best LoZ

[deathofghosts]

What do you think the best LoZ game is

[Castilveinya]

None of them.

[Chdonga]

All of them except Spirit Tracks.

[Castilveinya]

At 9/24/09 04:04 PM, Chdonga wrote: All of them except Spirit Tracks.

Still better than CD-I

[levusbevus]

At 9/24/09 04:04 PM, Chdonga wrote: All of them except Spirit Tracks.

God damnit not this again...

[TCD2008]

At 9/24/09 04:04 PM, Chdonga wrote: All of them except Spirit Tracks. it's gonna be way better then AOL(worst cannon zelda)

and i think the model they use for zelda games should be different for ds. if i wanna play the same shit over and over i'll play the console zeldas ,all except tp &oot they are the only zeldas+ that inovate without either having hugh flaws(ww-too easy too short) or being too different(mm) +i'm only counting the 3d ones as while i like the 2nd ones the 3d ones are more fun to me.
oh and favorites oot&tp

[Jerich0]

At 9/24/09 04:00 PM, Castilveinya wrote: None of them.

Agreed there all bad.

[IrishGun]

Wind Waker.

You know?

The only decent one?

[malachi117]

At 9/24/09 05:15 PM, IrishGun wrote: Wind Waker.

You know?

The only decent one?

Oh my god.

We're soulmates.

[Sun-Wukong]

Obvious trolls are obvious. Also, Majora's Mask.

[Aigis]

At 9/24/09 05:15 PM, IrishGun wrote: Wind Waker.

You know?

The only decent one?

I find it bizarre that you can like Wind Waker, but not like any of the other games in the series that are exactly the same as Wind Waker.

Anyway, I'm going to go with Twilight Princess as the best one.

It had the most enjoyable story, and that's really the only thing that sets them apart from each other, aside from the graphics (WHICH DON'T MATTER, HYUK HYUK).

[TCD2008]

At 9/24/09 05:30 PM, Aigis wrote:

At 9/24/09 05:15 PM, IrishGun wrote:

Wind Waker. my third favorite is your fav? weird.

You know?
The only decent one?(whoa! wtf? is wrong with have you played oot & Tp? if not i guess your somewhat right)

I find it bizarre that you can like Wind Waker, but not like any of the other games in the series that are exactly the same as Wind Waker.(not really but unless you only played ww and phg)
Anyway, I'm going to go with Twilight Princess as the best one.me too but for diffulcultly and wii version.
It had the (2nd)most enjoyable story, and that's really the only thing that sets them apart from each other, aside from the graphics (WHICH DON'T MATTER, HYUK HYUK).

[brother-of-vegeta]

Link to the Past, the only logical answer!

[Zwe]

Link's Awakening and Wind Waker. Haven't finished LttP or Oot. Note that I enjoy games with 'wake' in them.

[MrPercie]

Best LoZ? I would have to say OoT only because the newer ones are just a remake of OoT but with a 20% graphics increase and different story and very few new things were added.

[Aci6]

At 9/24/09 03:45 PM, deathofghosts wrote: What do you think the best LoZ game is

The Minnish Cap with no exceptions.

[SoulMaster71]

It's hard to choose. A Link to the Past was the innovator, creating the current gameplay dynamic for the series. Ocarina of Time was the biggest technological jump: ALttP had only to define a system within the traditional 2D world from the first game, but OoT had to make the jump to the entirely new 3D Hyrule. Majora's Mask had the most engaging storyline to yet make it into a Zelda game, with characters being involved and involving. And Twilight Princess is the most artistically refined game of the series thus far, featuring the best possible versions of earlier music and about as good of graphics as you can get on the Gamecube and the Wii.

[Kunera]

I'd have to say A Link to the Past.

[simon]

You know when people know what the fuck they're talking about in Zelda when not everyone is screaming "OCARINA OF TIEMZ" as their first answer. My respect for Newgrounds forums has gone up.

As for my choice, A Link To The Past.

[slackerzac]

Majora's Mask hands down.

[llnuclearmuffins]

majora mask, zoralinkwin

[Advertise-Play]

I only own the one for Gameboy and this classic plays great.

[dmansland]

Ocarina of Time. It's just so memorable and even the new games have nostalgic moments about that game.

