Are webcomics conisdered art?

[BAvinnie]

Didn't see a better place to post this so here it is, check them out and let me know what you think (theres not many, its brand new but I'm officially updating every tues/fri).

http://www.wix.com/dem9001/rsmc

[Kuoke]

I strongly advise against starting or even partaking 'is ____ art' discussions. They are long winded - and for no good reason.
I can't really tell if your post is blatant self promotion or not, but here's a couple of things - design/panelling is awkward. It's not really a 'comic', it's more like some text with accompanying images because the way you situated the 'narration' and the speech completely breaks the fact that there are even images to begin with.

[TurkeyOnAStick]

Yes, webcomics are art.

Links to webpages aren't art.
Please upload your comics to the art forum =(

otherwise this forum is in danger of being renamed the "Some text and a Link Forum"

[BAvinnie]

At 1/19/11 10:02 AM, Kuoke wrote: I strongly advise against starting or even partaking 'is ____ art' discussions. They are long winded - and for no good reason.
I can't really tell if your post is blatant self promotion or not, but here's a couple of things - design/panelling is awkward. It's not really a 'comic', it's more like some text with accompanying images because the way you situated the 'narration' and the speech completely breaks the fact that there are even images to begin with.

It was mostly self-promotion, I'll more than likely just take the link down since so many people are offended by it. Also I REALLY appreciate the feedback I honestly can never get people to give me an honest opinion, and every bit of it helps so I can improve

[Fifty-50]

At 1/19/11 10:10 AM, BAvinnie wrote: It was mostly self-promotion, I'll more than likely just take the link down since so many people are offended by it. Also I REALLY appreciate the feedback I honestly can never get people to give me an honest opinion, and every bit of it helps so I can improve

How? We can't help you unless you post pics. It's quite pointless to seek advice if there is nothing to advise on.

Pics or it didn't happen.

[TurkeyOnAStick]

At 1/19/11 10:10 AM, BAvinnie wrote: since so many people are offended by it.

Woah, exagerrate much?

I'm not offended by it, it's just lame. Especially when you want people to criticise it, when it's on another site.

[Fifty-50]

Plus I checked your site and it's hard to navigate in it. So I got lazy and didn't view anything at all.

[BAvinnie]

Alright, I'm going to leave it at this for everyone, 1st to the guy who said its hard to navigate, not it's not but okay, two the link leads to a webcomic archive so, yes there is something to criticize(also I was thanking someone for giving feedback, and you're bitching about that too?) and 3rd when I said offended I meant everybody is BITCHING about their being a link and not a slew of pictures, so now that we have that out of the way completely please kindly leave it alone, I'm done replying to this and for future reference the best way to make something you don't like go away is to ignore it.

[Fifty-50]

At 1/19/11 10:40 AM, BAvinnie wrote: Alright, I'm going to leave it at this for everyone, 1st to the guy who said its hard to navigate, not it's not but okay, two the link leads to a webcomic archive so, yes there is something to criticize(also I was thanking someone for giving feedback, and you're bitching about that too?) and 3rd when I said offended I meant everybody is BITCHING about their being a link and not a slew of pictures, so now that we have that out of the way completely please kindly leave it alone, I'm done replying to this and for future reference the best way to make something you don't like go away is to ignore it.

Why can't you understand that you should post your damn pics in the forum? Is it too hard to ask to post a damn picture so we can put up some crits? I know you're probably too stupid to look through this thread again, but why the hell can't you understand simple instructions? So let me get this straight, you want us to go to your site and come back here to critique you? That's pretty stupid if you look at it. We shouldn't have gone through this if you read the damn rules in the first place. Are you too stupid for that too? Damn, I hate these kind of people.

[TurkeyOnAStick]

Allright, bye bye Princess.

I don't care for people who make mountains out of molehills, especially when they're only hurting themselves needlessly.