Forum Topic: Movie > Book

(158 views • 8 replies)

This topic is 1 page long.

<< < > >>
Kissing

Ass-Crumb

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 03:23 PM

Ass-Crumb LIGHT LEVEL 05

Sign-Up: 03/31/07

Posts: 1,857

So NG, I'm sure you've heard atleast one person in your life whine about "oh the book was way better than the movie because it had more description and was more detailed and wah wah.."

Well, this thread is for movies that completely surpassed the book in some way or another. I'd also count comic book movies too.

To start, Fight Club. Sure the book was good, but the movie was just better in pretty much all aspects. It had a more memorable ending and better characters.

This signature is a pretty cool guy. eh quotes Dannyzx DOESN'T AFRAID OF ANYTHING.

The End: A written epic about the apocalypse

BBS Signature

None

Otto

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 03:25 PM

Otto DARK LEVEL 11

Sign-Up: 03/31/07

Posts: 8,321

While the film was epic, I still like the Fight Club book more.. there really is no example of a better film than book besides film renditions of child-hood stories, but more often than not they are butchered anyway.

This is a song about cum on hotel walls. - Fippity-fap-fipfap. Bonus fap.

BBS Signature

None

Sekhem

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 03:31 PM

Sekhem EVIL LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 02/20/06

Posts: 10,300

A Clockwork Orange.
The Shining.
Psycho.
City of God.
Die Hard.
The Godfather.
No Country for Old Men.
There Will Be Blood.

Also not a movie but the TV show Dexter is much better than the books it's based on.

Think about this; think about how stupid the average person is, and then realize that half of them are stupider than that.

BBS Signature

None

CuteAndFuzzy

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 03:32 PM

CuteAndFuzzy LIGHT LEVEL 21

Sign-Up: 06/08/04

Posts: 5,740

At 10/19/09 03:31 PM, Sekhem wrote: Psycho.

Possibly the best example of this.

.

BBS Signature

None

ryanson209

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 03:33 PM

ryanson209 NEUTRAL LEVEL 13

Sign-Up: 07/19/05

Posts: 1,107

The Outsiders, I guess.
With Tom Cruise and some minor douchebag instead of a major one :D

Consistency is for people who have no life. Live to the fullest, or at least try damnit
Life is a performance, and the world is full of critics.

Myspace|Facebook|Twitter

BBS Signature

Happy

Rabid-Animals

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 04:38 PM

Rabid-Animals LIGHT LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 08/20/05

Posts: 861

One Flew Over the Cuckoo's Nest. The book was unbearable.


None

agustana

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 04:46 PM

agustana FAB LEVEL 24

Sign-Up: 12/07/06

Posts: 1,751

At 10/19/09 03:23 PM, Ass-Crumb wrote: To start, Fight Club. Sure the book was good, but the movie was just better in pretty much all aspects. It had a more memorable ending and better characters.

I agree that the book was better than the movie, but I don't think the movie had 'better characters'.

Every word you read of this useless fine print is another second off your life.

BBS Signature

None

agustana

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 04:48 PM

agustana FAB LEVEL 24

Sign-Up: 12/07/06

Posts: 1,751

At 10/19/09 04:46 PM, agustana wrote:
At 10/19/09 03:23 PM, Ass-Crumb wrote: To start, Fight Club. Sure the book was good, but the movie was just better in pretty much all aspects. It had a more memorable ending and better characters.
I agree that the book was better than the movie, but I don't think the movie had 'better characters'.

I mean, movie was better than the book*

Every word you read of this useless fine print is another second off your life.

BBS Signature

None

estrago1

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 10/19/09 04:54 PM

estrago1 DARK LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 05/10/09

Posts: 479

Considering that all movies start out as books (or manuscripts), I would say just about all of them. But if you mean the movies that were based on actual books, like Harry Potter, then I would say that there are very few movies, if any, that surpass the book. Books DO give a lot more detail than the movie. Besides, its fun to try and imagine what a piece of scenery looks like. That's the joy of reading books: you can make it look like you want it to.

But movies do come in handy for things you are confused about in a book. The movie can also enhance the story. Like rock operas that were made into movies, like The Wall. It just really depends on the type of book and the type of movie that is made.

BBS Signature

All times are Eastern Standard Time (GMT -5) | Current Time: 05:54 PM

<< Back

This topic is 1 page long.

<< < > >>
You need a Grounds Gold Account to post on the NG BBS! If you don't have one, click here to sign up now! It's fast, free, and easy — and opens up tons of great NG features!