Support NATA 2014

Top 100 Art Reviewers List

  • 7,232 Views
  • 136 Replies
New Topic Respond to this Topic
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 12:27 AM Reply

Welcome to the first official Top Art Reviewers list. Previous list can be seen here.

Milestones:
500 Art Reviews - XwaynecoltX
100 Art Reviews - amyrenee, AppleLPfreak, NeverZone, RandomlyArtistic
200 Art Review Responses - XwaynecoltX
100 Art Review Responses - GenericJosh

June 1st, 2010 Update
#_ | Rev | Resp | Gain | Resp Gain || Username
01 | 946 | 534 | 042 | 31 || TheRealShadman
02 | 550 | 230 | 063 | 39 || XwaynecoltX 1
03 | 492 | 152 | 000 | 00 || msg2007 -1
04 | 403 | 189 |-001 |-01 || Dn83
05 | 375 | 166 | 028 | 12 || comicretard
06 | 353 | 144 | 007 | 05 || thepetergriffin
07 | 261 | 060 | 001 | 00 || Cometa-Guavaberry
08 | 242 | 133 | 001 | 00 || Sabtastic
09 | 238 | 136 | 002 | 01 || LegolaSS
10 | 234 | 071 | 006 | 02 || Hoboweasel
11 | 231 | 088 | 016 | 05 || spac3case916
12 | 197 | 086 | 033 | 15 || MAM259 8
13 | 190 | 114 | 003 | 02 || JakBaronKing-1
14 | 189 | 113 | 073 | 30 || GenericJosh 34
15 | 186 | 116 | 008 | 02 || dante224 -2
16 | 183 | 079 | 015 | 07 || Kinsei01 2
17 | 180 | 116 | 008 | 06 || Coop83 -3
18 | 178 | 099 | 009 | 05 || MindChamber -3
19 | 173 | 090 | 004 | 02 || sucho -3
20 | 171 | 063 | 028 | 11 || 7swords 10
21 | 168 | 083 | 000 | 00 || ZeWitchkid -4
22 | 164 | 071 | 001 | 01 || bloo-apple -3
23 | 163 | 112 | 007 | 03 || Haggard 1
24 | 161 | 083 | 000 | 00 || Hulalaoo -3
25 | 161 | 056 | 006 | 00 || Kreeslak
26 | 160 | 112 | 000 | 01 || Gamerx8 -4
27 | 160 | 074 | 001 | 01 || THEANTIFULP -4
28 | 154 | 046 | 001 | 00 || CrysisWolf -2
29 | 153 | 077 | 006 | 03 || ZaneZansorrow
30 | 153 | 072 | 000 | 00 || doppleganger -3
31 | 153 | 066 | 000 | 00 || CuteLolipop -3
32 | 146 | 051 | 004 | 02 || bocodamondo
33 | 145 | 072 | 000 | 00 || perfectedidiot2 NEW!
34 | 144 | 069 | 006 | 03 || dommi-fresh -1
35 | 144 | 050 | 001 | 00 || BULLETEGG -4
36 | 140 | 052 | 018 | 07 || GothicFreak119 6
37 | 137 | 055 | 000 | 00 || NeoZechs NEW!
38 | 135 | 082 | 014 | 07 || BizzaroJoe 5
39 | 135 | 081 | 000 | 00 || stigmaa NEW!
40 | 135 | 060 | 003 | 02 || HarraH -5
41 | 135 | 029 | 000 | 00 || Catsonmyface -7
42 | 133 | 077 | 007 | 04 || Famiry -6
43 | 131 | 041 | 008 | 03 || VidGameDude -3
44 | 129 | 037 | 003 | 01 || TheBigHero -7
45 | 128 | 042 | 015 | 07 || kazumazkan
46 | 128 | 038 | 009 | 06 || littek -1
47 | 125 | 044 | 000 | 00 || Craptaco -9
48 | 124 | 061 | 002 | 00 || TheManofSteal13 -7
49 | 124 | 051 | 000 | 00 || yahuwa -10
50 | 124 | 046 | 019 | 09 || johannek NEW!


