Forum Topic: Review Request Club

(22,556 views • 1,192 replies)

This topic is 40 pages long. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 92440 ]

<< < > >>
None

JKMonkey

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/2/09 12:26 PM

JKMonkey LIGHT LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 04/05/08

Posts: 9,727

Hey guys, quick question, do you have to do all the reviews on the list?

just asking

Misunderstood

MultiCanimefan

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/2/09 12:37 PM

MultiCanimefan LIGHT LEVEL 20

Sign-Up: 12/19/06

Posts: 4,381

Can a review mod delete one of my reviews? I forgot to put the little -Review Request Club- at the end and it's driving me INSANE. I'm obsessive-compulsive, and I literally will NOT be able to live with this.

England I Canada Now STFU.

BBS Signature

None

JKMonkey

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/2/09 12:51 PM

JKMonkey LIGHT LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 04/05/08

Posts: 9,727

At 7/2/09 12:37 PM, MultiCanimefan wrote: Can a review mod delete one of my reviews? I forgot to put the little -Review Request Club- at the end and it's driving me INSANE. I'm obsessive-compulsive, and I literally will NOT be able to live with this.

^^ I just did the same thing and it pissed me off, I wish there was some way to automatically put it on the bottom.


None

Haggard

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/2/09 03:12 PM

Haggard EVIL LEVEL 39

Sign-Up: 12/25/01

Posts: 3,950

At 7/2/09 12:26 PM, JKMonkey wrote: Hey guys, quick question, do you have to do all the reviews on the list?

just asking

Just do as many as you like. ;)

Surf Nazis must die! || Wi/Ht? #38 || Review Request Club || NG Logs || Game Quiz #21


Happy

blackcat2000

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 10:28 AM

blackcat2000 DARK LEVEL 22

Sign-Up: 04/04/06

Posts: 168

Finally done my animation... It wasn't as good as I thought it would be 5 seconds before i submitted it, but it's something! Check it out- I need your reviews ;)

Reviewing is good for your health!

BBS Signature

None

AnalPenguinFarming

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 11:13 AM

AnalPenguinFarming EVIL LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 08/23/04

Posts: 2,916

Nice work recreating a good group. I'm in. I'll start with the next list. If I'm accepted. Hopefully you have room for an ex-reviewer.

Yea, I farm Anal Penguins. Do something about it.

BBS Signature

Winking

SCTE3

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 11:32 AM

SCTE3 LIGHT LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 07/19/05

Posts: 10,837

At 7/3/09 11:13 AM, AnalPenguinFarming wrote: Nice work recreating a good group. I'm in. I'll start with the next list. If I'm accepted. Hopefully you have room for an ex-reviewer.

You haven't made a review in ages it seems and your latest review was in April, your reviews check out as OK to me, don't see why you can't join the crew. The list is now going to be kept posted on sonofkirk's 9th news post and t he weekly point updates will still come. If you've read the thread you don't have to review all of them, just review what you would like to review. The more reviews you complete the better.

Current to do list: here.

Just need to do those audio reviews at the bottom of the last page and all reviews posted on this page thus far.


None

Fro

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 12:02 PM

Fro LIGHT LEVEL 30

Sign-Up: 04/12/04

Posts: 9,208

Don't worry you don't have to tell APF how to review or how the club works man. He was here a little bit before you were if I'm not mistaken. He's also one of the best reviewers on the entire website so we really don't have much to worry about quality wise either. ;)


None

SCTE3

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 12:13 PM

SCTE3 LIGHT LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 07/19/05

Posts: 10,837

At 7/3/09 12:02 PM, Fro wrote: Don't worry you don't have to tell APF how to review or how the club works man. He was here a little bit before you were if I'm not mistaken. He's also one of the best reviewers on the entire website so we really don't have much to worry about quality wise either. ;)

Alrighty then, I guess that makes this club a little stronger now and helps the community more, yay, welcome back old member APF D: . Also finished all reviews up to this post, may go hunting up some audio or flashes that have no review, probably makes the user all warm inside to notice someone actually cared to give them a nice little review. =]


Happy

Sonofkirk

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 01:25 PM

Sonofkirk DARK LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 04/14/07

Posts: 1,311

At 7/3/09 11:13 AM, AnalPenguinFarming wrote: Nice work recreating a good group. I'm in. I'll start with the next list. If I'm accepted. Hopefully you have room for an ex-reviewer.

Awesome, as Cork... Fro said, you are one of the best reviewer on the site and you are a returning member, you don't even have to ask to be accepted and no need to post your points next week. That's good to see how the new club can get former members out of the their reviewing inactivity, I hope you will enjoy your stay ;). *Warm/gay hugs*

-----

I will update the list on Sunday morning but I'm not sure when exactly. I'll probably pull the stats the morning and then create the update post a bit later in the day, therefore the update should be up around 2:00 GMT +2. Be sure that you reviewed the requests from THAT list.


