Reviewed:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/607927
I want a review on my latest track :) First time I made a ambient/spacy track :)
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/607988
At 2/15/15 01:39 PM, Retsamehtmai wrote: Hello all!
Here is a neat little song I reviewed :)
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/607262
Please critique this one of mine ^_^
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/606530
Hey, you're supposed to review the song above yours, not a random song.
He reviewed a song that was skipped, you dont have to review the song above you exactly, heck you dont even have to review one (In the last page i reviewed 2 for 1 review lol)
At 2/16/15 01:27 AM, NyxTheShield wrote: He reviewed a song that was skipped, you dont have to review the song above you exactly, heck you dont even have to review one (In the last page i reviewed 2 for 1 review lol)
u have to review the one above you AT LEAST to keep this thread organized
thanks guys fro trying to help means im not the only one frustrated when people don't read :)
lel
At 2/16/15 02:32 AM, Sequenced wrote:At 2/16/15 01:27 AM, NyxTheShield wrote: He reviewed a song that was skipped, you dont have to review the song above you exactly, heck you dont even have to review one (In the last page i reviewed 2 for 1 review lol)u have to review the one above you AT LEAST to keep this thread organized
thanks guys fro trying to help means im not the only one frustrated when people don't read :)
That's a really aggressive, even more when you wrote, line by line:
How does the R4R thread work then? Basically, you HAVE to review ANY song that has been linked in this thread BEFORE you can post a link to what ever song you want to be reviewed
But whatever, i will keep doing what i am doing.
At 2/16/15 05:25 AM, NyxTheShield wrote:
How does the R4R thread work then? Basically, you HAVE to review ANY song that has been linked in this thread BEFORE you can post a link to what ever song you want to be reviewed
But whatever, i will keep doing what i am doing.
yehh i was sick that day with 102 fever so couldn't get my thoughts down clearly :D
lel
I reviewed this
And i would enjoy a review on this (Honestly, be aware, it might not be your cup of tea, Dark Ambient/Drone)
And back at it after a couple days, I am.
I have reviewed:
And I would like reviewed:
Or
At 2/16/15 01:58 PM, JandreParis wrote: And back at it after a couple days, I am.
I have reviewed:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/606837
And I would like reviewed:
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/604229
Or
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/426730
I got caught in the page change XD So i will review this (Or well, have reviewed it by the time this post is live xD):
And would like a review on this:
I reviewed a dark ambient piece, you should also look at it!
Please give me some feedback on this song:
I reviewed this haunting and jazzy tune
Here's some high energy electronica I remastered from the archives
Developer by day; Deviant by night
Reviewed this epic, hyper energetic track:
Would love some feedback on my newest track :);
Just a random idiot
I reviewed this:
And would enjoy a review on this :3
![Aquatic Ambiance [Acoustic]](https://aicon.ngfiles.com/608/608513_medium.png?f1424219322)
Reviewed this awesome piece:
Would appreciate a review on this:
-
Unpublished Submission
Cheers!
Hello, I'm an up and comer. So I apologize if I forget to mention something else.
Anyway not to waste too much time.
This little tune here shot WAY passed what I expected when I decided to click it. I recommend this
to anyone who likes to play classic/Retro/horror games. Preferably both.
In exchange I would like to have this little SHORT ditty here reviewed.
http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/608705 Thank you. ^^
At 2/18/15 07:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote: Hello, I'm an up and comer. So I apologize if I forget to mention something else.
dude put in more thought into your reviews.
lel
At 2/18/15 08:30 PM, Sequenced wrote:At 2/18/15 07:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote: Hello, I'm an up and comer. So I apologize if I forget to mention something else.dude put in more thought into your reviews.
Could you be more specific..? I mean anyone could tell me that.
Reviewed:
Check it out! It was really good stuff
Please someone review:
I gave a quick review of
If someone could give a review of this piece of shit I'd be grateful.