[Crashman]

Ocarina of Time was a good transition of 2D to 3d but Wind Waker and the Oracle Series for GB were my favorite.

Got the 4-Game Disc, Link to the Past, Link's Awakening, Wind Waker and someone is borrowing me Oracles. Twilight again for Wii someday.

[Dr-Worm]

I personally think that the best game overall is A Link to the Past, simply because everything just comes together so nicely, especially the gameplay, which is more or less perfect (something that can't be said for the understandably sometimes clunky Ocarina of Time and the slightly less understandably far too easy Twilight Princess). The items are all put to good use throughout the game instead of just being one-dungeon gimmicks. The graphics are gorgeous for 16-bit, and the world is filled with color and detail. The dungeons are challenging without being frustrating, and the boss fights are some of the series' best. The music is some of gaming's most memorable. What's not to like?

Ocarina of Time comes close, though. It has quite possibly the best original soundtrack of any game ever. The gameplay is obviously top-notch, though there are some flaws and frustrating moments here and there. Most of all, though, it displays the series' setting, general atmosphere, characters, overarching plotline, and themes (basically, all the storytelling elements) in a kind of broad, sweeping way that none of the other games in the series have been able to match before or since. Somehow, even though most of the other games in the series portray their worlds in much more detail, Ocarina of Time's still seems the most fully realized.

And of course the other games have their own merits. Wind Waker is by far the best looking game in the series, and kind of reminds me of a Disney movie (I mean this in the best way possible), though its climax and ending are oddly some of the series' most mature and philosophically complex moments. Twilight Princess is sleek, modern (as modern as Nintendo gets, anyway), and the most cinematic and action-packed game in the series. Majora's Mask takes the story and basic gameplay tools to some very unexpected, dark, weird, and most of all fascinating places. And of course, the original game not only started off the whole series, but arguably pioneered the entire realm of the narrative video game.

So yeah, with just a few exceptions, Zelda can really do no wrong.

P.S. I know I'm neglecting the handheld games here, but I haven't played them in a very long time. But um...yeah, they're all good.

[beautheschmo]

It's a toss-up between Link's Awakening, MM, and WW. They were all exceptional games. Also interesting is that these three are the only one's I've played that break away from the traditional Hyrule universe of the games (I haven't played the Oracle games or MC, so I don't know where they are). Maybe I'm allergic? Or something.

[TCD2008]

i really think the new zelda game will be good enough to win over some of the "o.o.t will never be topped" and"lttp will never be topped" people. really if you reallly think about with a couple exceptions(ww,aol,mm) all zelda are basically the same, except in story(o.o.t's is the best),difulculty(tp is my fav here),graphics(which mater, but only a little),& unique to that game iteams(tp's ball'n chain,ww's deku leaf,etc.)

[ghdude85]

this is hard one...

i must say that A Link to the Past is the best game. sometimes a little hard but i figured it out somehow xD the game is just pure awsome. with the best story, gameplay, items and map. even though the map could feel a little small, but that was fixed by adding the dark world or the sacred realm.

also WindWaker was pretty good. i had my doubts about the graphics, but i just didn't care after getting the story and the hang of it.

Majoras Mask sure is the hardest and most challenging one. i'm still not done xD i can't beat the water temple boss xD (i'm a noob)

also the 4 sword story is cool, adding Vaati as enemy. Minish cap is my favorite "4 sword" game. and 4S Advanture as 2nd, but i never bother playing it once more, so if you ask me, 4SA have no re-run value.

Twilight Princess was also very cool. it was a darker game and maybe a little deeper then many of the others.

and we can't forget OoT which more or less set the new basics in zelda gameplay and graphics. i remember i was pretty sure i was alsmost done with the game after getting the Zora Sapphire, but instead i just had 5 temples + ganons castle to go xD

Phantom Hourglass was ok. i didn't like the Ocean King Temple though. it made the game to repetive. and Spirit Tracks seems to be very much the same, but with trains and not boats. still gonna get the game so i'll be busy over some time.

[Racoonmario]

Majora's Mask.

[Psychopathic-Mind]

Personally I like Majora's Mask the best. It was one of my first games, so I really got drawn into it. The story was good, the gamplay was good, the music was awesome, it was a great game.