None

bribri123123

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 01:27 PM

bribri123123 EVIL LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 07/02/09

Posts: 8

May I join? I would like to give people honest reviews on their game :)


None

Fro

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 01:31 PM

Fro LIGHT LEVEL 30

Sign-Up: 04/12/04

Posts: 9,208

At 7/3/09 01:27 PM, bribri123123 wrote: May I join? I would like to give people honest reviews on their game :)

I would say no from what you have written so far. Now you can go out and write some good reviews and then perhaps you may join. Take a look at some of the other members reviews to see how you should review to be a part of this club. Your reviews more resemble youtube comments. :/


None

JKMonkey

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 02:28 PM

JKMonkey LIGHT LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 04/05/08

Posts: 9,727

At 7/3/09 11:32 AM, SCTE3 wrote:
Just need to do those audio reviews at the bottom of the last page and all reviews posted on this page thus far.

^^ same here, i'm going to get those done now

when do we post how many points we have? Today or tomorrow?

None

MultiCanimefan

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 02:31 PM

MultiCanimefan LIGHT LEVEL 20

Sign-Up: 12/19/06

Posts: 4,381

At 7/3/09 02:28 PM, JKMonkey wrote:
At 7/3/09 11:32 AM, SCTE3 wrote:
when do we post how many points we have? Today or tomorrow?

Anytime before this Sunday.

England I Canada Now STFU.

BBS Signature

None

JKMonkey

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 03:19 PM

JKMonkey LIGHT LEVEL 23

Sign-Up: 04/05/08

Posts: 9,727

At 7/3/09 02:31 PM, MultiCanimefan wrote:
Anytime before this Sunday.

OK, ill have to do it today because I probably wont be able to get on tomorrow, this week I have a total of 146 points. 53 points for Flash Reviews, 66 points for Audio Reviews, 17 points for Art Reviews, plus 3 points for posting atleast once during the week, and plus 7 for doing all the requested Reviews for teh week.


None

AnalPenguinFarming

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 04:13 PM

AnalPenguinFarming EVIL LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 08/23/04

Posts: 2,916

At 7/3/09 12:02 PM, Fro wrote: Don't worry you don't have to tell APF how to review or how the club works man. He was here a little bit before you were if I'm not mistaken. He's also one of the best reviewers on the entire website so we really don't have much to worry about quality wise either. ;)

Aw what nice things people have said about me. Thanks guys. I'll make sure I live up to the reputation. Hopefully Bahamut is still posting in here because I always loved reviewing/watching his movies. Some of the funniest flash work on NG was what he was making. See you all in the flash section!

Yea, I farm Anal Penguins. Do something about it.

BBS Signature

None

SCTE3

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 04:25 PM

SCTE3 LIGHT LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 07/19/05

Posts: 10,837

At 7/3/09 04:13 PM, AnalPenguinFarming wrote: Aw what nice things people have said about me. Thanks guys. I'll make sure I live up to the reputation. Hopefully Bahamut is still posting in here because I always loved reviewing/watching his movies. Some of the funniest flash work on NG was what he was making. See you all in the flash section!

I haven't seen that bugger post a new flash in quite awhile. Pretty sad actually, maybe he'll post here when he makes a new flash sometime, he seems to be pretty busy maintaining 2 lists in the WI/HT forum and other things.


Happy

NEVR

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 04:28 PM

NEVR LIGHT LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 06/29/05

Posts: 10,753

Two of my favourite art pieces that I've submitted so far, would like a bit of feedback on them if ya'll please ;)

Colin
Mike (colour)

I name all my art pieces by random names. >_>

[ NG Review & BBS Moderator ] +++ @ @ @ +++ Backseat modding, clarified. +++ {<3 Karl for the sig}

BBS Signature

None

bribri123123

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 08:35 PM

bribri123123 EVIL LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 07/02/09

Posts: 8

I have just reviewed the two things NEVR put up. I did 2 different styles or reveiwing. Please tell me which is better. I dont thinkk I did too good on the art ones. i think I will do better when games are posted.

I have some questions on points. What is the benifeit of getting points? Do I only add the points on reviews people have requested?


None

AnalPenguinFarming

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 10:08 PM

AnalPenguinFarming EVIL LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 08/23/04

Posts: 2,916

At 7/3/09 08:35 PM, bribri123123 wrote: I have just reviewed the two things NEVR put up. I did 2 different styles or reveiwing. Please tell me which is better. I dont thinkk I did too good on the art ones. i think I will do better when games are posted.

I have some questions on points. What is the benifeit of getting points? Do I only add the points on reviews people have requested?

If I can step in for a moment, I'd just like to tell you that your reviews need work because you aren't giving any positive input as to what the artist has given you, or any input that will benefit the artist to make them better. They come to this thread for people to criticize their work and give them ideas to help them become better as flash artists. Take time with your reviews and let the artist know everything you're thinking.

Yea, I farm Anal Penguins. Do something about it.

BBS Signature

Resigned

SCTE3

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/3/09 11:10 PM

SCTE3 LIGHT LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 07/19/05

Posts: 10,837

Same as last post, deleted audio entry in last post so if a mod could please delete that post then thanks to the mod a lot.