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 12:28 AM Reply

51 | 123 | 059 | 002 | 01 || Wasim -7
52 | 123 | 053 | 005 | 04 || Botar -6
53 | 119 | 054 | 000 | 00 || deathslayer
54 | 118 | 080 | 002 | 02 || Fro -5
55 | 118 | 039 | 001 | 01 || Ritzcrakerz -8
56 | 115 | 057 | 000 | 00 || PixelCake
57 | 115 | 040 | 000 | 00 || Ray80
58 | 114 | 033 | 000 | 00 || kakashi1930
59 | 113 | 041 | 000 | 00 || Trash-man-1-9
60 | 111 | 044 | 000 | 00 || majoramaster
61 | 110 | 072 | 000 | 00 || Joshsouza
62 | 108 | 059 | 000 | 00 || CanadianBlues
63 | 107 | 037 | 000 | 00 || ThePunisher9000
64 | 105 | 031 | 000 | 00 || RickyBarbosa
65 | 104 | 063 | 000 | 00 || amyrenee
66 | 103 | 034 | 000 | 00 || AppleLPfreak
67 | 101 | 029 | 000 | 00 || NeverZone
68 | 100 | 042 | 000 | 00 || RandomlyArtistic
69 | 100 | 037 | 000 | 00 || joovyXL
70 | 100 | 034 | 000 | 00 || HiryuGouki
71 | 099 | 063 | 000 | 00 || gladiatorofchaos
72 | 098 | 030 | 000 | 00 || eightball6219
73 | 097 | 048 | 000 | 00 || kreal-84
74 | 091 | 037 | 000 | 00 || llarss
75 | 096 | 050 | 000 | 00 || FurryOwlet
76 | 096 | 043 | 000 | 00 || vellcrif
77 | 096 | 038 | 000 | 00 || aba1
78 | 095 | 050 | 000 | 00 || DJ-Delinquent
79 | 095 | 047 | 000 | 00 || LinaInverseFan
80 | 095 | 045 | 000 | 00 || Kaptain-Karmel
81 | 095 | 039 | 000 | 00 || Finale
82 | 093 | 035 | 000 | 00 || ThePdiddlings
83 | 092 | 059 | 000 | 00 || Aronkong
84 | 092 | 048 | 000 | 00 || jamnth1
85 | 092 | 031 | 000 | 00 || xellon
86 | 091 | 038 | 000 | 00 || jeeshwa123
87 | 090 | 043 | 000 | 00 || Esn
88 | 088 | 059 | 000 | 00 || acid-burn
89 | 086 | 057 | 000 | 00 || Supersteph54
90 | 084 | 030 | 000 | 00 || Auntjemimatron
91 | 083 | 036 | 000 | 00 || Zombiffix
92 | 082 | 017 | 000 | 00 || Evilpumpkinman
93 | 081 | 037 | 000 | 00 || automagicashie
94 | 081 | 035 | 000 | 00 || hawkmuffinz
95 | 081 | 024 | 000 | 00 || JasonXXL
96 | 081 | 018 | 000 | 00 || potatoboy37
97 | 080 | 032 | 000 | 00 || chainsawmurderer53
98 | 079 | 037 | 000 | 00 || lenkobiscuit
99 | 079 | 028 | 000 | 00 || Bailstuh
100| 078 | 056 | 000 | 00 || TheFlameAlchemist

===634 New Reviews and 319 New Responses===

Most Art Reviews Gained: GenericJosh - 73 Reviews
Most Art Reviews Lost: Dn83 - -1 Review
Most Responses Gained: XwaynecoltX - 39 Responses
Most Responses Lost: Dn83 - -1 Response
Best Review Percentage: TheFlameAlchemist - 71.79%

Top Five Gainers
#_ | Gain || Username
01 | 73 || GenericJosh
02 | 63 || XwaynecoltX
03 | 42 || TheRealShadman
04 | 33 || MAM259
05 | 28 || comicretard

Top Five Response Gainers
#_ | Gain || Username
01 | 39 || XwaynecoltX
02 | 31 || TheRealShadman
03 | 30 || GenericJosh
04 | 15 || MAM259
05 | 12 || comicretard

Top Five Review Response Percentage
#_ | Percentage || Username
01 | 71.79% || TheFlameAlchemist
02 | 70.00% || Gamerx8
03 | 68.71% || Haggard
04 | 67.80% || Fro
05 | 67.05% || acid-burn


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 12:42 AM Reply

Awesome. Awesome to the max!

General Notes: I'm sure I have a decent picture of the top 100, but no list is perfect all the time especially when the requirement to enter is so low comparatively speaking to other review lists. Find somebody, mention them here or in a PM.

Not to mention I think it'll be best to have this list monthly since these reviews are typically slow.

Enjoy!


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
XwaynecoltX
XwaynecoltX
  • Member since: Jan. 17, 2001
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 52
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 12:52 AM Reply

Nice

Its about time, i spend alot more time in the art portal these days, the reason why my flash reviews are down but on the plus my art reviews are on the up, so all is good, and this will be interesting.

ps: 2nd

heh i think anyways great first thread update.

~X~


~X~ ~X~ ~X~ (FOLLOW-ME)
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
POXNORA ??? A Very Unique game

BBS Signature
Auz
Auz
  • Member since: Feb. 23, 2005
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 55
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 02:45 AM Reply

Hey so you decided to finally create the official topic.

The list looks nice reverend. I like the addition of responses, although I suppose that might turn into a separate list eventually.

At 6/1/10 12:28 AM, reverend wrote: 100| 078 | 056 | 000 | 00 || TheFlameAlchemist

The requirements aren't that high yet, so I could make an appearance if I want. I don't care much for the art portal though, so meh... =/

Anyway thanks for this first update reverend! And I think monthly updating is indeed best for this list.


[Forum, Portal and Icon Mod]
Wi/Ht? #36 // Steam: Auz
The Top 100 Reviewers List (Last updated: 21 April 2014)

BBS Signature
Coop
Coop
  • Member since: Apr. 28, 2004
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 58
Writer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 03:00 AM Reply

At 6/1/10 12:27 AM, reverend wrote: Welcome to the first official Top Art Reviewers list. Previous list can be seen here.

