At 10/11/09 01:49 AM, TheReno wrote:
So I like what you got so far writer. You really got your scene down pat. Very grim and gritty and grimy and nasty. I just wish for one thing. What does the drill man look like? You can skip over and get away with not telling us what the boss looks like, but not the guy whose drilling into the main characters back. You didnt specifiy if he was out of the range of vision but most (in many books at movies) stories have it set for when the character wakes he sees his imprisoner.
Other then that this is a great start. It would be nice that when you continue on for him to have dreamt of happy things of past or present to starkly contrast his current prediciment. Your story makes me want to read more. Good job.
I'll be revealing more of both characters as the story progresses. It's going to be a long one, so there's no need to rush things. I'm glad you like what I've got so far, thanks.
As for your story, well insofar as the punk themes go, you've got a great concept. I think now that you've got that down, your main point of focus should be the horror aspect of the story, as that didn't nearly come off as strongly as I would have liked (as far as my opinion is concerned anywho). I think the point of conflict was nice and intense, what with the threatening suffocation and all that, I just think the build up to that could use more tension and give a greater importance to the horror climax than to the specific workings of the ship. I'd suggest telling those details as if the narrator belongs within that world and is telling others within that world the story instead of explaining everything in too fine of a detail. The world is your world, and your world should feel as natural and real as possible. Here's where the term "Show, don't tell" becomes of great importance.
One thing I like to focus on when I'm writing is the selection of information. As the author of my own stories, I should know everything about them. The characters. Their backgrounds. The settings. The plot, conflict and resolution. I know everything, but what the reader knows is only what I write on the page. I could tell you right now what the drill man looks like or what the boss looks like, or even the boss's name, but I won't because I've chosen to release those bits of information at a later point in time, to give significance to certain things over others. As you said yourself, my story made you want to read more, which means that I must be doing something in all this right. My narrator is the character, and while I know everything, he only knows what's happening right there and then. So I think it's important to know your narrator as well, and know how he chooses to tell the story.
That's just some of the stuff I've been going over in some of my classes, hope it'll be helpful.
Like I said, you've got a great punk concept and a well defined world. I suggest working on how you tell your story, and other than that, just spelling, grammar, sentence structure etc. I'd love to see this story fleshed out some more and polished up. As you mentioned, it's what you've got so far, so I look forward to seeing what your end result looks like.