Any ideas of how I can improve?


None

blackcat2000

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/4/09 10:29 AM

blackcat2000 DARK LEVEL 22

Sign-Up: 04/04/06

Posts: 168

Gave you whatever I could muster in regards to the audio portal on your Mail submission =X
I just looked back to page 2, and realized that no one has 'approved' me to do reviews fro the club... I've done 2 reviews within people requests, and a few others on new submissions, and don't really mind if I end up just reviewing without being on the scoreboard thing (I'd like to think I review to benefit others =D) but... should I be approved? Do I need to be? =O

Reviewing is good for your health!

BBS Signature

Happy

Sonofkirk

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/4/09 11:47 AM

Sonofkirk DARK LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 04/14/07

Posts: 1,311

At 7/4/09 10:29 AM, blackcat2000 wrote: Gave you whatever I could muster in regards to the audio portal on your Mail submission =X
I just looked back to page 2, and realized that no one has 'approved' me to do reviews fro the club...

Sorry I forgot to quote your applying post on the previous page. Yes you can join you reviews are good and you provide helpful and actual tips to the author.

Though you could work a bit on the style of your reviews, they are one block of text and as consequence a bit difficult to read. Try to divide your tips and critics into different paragraphs and if you need help check the reviews of any regular of this club :).


None

kiwi-kiwi

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/4/09 11:51 AM

kiwi-kiwi LIGHT LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 03/06/09

Posts: 645

Hello, first of all, thank you for all the reviews on my submission, they were all helpful and nice and I tried my best to give an appropriate response to each of them.
I would like to make a second request for another piece of art - Seaside Sunrise


None

bribri123123

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/4/09 11:57 AM

bribri123123 EVIL LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 07/02/09

Posts: 8

I really liked it kiwi :)


None

MultiCanimefan

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/4/09 01:06 PM

MultiCanimefan LIGHT LEVEL 20

Sign-Up: 12/19/06

Posts: 4,381

Ok, I know that the first time we post our points it can be the last, but would it hurt to post my points again anyway? I'm paranoid that when the next update is due, the added points from this week won't be taken into account.

England I Canada Now STFU.

BBS Signature

None

Soapbubble

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/4/09 07:52 PM

Soapbubble LIGHT LEVEL 21

Sign-Up: 06/12/04

Posts: 713

I'm thinking of joining this club when the summer is over, but the points system seems kinda confusing to me. I'll try to keep track of my points myself, but I'm a lazy kid, So I won't promise it. Back in a month or two!

I am not retarded.
Review Request Club - NG Viking Army


None

Fro

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/4/09 11:17 PM

Fro LIGHT LEVEL 30

Sign-Up: 04/12/04

Posts: 9,208

At 7/4/09 01:06 PM, MultiCanimefan wrote: Ok, I know that the first time we post our points it can be the last, but would it hurt to post my points again anyway? I'm paranoid that when the next update is due, the added points from this week won't be taken into account.

It won't hurt to post them every week if you want just to make sure Sonofkirk doesn't make any mistakes, but other than that there isn't a need or a point to it. Go ahead if you want and post them up. I know when I first became I member I posted my scores for the first month or so.

At 7/4/09 07:52 PM, Soapbubble wrote: I'm thinking of joining this club when the summer is over, but the points system seems kinda confusing to me. I'll try to keep track of my points myself, but I'm a lazy kid, So I won't promise it. Back in a month or two!

All you have to do is keep track of them the first week. They aren't confusing at all as long as you can read and comprehend some simple English and math. :P


None

Soapbubble

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/5/09 12:56 AM

Soapbubble LIGHT LEVEL 21

Sign-Up: 06/12/04

Posts: 713

At 7/4/09 11:17 PM, Fro wrote:
At 7/4/09 07:52 PM, Soapbubble wrote: I'm thinking of joining this club when the summer is over, but the points system seems kinda confusing to me. I'll try to keep track of my points myself, but I'm a lazy kid, So I won't promise it. Back in a month or two!
All you have to do is keep track of them the first week. They aren't confusing at all as long as you can read and comprehend some simple English and math. :P

English is my second language and I nearly failed maths.

Also, I'm leaving tomorrow and won't be back in like, a month, so... I'll do it after.

I am not retarded.
Review Request Club - NG Viking Army


None

Son-Of-Dime

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 7/5/09 06:03 AM

Son-Of-Dime DARK LEVEL 06

Sign-Up: 02/19/08

Posts: 12

The update will be posted at around 6:00 PM GMT+2. Have a nice day :).


All times are Eastern Standard Time (GMT -5) | Current Time: 11:23 PM

<< Back

This topic is 40 pages long. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 | 6 | 7 | 8 | 92440 ]

<< < > >>
You need a Grounds Gold Account to post on the NG BBS! If you don't have one, click here to sign up now! It's fast, free, and easy — and opens up tons of great NG features!