Thanks for making this list, reverend. Great stuff.

14 | 189 | 113 | 073 | 30 || GenericJosh 34
15 | 186 | 116 | 008 | 02 || dante224 -2
16 | 183 | 079 | 015 | 07 || Kinsei01 2
17 | 180 | 116 | 008 | 06 || Coop83 -3
18 | 178 | 099 | 009 | 05 || MindChamber -3

Looks like I've got some work to do, if I'm going to keep the robot behind me :P

I can't believe that I allowed myself to be passed by 3 reviewers since the last update.

Speaking of updates, what schedule were you planning on using for updates? Once monthly? Bi-monthly?


Olympic standard B/Per *** Review Request Club
News
Post Stats Here!

BBS Signature
Haggard
Haggard
  • Member since: Dec. 25, 2001
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 54
Writer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 04:54 AM Reply

At 6/1/10 12:27 AM, reverend wrote: Welcome to the first official Top Art Reviewers list. Previous list can be seen here.

Thanks for this topic and the new update! :)
I like the idea of added responses, it keeps the number of stat lists in Wi/Ht down a bit. ^^

#_ | Rev | Resp | Gain | Resp Gain || Username
21 | 168 | 083 | 000 | 00 || ZeWitchkid -4
22 | 164 | 071 | 001 | 01 || bloo-apple -3
23 | 163 | 112 | 007 | 03 || Haggard 1

Awesome, almost in the top 20 already. But I have some more work to do, hopefully I'll find my motivation to review for the RRC again soon enough.


Surf Nazis must die! || Wi/Ht? #38 || Review Request Club || NG Logs || METAL-ABC (Last update: 04. March 2012)

sixflab
sixflab
  • Member since: Jun. 30, 2007
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 27
Gamer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 04:59 AM Reply

Looks pretty snazzy to me. I didn't even know you were compiling an art reviews list Reverend. I like how the responses are also included in the list. The requirement for the list is still really really low which means i'll eventually climb up on here even if I only review the art that comes into the RRC.

tyler2513
tyler2513
  • Member since: Jan. 6, 2009
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 30
Gamer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 08:47 PM Reply

Amazing list it was just a matter of time before this was made and I knew it. Very nice job you've
done with it good luck with the next update.


BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 1st, 2010 @ 09:15 PM Reply

At 6/1/10 12:52 AM, XwaynecoltX wrote: ps: 2nd

heh i think anyways great first thread update.

Yes, I can say safely say that you are second.

At 6/1/10 02:45 AM, Auz wrote: The requirements aren't that high yet, so I could make an appearance if I want. I don't care much for the art portal though, so meh... =/

Heh, the secret is out now and there is going to be more interest in art reviewing; so you better get started. :)

At 6/1/10 03:00 AM, Coop83 wrote: Speaking of updates, what schedule were you planning on using for updates? Once monthly? Bi-monthly?

I stated monthly, but I'm not sure if it's going to be the First Tuesday as I mentioned in my newspost or just have it on the 1st of each month. You guys can decide that.

At 6/1/10 04:54 AM, Haggard wrote: Thanks for this topic and the new update! :)
I like the idea of added responses, it keeps the number of stat lists in Wi/Ht down a bit. ^^

I'm ready to email my spreadsheet if you want to the Responses. Ha!

At 6/1/10 04:59 AM, sixflab wrote: Looks pretty snazzy to me. I didn't even know you were compiling an art reviews list reverend. I like how the responses are also included in the list. The requirement for the list is still really really low which means i'll eventually climb up on here even if I only review the art that comes into the RRC.

Awesome.

So guys, is there anything that needs to be tweaked or computations you want to see?


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
sixflab
sixflab
  • Member since: Jun. 30, 2007
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 27
Gamer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 2nd, 2010 @ 02:20 AM Reply

At 6/1/10 09:15 PM, reverend wrote: So guys, is there anything that needs to be tweaked or computations you want to see?

Well the one thing that I would say about the list is it's a bit bunched up and number filled. If there is a way to space it out a bit and align the columns better it would look better and be easier to read out.

ViceFullbuster
ViceFullbuster
  • Member since: Sep. 16, 2002
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 60
Melancholy
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 2nd, 2010 @ 01:42 PM Reply

It's great to see someone is getting around to do a list of the Top 100 Art Reviewers which should count as reviews just as much as Flash & Audio reviews,thanks much. =)


NOW IS WHEN YOU RAM HAPPY WITH LIFE SAUCE. PSN Screenname - Mooglejoke Wii U Network ID - Mooglejoke - Nintendo 3DS Friend Code 4768-8871-1657

BBS Signature
XwaynecoltX
XwaynecoltX
  • Member since: Jan. 17, 2001
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 52
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 4th, 2010 @ 06:11 PM Reply

At 6/2/10 01:42 PM, Molotov wrote: It's great to see someone is getting around to do a list of the Top 100 Art Reviewers which should count as reviews just as much as Flash & Audio reviews,thanks much. =)

Yeah it should count, :(

Ohwell i guess in time it will, so we can hope or just wait it out lol.