At 2/18/15 08:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote:At 2/18/15 08:30 PM, Sequenced wrote:Could you be more specific..? I mean anyone could tell me that.At 2/18/15 07:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote: Hello, I'm an up and comer. So I apologize if I forget to mention something else.dude put in more thought into your reviews.
anybody can tell me a song is good in three sentences. you really think someone is going to learn from that?
lel
At 2/19/15 08:32 AM, Sequenced wrote:At 2/18/15 08:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote:anybody can tell me a song is good in three sentences. you really think someone is going to learn from that?At 2/18/15 08:30 PM, Sequenced wrote:Could you be more specific..? I mean anyone could tell me that.At 2/18/15 07:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote: Hello, I'm an up and comer. So I apologize if I forget to mention something else.dude put in more thought into your reviews.
Well I was asking a question. I'm not doing this to be a smart ass. It's just when you got onto me because my review in your opinion "Needed more thought." Your criticism of my review also needed more thought. Get it..? I mean you have to set an example first is all I'm saying.
At 2/19/15 09:56 AM, Skythevoiceguy wrote:
anybody can tell me a song is good in three sentences. you really think someone is going to learn from that?Well I was asking a question. I'm not doing this to be a smart ass. It's just when you got onto me because my review in your opinion "Needed more thought." Your criticism of my review also needed more thought. Get it..? I mean you have to set an example first is all I'm saying.
anybody can tell me a song is good in three sentences. you really think someone is going to learn from that?
lel
At 2/19/15 09:56 AM, Skythevoiceguy wrote:At 2/19/15 08:32 AM, Sequenced wrote:Well I was asking a question. I'm not doing this to be a smart ass. It's just when you got onto me because my review in your opinion "Needed more thought." Your criticism of my review also needed more thought. Get it..? I mean you have to set an example first is all I'm saying.At 2/18/15 08:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote:anybody can tell me a song is good in three sentences. you really think someone is going to learn from that?At 2/18/15 08:30 PM, Sequenced wrote:Could you be more specific..? I mean anyone could tell me that.At 2/18/15 07:56 PM, Skythevoiceguy wrote: Hello, I'm an up and comer. So I apologize if I forget to mention something else.dude put in more thought into your reviews.
I'm just gonna be really rude and cut in on your conversation and set a decent example of how artists of this community ought to treat one anothers' work.
Here are a few general points that I usually follow:
1. Listen to the song (obviously), and I mean LISTEN, don't just cut through half the thing and then build a review based on the fraction of the material you've observed.
2. Point out minor and/or major pros and cons.
3. (Optional) give the artist some tips on how to solve the problems. While you're at it, give them the names of artists that sound similar to the song you're reviewing. It might just help them get through the mixing process a little more easily.
4. *IMPORTANT*: You can criticize stuff without being a total dick.
Writing a good or at least decent review doesn't take so long. Make an effort to help others, and they will most likely act the same towards you and to the rest of the NG music community.
Thanks for reading. Take care.
//Kabalist.
I reviewed this:
And i would enjoy a review on this :3
![Flutterwonder [Acoustic Cover]](https://aicon.ngfiles.com/608/608866_medium.png?f1424367171)
I reviewed this: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/607001
and this: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/608866
^ Really calming cover there, you should hear it.
------
And I'd like this reviewed: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/598886
Also, apperently my links won't show up like the rest, all fancy up with information and all that, even though I just used the URL as well, any help here?
I left a review for: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/598886
I would like this reviewed please: http://www.newgrounds.com/audio/listen/608995
Harro!
I have reviewed:
I would like this artist to be reviewed:
Cheers!
Hi, I'm not sure how to post these audio links. If you wouldn't mind, check out my latest track. I tried to mix some elements from modern electronic music and video game music.
Anyways, I gave this cool acoustic/female-vocalist song a review.
I also reviewed this relaxing electronic track here.
And lastly, I reviewed this artist's dubstep track.
Hey, I reviewed this artist's retro-inspired electronic track here:
And I'd like this track reviewed, if you'd be so kind. Cheers!
Reviewed this awesome song -
Would love some feedback on this one -
