Well, the Phils missed a golden opportunity to go up 2-0 in this series. Myers wasn't great, but he wasn't terrible either. The first inning still gives him troubles, but he shouldn't have given up any runs in the 2nd inning after a bad call by home plate umpire Kerwin Danley. Myers got Baldelli to check swing far enough on a slider for it to be a called third strike, then my boy Kerwin rings him up... or does he? He throws up his arm to ring him up but he checks with the 1st base umpire, who blew the call of him swinging as well. So that changed the inning from 1 on with 2 outs to 2 on with 1 out.
Link to event + ruling.
I understand the rule, but they fail to point out that Danley already raised his arm to call it a 3rd strike before it was appealed... by himself? Ruiz didn't ask for an appeal on the swing and I don't believe Baldelli did either. As far as I know, once a ruling has been made on balls and strikes, they can't be overturned, even by yourself. I have no idea why Danley called him out and then asked for a 2nd ruling.
One could argue that this call evened out the supposed Hamels balk in game one, which I guess I can't argue with. But, I'll refer to my point that there was no guarantee the Rays would've scored after that, but they did here. Of course, had Myers done a better job, this would all be a moot point.
As forShields, he was good, but he wasn't BIG GAME in my opinion tonight as he didn't even finish 6 innings. Sure he didn't give up any runs, but he had runners on base basically every inning, and the Phils continued with their lackluster performance of hitting with runners in scoring position. I honestly didn't think they'd have back to back games where they basically did nothing with runners in scoring position. 1 or 2 hits with RISP in any innings from 2-6 or so could've changed the face of this game.
They did actually get one in the 9th. Which brings me back to my boy Kerwin! Clearly that ball hit J-Rolls jersey and he should've been on 1st base for 2 on and 0 outs. On Home plate umps I'm usually not that critical when it comes to the strike zone as everyone has their own feel for it, but he's gotta make those calls (or rather not screw up) that involve swings and hits by pitch. Werth connected well enough to score Ruiz on that weird hop that Longoria couldn't handle, and who knows, with that speed maybe J-Roll scores from 1st, making it 4-3 instead of 4-2.
But yeah, I can't blame it all on umps, the Phils did their fair share of not getting clutch hits. Howard woke up a bit, but when he did he was leading off and was stranded twice, but J-Roll was looking pretty bad again. It goes to Philly for 3 must win games in my opinion. It might be difficult with Blanton and Moyer going for the Phils in 2 of those 3, but perhaps some home cooking will do them good.