~X~


~X~ ~X~ ~X~ (FOLLOW-ME)
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
POXNORA ??? A Very Unique game

BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 30th, 2010 @ 10:10 PM Reply

July 1st, 2010 Update

Milestones:
600 Art Reviews - XwaynecoltX
200 Art Reviews - 7swords, Coop83, MAM259, MindChamber, and GenericJosh
100 Art Reviews - aba1, eightball6219, FurryOwlet, gladiatorofchaos, and llarss
100 Art Review Responses - MindChamber

Entering: SirCannabisClock and SUPER-JOHN-DOE
Leaving: Bailstuh and TheFlameAlchemist

#_ | Rev | Resp | Gain | Resp Gain || Username
01 | 958 | 541 | 012 | 07 || TheRealShadman
02 | 620 | 258 | 070 | 28 || XwaynecoltX
03 | 492 | 152 | 000 | 00 || msg2007
04 | 408 | 190 | 005 | 01 || DN83
05 | 388 | 173 | 013 | 07 || comicretard
06 | 362 | 148 | 009 | 04 || thepetergriffin
07 | 262 | 061 | 001 | 01 || Cometa-Guavaberry
08 | 245 | 136 | 003 | 03 || Sabtastic
09 | 240 | 137 | 002 | 01 || LegolaSS
10 | 237 | 074 | 003 | 03 || Hoboweasel
11 | 233 | 088 | 002 | 00 || spac3case916
11 | 222 | 072 | 051 | 09 || 7swords 8
13 | 213 | 087 | 016 | 01 || MAM259 -1
14 | 200 | 120 | 020 | 04 || Coop83 3
15 | 200 | 119 | 011 | 07 || GenericJosh -1
16 | 200 | 112 | 022 | 13 || MindChamber 2
17 | 198 | 117 | 012 | 01 || dante224 -2
18 | 194 | 118 | 004 | 04 || JakBaronKing-5
19 | 185 | 116 | 022 | 04 || Haggard 4
20 | 185 | 080 | 002 | 01 || Kinsei01 -4
21 | 182 | 096 | 009 | 06 || sucho -2
22 | 168 | 083 | 000 | 00 || ZeWitchkid -1
23 | 167 | 062 | 006 | 06 || Kreeslak 2
24 | 165 | 076 | 000 | 00 || SirCannabisClock New!
25 | 164 | 072 | 000 | 01 || bloo-apple -3
26 | 163 | 114 | 003 | 02 || Gamerx8
27 | 162 | 057 | 022 | 05 || GothicFreak119 9
28 | 161 | 083 | 000 | 00 || Hulalaoo -4
29 | 160 | 074 | 000 | 00 || THEANTIFULP -2
30 | 158 | 078 | 005 | 01 || ZaneZansorrow -1
31 | 158 | 059 | 027 | 18 || VidGameDude 12
32 | 155 | 073 | 002 | 01 || doppleganger -2
33 | 155 | 067 | 002 | 01 || CuteLolipop -2
34 | 154 | 046 | 000 | 00 || CrysisWolf -6
35 | 150 | 052 | 004 | 01 || bocodamondo -3
36 | 149 | 060 | 025 | 14 || johannek 14
37 | 147 | 087 | 012 | 05 || BizzaroJoe 1
38 | 147 | 073 | 002 | 01 || perfectedidiot2 -5
39 | 145 | 050 | 001 | 00 || BULLETEGG -4
40 | 144 | 069 | 000 | 00 || dommi-fresh -6
41 | 138 | 058 | 001 | 03 || NeoZechs -4
42 | 137 | 082 | 002 | 01 || stigmaa -3
43 | 137 | 079 | 004 | 02 || Famiry -1
44 | 137 | 043 | 009 | 01 || kazumazkan 1
44 | 137 | 039 | 008 | 02 || TheBigHero -1
46 | 135 | 061 | 000 | 01 || HarraH -6
47 | 135 | 029 | 000 | 00 || Catsonmyface -6
48 | 133 | 039 | 005 | 01 || littek -2
49 | 126 | 060 | 003 | 01 || Wasim 2
50 | 125 | 044 | 000 | 00 || Craptaco -3


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jun. 30th, 2010 @ 10:12 PM Reply

