At 8/2/09 04:33 AM, Gooch wrote:
At 8/1/09 08:20 AM, Coop83 wrote:
So, you're saying that they should release him? That would go down in New York like the incident at 3 mile island.
Most definitely. I wouldn't release him, because he may be able to provide something for a couple of years while the Islanders get some young talent on that roster. Maybe if he's still not working out after that time, just try and trade him and see what you can get out of him. You'd probably be able to shell another prospect goalie in a trade for him, or just try and pick up one on the free agent market.
To release him though just wouldn't make much sense right now. I do agree that he's a bit overrated, but at least he's somewhat of a working cog in the New York Islanders' system.
I never said he should be released, I'm saying that at any viewpoint, no matter what the circumstance, a 15-year contract is absolutely retarded unless you know that this guy already has the skills to live up to a lifetime deal, like Henrik Zetterburg, for instance. He played for years in Detroit before they finally decided that they wanted him for the rest of his career. Vinny Lecavelier also played for a while before new management came into Tampa Bay and realized he should be there for the rest of his career. Rick DiPietro barely got out of the starting gate when NYI decided that he would shoulder the load for the next 15 years.
Certainly, there are some cases where it's unavoidable. Thomas Vanek, for example, was slapped with a nice 7-year $50 million offer sheet that he couldn't refuse by that idiot Kevin Lowe. The Sabres got stuck with matching that offer sheet due to the front office being absolutely God awful, letting go of Briere and Drury (yes, I'm still a bit bitter that we lost both of them) because of a stupid FO policy that there was to be no contract negotiating mid-season. For a player that had only gotten 2 NHL seasons under his belt, that contract was absurd, but since the Blades had already lost 2 key pieces, they couldn't afford to lose another one, no matter what the price. Luckily for the Sabres, he's panning out OK.
What I'm saying is that the RDP was a totally avoidable situation that did not have to result in 15 years of what could be serious skill, mediocrity, or failure. There was way too much uncertainty with that deal.