants (video here). He has shown he is the most powerful hitter in the league this year when it comes to home runs, as judged by his league-leading average distance per HR, which is a beastly 415.7 feet.
Final Line - TBD, but currently .264 AVG/.355 OBP/.558 SLG/.912 OPS, 44 HRs, 101 RBIs, 95 R, 24 SBs
SS - An interesting crop to pick from here, as Erick Aybar and Asdrubal Cabrera both finally began to meet expectations. However, this position is won out by Jason Bartlett, perhaps the most surprising of any player this year. An afterthought piece in the Matt Garza-Delmon Young trade, Bartlett has combined standout defense at short with a breakout season at the plate. Joe Maddon called him the Rays' MVP for this year, despite the team having Evan Longoria and fellow breakout-year-buddy Ben Zobrist. The Rays may not have met expectations this year, but Bartlett has certainly exceeded his own, with a 30+ point jump in average, a nearly 60 point jump in OBP, a whopping 130-point jump in SLG, and a 185+ point jump in OPS, to go along with career highs in HRs, RBIs, Rs, SBs, hits, doubles, and triples.
Final Line - TBD, but currently .320 AVG/.386 OBP/.492 SLG/.868 OPS, 28 2Bs, 14 HRs, 65 RBI, 87 R, 27 SBs
OF - A huge crowd to pick three out of for this year, thanks to breakout seasons all around. However, my selections go to Justin Upton, Garrett Jones, and Nelson Cruz. Shin-Soo Choo's 20-20 campaign does not deserve to go unnoticed, however, and neither does Rajai Davis's 40-SB season, Chris Coghlan's potential ROY season, Carlos Gonzalez's breakout, or Andrew McCutchen's dazzling rookie year. However, these three have shone above the rest.
We all know (and probably knew) that Justin, the younger Upton, had more potential than his older brother does/did, but after a fairly pedestrian rookie year, I don't think too many people were expecting this 2009 breakout at the young age of 22. Posting a 20-20 campaign in another lousy offensive year from Arizona's lineup, Upton made strides in every dimension at the plate, improving 80 points in SLG, 100 points in OPS, 50 points in AVG, and nearly 20 points in OBP. The Ken Griffey Jr. comparisons are slowly beginning to look merited, and I for one cannot wait to see what JUpton brings to the table in 2010.
Final Line - TBD, currently .307 AVG/.375 OBP/.543 SLG/.917 OPS, 30 2Bs, 25 HRs, 83 RBI, 82 R, 20 SBs
Nelson Cruz for a long time was considered the quintessential Quad-A player: a guy that could rip through Triple-A pitching like it was nothing, but could not hit a lick at the major league level. That changed in the last month of last year, forecasting a big year in 2009 for Cruz. However, not too many people could have expected a campaign such as this one. Despite Cruz's tendency to be red-hot and then ice-cold for extended periods of time, he still buoyed a Rangers outfield that was depleted by the consistent, nagging injuries to Josh Hamilton. His power has always been noted (as was shown off at this year's Home Run Derby), but his accompanying speed was not. He stopped running as much in the 2nd half of the season, likely due to fatigue, but still has posted a 30-20 season. Along with fellow breakout-season-haver Marlon Byrd, Cruz delighted many Rangers fans and helped them to challenge the Angels in the AL West, a surprise for most everyone. 2010 should be a big year and a big step forward for the Rangers, as well as Cruz.
Final Line - TBD, currently .263 AVG/.335 OBP/.530 SLG/.865 OPS, 21 2Bs, 33 HRs, 76 RBI, 75 R, 20 SBs
And perhaps the biggest surprise of any surprise, Garrett Jones. Cast away by the Twins organization, he came to the Pirates' minor-league system. Not expected to be a major piece in the Pirates plans by any stretch of the imagination, Jones burst onto the scene in July, conducting a ridiculous three-month campaign so good that it forced his manager to play him every day. While many thought he would eventually cool off, Jones has stayed fairly consistent all-around, in fact, hitting for a better average in September than any other month. He gives the Pirates a new piece to their ever-enduring puzzle, and could potentially be a powerful lineup staple in 2010. His moderate speed is just an added bonus.
Final Line - TBD, currently .305 AVG/.380 OBP/.596 SLG/.975 OPS, 20 2Bs, 21 HRs, 44 RBI, 42 R, 10 SBs
DH - Another no-doubt here, this one goes to the Jays' Adam Lind. Another player stuck with the Quad-A label, Lind also broke out this year in a big way for the Jays, improving their lineup by leaps and bounds over past years. Though he was called up for three short stints in the past three years by the Jays, he never showed anything; this year, Lind has shown what he can do when given a full season to hit.
Final Line - TBD, currently .304 AVG/.367 OBP/.545 SLG/.912 OPS, 46 2Bs, 34 HR, 113 RBI, 92 R, 1 SB