51 | 124 | 061 | 000 | 00 || TheManofSteal13 -3
52 | 124 | 053 | 001 | 00 || Botar
53 | 124 | 051 | 000 | 00 || yahuwa -4
54 | 119 | 054 | 000 | 00 || deathslayer -1
55 | 118 | 040 | 000 | 01 || Ritzcrakerz
56 | 117 | 079 | -01 | -01 || Fro -2
57 | 116 | 057 | 001 | 00 || PixelCake -1
58 | 115 | 040 | 000 | 00 || Ray80 -1
59 | 114 | 033 | 000 | 00 || kakashi1930 -1
60 | 113 | 072 | 003 | 00 || Joshsouza 1
61 | 113 | 042 | 000 | 01 || Trash-man-1-2
62 | 111 | 062 | 003 | 03 || CanadianBlues
63 | 111 | 044 | 000 | 00 || majoramaster -3
64 | 111 | 034 | 006 | 03 || RickyBarbosa
65 | 110 | 036 | 007 | 02 || AppleLPfreak 1
66 | 109 | 064 | 005 | 01 || amyrenee -1
67 | 109 | 033 | 008 | 04 || NeverZone
68 | 108 | 043 | 011 | 06 || llarss 6
69 | 107 | 037 | 000 | 00 || ThePunisher9000 -6
70 | 106 | 051 | 010 | 01 || FurryOwlet 5
71 | 105 | 041 | 005 | 04 || joovyXL -2
72 | 101 | 064 | 002 | 01 || gladiatorofchaos -1
73 | 101 | 045 | 001 | 03 || RandomlyArtistic -5
74 | 101 | 032 | 003 | 02 || eightball6219 -2
75 | 100 | 039 | 004 | 01 || aba1 2
76 | 100 | 034 | 000 | 00 || HiryuGouki -6
77 | 098 | 044 | 002 | 01 || vellcrif -1
78 | 097 | 048 | 000 | 00 || kreal-84 -5
79 | 097 | 046 | 002 | 01 || Kaptain-Karmel 1
80 | 097 | 040 | 002 | 01 || Finale 1
81 | 097 | 032 | 005 | 01 || xellon 4
82 | 095 | 061 | 007 | 02 || acid-burn 6
83 | 095 | 050 | 003 | 02 || jamnth1 1
84 | 095 | 050 | 000 | 00 || DJ-Delinquent -6
85 | 095 | 047 | 000 | 00 || LinaInverseFan -6
86 | 094 | 059 | 002 | 00 || Aronkong -3
87 | 094 | 047 | 004 | 04 || Esn
88 | 094 | 026 | 013 | 02 || JasonXXL 7
89 | 093 | 059 | 007 | 02 || Supersteph54
90 | 093 | 035 | 000 | 00 || ThePdiddlings -8
91 | 091 | 038 | 000 | 00 || jeeshwa123 -5
92 | 084 | 038 | 005 | 01 || lenkobiscuit 6
93 | 084 | 030 | 000 | 00 || Auntjemimatron -3
94 | 084 | 023 | 000 | 00 || SUPER-JOHN-DOE New!
95 | 083 | 037 | 000 | 01 || Zombiffix -4
96 | 082 | 035 | 001 | 00 || hawkmuffinz -2
97 | 082 | 018 | 000 | 00 || potatoboy37 -1
97 | 082 | 017 | 000 | 00 || Evilpumpkinman -6
98 | 081 | 038 | 000 | 01 || automagicashie -6
100 | 081 | 033 | 001 | 01 || chainsawmurderer53 -3

===640 New Reviews and 248 New Responses===

Most Art Reviews Gained: XwaynecoltX - 70 Reviews
Most Art Reviews Lost: Fro - -1 Review
Most Responses Gained: XwaynecoltX - 28 Responses
Most Responses Lost: Fro - -1 Response
Best Review Percentage: Gamerx8 - 69.94%

Top Five Gainers
#_ | Gain || Username
01 | 70 || XwaynecoltX
02 | 51 || 7swords
03 | 27 || VidGameDude
04 | 25 || johannek
05 | 22 || MindChamber

Top Five Response Gainers
#_ | Gain || Username
01 | 28 || XwaynecoltX
02 | 18 || VidGameDude
03 | 14 || johannek
04 | 13 || MindChamber
05 | 09 || 7swords

Top Five Review Response Percentage
#_ | Percentage || Username
01 | 69.94% || Gamerx8
02 | 67.52% || Fro
03 | 64.21% || acid-burn
04 | 63.72% || Joshsouza
05 | 63.44% || Supersteph54


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
Haggard
Haggard
  • Member since: Dec. 25, 2001
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 54
Writer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 1st, 2010 @ 02:33 AM Reply

At 6/30/10 10:10 PM, reverend wrote: July 1st, 2010 Update

Thanks for the update!

#_ | Rev | Resp | Gain | Resp Gain || Username
17 | 198 | 117 | 012 | 01 || dante224 -2
18 | 194 | 118 | 004 | 04 || JakBaronKing-5
19 | 185 | 116 | 022 | 04 || Haggard 4

Woohooo, a +4 gain means that I just entered the top 20. Awesome!
Good thing that I finished the art requests for the RRC yesterday...
JakBaronKing is a bit farther away, but 9 reviews aren't that much. If he doesn't pick up on reviewing I might pass him on the next update.


Surf Nazis must die! || Wi/Ht? #38 || Review Request Club || NG Logs || METAL-ABC (Last update: 04. March 2012)

CloudEater
CloudEater
  • Member since: Oct. 17, 2009
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 02
Blank Slate
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 1st, 2010 @ 03:21 AM Reply

My efforts have gone unnoticed D:
Thanks for doing this Reverend.

Jolly
Jolly
  • Member since: Jun. 6, 2008
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 40
Programmer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 1st, 2010 @ 04:36 AM Reply

I might try to get on this list.

