At 9/14/09 10:21 PM, kikomannnn wrote:
I really can't have a civilized discussion with you because you have such a vehement distaste for any rap that isn't Necro or whatever god awful back backer shit you listen to. Ignoring this.
I don't even know what necro-rap is, and I'm pretty sure I would never listen to it. I also don't like rap in general, yeah, but I don't mind some rap. I respect rappers like the Rza, Busta Rhymes, Chali 2na, and some others. They have some okay stuff. Generally, older rap is superior to the stuff that plays on the radio these days.
Regardless, I'm talking about Kanye relative to other rap and hip-hop. I'm not saying that Kanye is shit because it's rap, I'm saying he's shit because he is shit even within his genre.
Sampling a bass line and 2 lines of lyrics over a drum machine and Kanye West trying to perform is the kind of sampling I was referring to. That is the most common and easily arranged type of sampling that is around. Kanye West didn't pioneer anything at all.
At this time, no one was combining those type of sounds and getting it played on mainstream radio. So no, Kanye is not the fucking messiah of rap trends, but he made exceptional music at the time.
If by that you mean he made music that was better than his competition when it came out, then that's just not saying a whole lot. You even said earlier that the genre was flooded with shitty dance garbage, and that's all Kanye had to compete with. I'm sure that if you took that as a still frame in the context of music and put Kanye's stuff next to the other stuff, then yeah, he'd probably seem god, but when you compare him to other musicians and producers within the same genre from earlier/later times, he just doesn't stand out nearly as much.
However, when you take thousands of records and take bites from them to arrange several coherent and good sounding songs that sound absolutely seamless is an entirely different matter.
Opinions. They're fun to have aren't they?
Kanye West is good at sampling. This is not an opinion, this is fact. He can create a well structured song out of a sampled portion and overdub it with instruments.
I still don't understand why you think this makes him good. That is the industry standard at the moment. Any hip hop producer can make a structured song with a couple samples and some extra orchestration. Of course Kanye can do that, thousands of people can, and they can do it better and without having egos the size of the Hindenburg.
You need to separate his personality from his music. Yes, Kanye is a douchebag. I AGREE WITH YOU. But if thousands of people can do what he's doing, why aren't they? Why aren't they making tracks like H to the Izzo, Flashing Lights, Good Life? He happens to be the guy doing it, and these tracks are examples of good production in hip hop. If you don't like it, then I'm sorry lol. Cry me a fucking river.
Flashing lights is the only Kanye song that has a beat that I will admit I enjoy. However, as soon as Kanye's voice is audible, the song goes downhill from there. He managed to ruin his own song just by being in it. If he would just stop doing his shitty fucking vocals and work for someone else who had actual vocal talent, then maybe I'd consider listening to his work, even though I find his music really simple by means of production, rhythm modes, instrumentals, etc. when compared to the music that I actually enjoy listening to. But no, that's not the case, so his average skills as a producer are overshadowed by his insistence upon doing the vocals, which make his music very unpleasant to listen to.
BY using only samples, the Avalanches are actually making a challenge for themselves. You yourself said that it was hard to arrange samples, and you were talking about the way Kanye does it, with only a few pieces of sampled tracks. The Avalanches utterly outdo him on the scale of complexity, and they even sound better. If you think that Kanye's sampling is impressive, then there's no way that you could deny that the song I just posted is mind-blowing.
it sounds lovely. Too bad it's not hip hop. When you compare two different genres, it's fun to make retarded comparisons. Jimmi Hendrix and Rakim are compared. OMG HENDRIX can do it WAY bEDDur! Two different genres, both are quality examples of skill in their respective genres...
I'm not talking about this in respect to GENRE, you dumb shit, I'm talking about the technique of SAMPLING as a music feature, which both Kanye and The Avalanches obviously are both involved in. Genre has nothing to do with it.
You seem to be under the impression that Kanye is doing something that no one else in hip-hop has ever done before, and that's just not true. Leading an orchestra is something I would expect a musician/producer to be able to do if he wants to keep his job.
Really. Because I never said that Kanye was the first producer to use live musicians and orchestras and what not. I just said he's good at what he does, because he is, and you are trying to base your opinion as fact. That's why this debate will never end.
And yet you just said
I just said he's good at what he does, because he is
as if it were fact, making you no better than I am.
I don't recall saying he was a thief, but paying royalties really makes no difference to me at all. He shouldn't be praised for sourcing where he obtained his samples, that should be considered common practice.
This doesn't make sense now that you claim to acknowledge that there are good examples of sampling so I'm just going to ignore it.
I was referring to sampling as used by modern hip-hop artists.
cool man!