Coop
Coop
  • Member since: Apr. 28, 2004
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 58
Writer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 1st, 2010 @ 06:53 AM Reply

At 6/30/10 10:10 PM, reverend wrote: 13 | 213 | 087 | 016 | 01 || MAM259 -1
14 | 200 | 120 | 020 | 04 || Coop83 3

Thanks for the update, reverend - nice work.

I wonder if I'll be able to get past MAM259 over the next month... Still, I'll be carrying on reviewing over the next few weeks and perhaps there is a project coming up that might interest you all?

Ooh, the suspense!


Olympic standard B/Per *** Review Request Club
News
Post Stats Here!

BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 1st, 2010 @ 08:43 AM Reply

Two things:
Obviously, 7swords should be at 12, TheBigHero at 45, Evilpumpkinman at 98, and automagicsashie at 99.

damn edit button not working

Also, the next update should be August 1st.

At 6/2/10 02:20 AM, sixflab wrote: Well the one thing that I would say about the list is it's a bit bunched up and number filled. If there is a way to space it out a bit and align the columns better it would look better and be easier to read out.

Unfortunately NG tends to strip out excess spaces. So I would have to use a symbol or more zeros to add space.

At 6/2/10 01:42 PM, Molotov wrote: It's great to see someone is getting around to do a list of the Top 100 Art Reviewers which should count as reviews just as much as Flash & Audio reviews,thanks much. =)

That's really up to Bahamut. It'll probably happen once art reviews become fully functional and listed on the front of the userpage i.e the time of NG's next face lift. Otherwise, he would have to the get the art reviews for the Pentalist manually.

At 7/1/10 03:21 AM, CloudEater wrote: My efforts have gone unnoticed D:
Thanks for doing this reverend.

Got ya now. Welcome. :)

At 7/1/10 04:36 AM, Jolly wrote: I might try to get on this list.

"Do or do not; there is no try."

Not to mention, please write a review that consists of more than one sentence please; you're critiquing not commenting.

At 7/1/10 06:53 AM, Coop83 wrote: . . . perhaps there is a project coming up that might interest you all?

Ooh, the suspense!

My interest has been peaked. What sort of project?


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
Jolly
Jolly
  • Member since: Jun. 6, 2008
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 40
Programmer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 1st, 2010 @ 06:08 PM Reply

I should be on this list now. I've gotten quite a few reviews, and I made a review template which will hopefully improve the quality of my reviews.

reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 1st, 2010 @ 11:13 PM Reply

So you wrote approximately 40 reviews in the span of 14 hours? Do you not see anything wrong with that?

When you write a review, you are really should be doing it for the author since it's he/she that is reading them. It's meant to tell them your opinion of their work, whether you enjoyed it hated it, found it humorous, etc. And that goes not just for Art, but for any medium: Movies, Games, Audio, etc.

Using you last review as an example:
"Pros: -Great drawing -Great Shading"
So what was so great about it? Did the piece achieve it's goal in humoring you, striking fear, driving some emotion, etc. What about the shading? How does it affect the piece? What are some items that are a defining feature of this work?

"Cons: -Kind of bland, colorwise."
Okay, so what colors would make this piece better. Does it need to be lighter, darker, more red, blue, etc. What other items that were off-putting that you gave this piece a 5/10. Was this piece unoriginal, did it not create interest, what are something that you might have done differently?

I'm not saying you have to write a narrative each review, but you have to be more specific. For example, if I was reviewing the Mona Lisa it would go something like this:

"This is a wonderful lifelike piece of a young beautiful woman. I really like the fine detail of her face, especially her half smile. Some of the thing I don't particularly care for are the colors. I think you could have use less yellows and overall it just seems a little dark. I'm also not to fond of the background. I'm not quite sure if that's suppose to be a road or a stream back there. Despite that, this is a great realistic piece and I enjoyed it very much. Keep up the good work!"

A few sentences of what I like, a few sentence of what I didn't, and a summary; that's it. Just from now on please be constructive, because it's the rules.


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
Jolly
Jolly
  • Member since: Jun. 6, 2008
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 40
Programmer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 2nd, 2010 @ 04:58 AM Reply

At 7/1/10 11:13 PM, reverend wrote: So you wrote approximately 40 reviews in the span of 14 hours? Do you not see anything wrong with that?

When you write a review, you are really should be doing it for the author since it's he/she that is reading them. It's meant to tell them your opinion of their work, whether you enjoyed it hated it, found it humorous, etc. And that goes not just for Art, but for any medium: Movies, Games, Audio, etc.

Using you last review as an example:
"Pros: -Great drawing -Great Shading"
So what was so great about it? Did the piece achieve it's goal in humoring you, striking fear, driving some emotion, etc. What about the shading? How does it affect the piece? What are some items that are a defining feature of this work?

"Cons: -Kind of bland, colorwise."
Okay, so what colors would make this piece better. Does it need to be lighter, darker, more red, blue, etc. What other items that were off-putting that you gave this piece a 5/10. Was this piece unoriginal, did it not create interest, what are something that you might have done differently?

I'm not saying you have to write a narrative each review, but you have to be more specific. For example, if I was reviewing the Mona Lisa it would go something like this:

"This is a wonderful lifelike piece of a young beautiful woman. I really like the fine detail of her face, especially her half smile. Some of the thing I don't particularly care for are the colors. I think you could have use less yellows and overall it just seems a little dark. I'm also not to fond of the background. I'm not quite sure if that's suppose to be a road or a stream back there. Despite that, this is a great realistic piece and I enjoyed it very much. Keep up the good work!"

A few sentences of what I like, a few sentence of what I didn't, and a summary; that's it. Just from now on please be constructive, because it's the rules.

Is this better?

"Pros:
You make the most high quality artwork than anybody in the Portal. I love all of your work. It's purely amazing. I love everything about this. And I do mean everything. INCLUDING your signature. You defiantly deserve to be a professional artist, if you're not already.

My favorite part of this is the face. You did amazing on it. Most people have one thing I don't like when it comes to the face, but you don't. The nose, eyes, and mouth looks absolutely amazing. The hair is perfect as well. I think you did absolutely perfect on everything on her head.

The clothes look amazing as well. They have so much details. I love it. The clothes are perfect as well.

I think the environment is the best of all. Everything from the leafs on the tree to the grass on the ground looks absolutely amazing. They have so much details. Everything in this piece of art is absolutely perfect. This is by far, in my honest opinion, the best piece of art on NewGrounds.

Cons:
I don't really have any cons for this. It's amazing. But, if I had to pick one thing, and it's a very small thing which defiantly will not bring down my rating, it's the little white in the bottom right corner.
"

Or should I continue to improve?

Domo
Domo
  • Member since: Nov. 11, 2009
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 22
Gamer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 2nd, 2010 @ 05:18 AM Reply

This is a cool thread.Those threads of top users for something like the top 300 voting pow users or top 100 medal getters.And it takes dedication to make this thread and keep up with it.I could never do that cause i am to lazy.But why is it in the where is/how to? forum


BBS Signature
Coop
Coop
  • Member since: Apr. 28, 2004
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 58
Writer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 2nd, 2010 @ 05:26 AM Reply

At 7/1/10 08:43 AM, reverend wrote:
At 7/1/10 06:53 AM, Coop83 wrote: . . . perhaps there is a project coming up that might interest you all?

Ooh, the suspense!
My interest has been peaked. What sort of project?

You'll see *returns to shed, with "TOP SECRET" sign painted on the door in red* I've got a few things to iron out first :P

At 7/2/10 04:58 AM, Jolly wrote: Or should I continue to improve?

You've got some time to think about what you did wrong with your reviews - short and shit has never been good, if you're getting noticed in the lists.

At 7/2/10 05:18 AM, domo48 wrote: But why is it in the where is/how to? forum

Because we don't have a stats forum. That wouldn't work, anyway.

I guess it's from people asking "How can I find who has the most [stat]s?", which over time has produced all of these lists.


Olympic standard B/Per *** Review Request Club
News
Post Stats Here!

BBS Signature
XwaynecoltX
XwaynecoltX
  • Member since: Jan. 17, 2001
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 52
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 3rd, 2010 @ 07:54 PM Reply

Sorry so late on this i been busy getting things ready for FAN-FEST at work, its gonna be 5 days of hell at this show before the allstar game which im proud to say is down here in anheim, where i live and work woot woot.

But anyways Thanks for an awsime effort on the top art reviewers list, it is looking pretty good, and i look forward to more of these awsome and great updates.

~X~


~X~ ~X~ ~X~ (FOLLOW-ME)
= = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = = =
POXNORA ??? A Very Unique game

BBS Signature
sixflab
sixflab
  • Member since: Jun. 30, 2007
  • Offline.
Forum Stats
Member
Level 27
Gamer
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 3rd, 2010 @ 08:26 PM Reply

At 7/1/10 08:43 AM, reverend wrote: Unfortunately NG tends to strip out excess spaces. So I would have to use a symbol or more zeros to add space.

I've always wondered about this and I guess it makes sense that they would remove all of the excess so everything is compacted. Other than that though the list looks great. You've done an excellent job of tracking people down, for the most part, with the art reviews still not being completely viewable.

Wegra
Wegra
  • Member since: Feb. 21, 2006
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Member
Level 45
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 10th, 2010 @ 02:09 PM Reply

At 7/2/10 12:30 PM, Dew wrote: Ahh this reminds me of Retrograde, how I miss that wonderful art portal site. It's a good thing you're finally starting this up, it'll encourage some more art reviews.

That's funny you remember that site. Ah those were the days.

But what surprises me more is that I never even knew that we were being credited for Art reviews. How long has this been going on? Because I don't recall keeping track of art reviews when the portal first opened up. Eh, maybe I just need to be on here more often.

Cool list though!


I have a penis

BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Jul. 10th, 2010 @ 04:46 PM Reply

At 7/2/10 04:58 AM, Jolly wrote: Is this better?

Better, but your first paragraph sounds like you're being sarcastic.

At 7/2/10 05:26 AM, Coop83 wrote: You'll see *returns to shed, with "TOP SECRET" sign painted on the door in red* I've got a few things to iron out first :P

So I guess, Top Responses was the secret project; awesome. I wonder who will be bold and pick up the Total Reviews.

At 7/10/10 02:09 PM, Wegra wrote: But what surprises me more is that I never even knew that we were being credited for Art reviews. How long has this been going on? Because I don't recall keeping track of art reviews when the portal first opened up. Eh, maybe I just need to be on here more often.

It wasn't until Mid-April before the Art Reviews were available in the profiles and even then it's just a number and isn't fully visible. After the redesign it will be and hopefully it will be listed on the front of each userpage like the other reviews.


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature
reverend
reverend
  • Member since: Nov. 3, 2003
  • Online!
Forum Stats
Moderator
Level 49
Movie Buff
Response to Top 100 Art Reviewers List Aug. 1st, 2010 @ 12:02 AM Reply

August 1st, 2010 Update

Milestones:
1,000 Art Reviews: TheRealShadman
500 Art Reviews: msg2007
400 Art Reviews: comicretard
200 Art Reviews: dante224, Haggard, JakBaronKing, and Kinsei01
100 Art Reviews: Kaptain-Karmel
100 Art Review Responses: sucho

Entering: Ashman, BlackStarZ117, CloudEater, Jolly, Krazytwin26, OnionsXD, sixflab, and WeirdAlthe3rd
Leaving: Auntjemimatron, automagicashie, chainsawmurderer53, Evilpumpkinman, hawkmuffinz, potatoboy37, SUPER-JOHN-DOE, and Zombiffix

#_ | Rev | Resp | Gain | Resp Gain || Username
01 | 1007 | 573 | 049 | 32 || TheRealShadman
02 | 639 | 270 | 019 | 12 || XwaynecoltX
03 | 502 | 157 | 010 | 05 || msg2007
04 | 409 | 192 | 001 | 02 || DN83
05 | 409 | 175 | 021 | 02 || comicretard
06 | 368 | 148 | 006 | 01 || thepetergriffin
07 | 262 | 061 | 000 | 00 || Cometa-Guavaberry
08 | 255 | 087 | 033 | 15 || 7swords 4
09 | 246 | 139 | 006 | 02 || LegolaSS
10 | 245 | 136 | 000 | 00 || Sabtastic -2
11 | 242 | 078 | 005 | 04 || Hoboweasel -1
12 | 233 | 088 | 000 | 00 || spac3case916 -1
13 | 219 | 136 | 019 | 16 || Coop83 1
14 | 215 | 089 | 002 | 02 || MAM259 -1
15 | 214 | 124 | 014 | 12 || MindChamber 1
16 | 206 | 120 | 006 | 01 || GenericJosh -1
17 | 205 | 126 | 011 | 08 || JakBaronKing 1
18 | 201 | 126 | 003 | 09 || dante224 -1
19 | 201 | 088 | 016 | 08 || Kinsei01 1
20 | 200 | 132 | 015 | 16 || Haggard -1
21 | 188 | 100 | 006 | 04 || sucho
22 | 182 | 072 | 024 | 13 || VidGameDude 9
23 | 177 | 068 | 010 | 06 || Kreeslak
24 | 173 | 062 | 011 | 05 || GothicFreak119 3
25 | 168 | 083 | 000 | 00 || ZeWitchkid -3
26 | 165 | 116 | 002 | 02 || Gamerx8
27 | 165 | 076 | 000 | 00 || SirCannabisClock -3
28 | 164 | 076 | 009 | 03 || doppleganger 4
29 | 164 | 072 | 000 | 00 || bloo-apple -4
30 | 164 | 069 | 009 | 02 || CuteLolipop 3
31 | 163 | 082 | 005 | 04 || ZaneZansorrow -1
32 | 162 | 098 | 015 | 11 || BizzaroJoe 5
33 | 161 | 083 | 000 | 00 || Hulalaoo -5
34 | 161 | 074 | 001 | 00 || THEANTIFULP -5
35 | 160 | 067 | 011 | 07 || johannek 1
36 | 154 | 046 | 000 | 00 || CrysisWolf -2
37 | 150 | 052 | 000 | 00 || bocodamondo -2
38 | 149 | 073 | 002 | 00 || perfectedidiot2
39 | 148 | 042 | 011 | 03 || TheBigHero 6
40 | 147 | 084 | 010 | 05 || Famiry 3
41 | 147 | 046 | 010 | 03 || kazumazkan 3
42 | 146 | 070 | 002 | 01 || dommi-fresh -2
43 | 145 | 050 | 001 | 00 || BULLETEGG -4
44 | 144 | 059 | 006 | 01 || NeoZechs -3
45 | 140 | 091 | 000 | 00 || OnionsXD NEW!
46 | 138 | 083 | 001 | 01 || stigmaa -4
47 | 136 | 063 | 001 | 02 || HarraH -1
48 | 136 | 041 | 003 | 02 || littek
49 | 135 | 029 | 000 | 00 || Catsonmyface -2
50 | 131 | 051 | 000 | 00 || Krazytwin26 NEW!


Rev 22:20 || Wi/Ht? # 46 || Why was my review deleted? || Without her, we are lifeless satellites drifting.

BBS Signature