Forum Topic: New Metallica Sucks?

(1,787 views • 127 replies)

This topic is 5 pages long. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 ]

<< < > >>
None

Tabascork

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 04:49 PM

Tabascork DARK LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 05/13/06

Posts: 424

Your friends hate Death Magnetic because they grew up listening to that bullshit album St. Anger. St. Anger is hands down the worst Metallica album of all time. Death Magnetic falls back on Metallica's original style that made them insanely popular in the 80's and 90's.

The best Metallica album of all time? ...And Justice for All.

IMHO.


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 04:59 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

At 5/25/09 04:49 PM, Tabascork wrote: Your friends hate Death Magnetic because they grew up listening to that bullshit album St. Anger. St. Anger is hands down the worst Metallica album of all time. Death Magnetic falls back on Metallica's original style that made them insanely popular in the 80's and 90's.

The best Metallica album of all time? ...And Justice for All.

IMHO.

you're right and wrong. death magnetic sounds nothing like old metallica. its too loud. new metallica is just trying out to be more like current metal bands, which they shouldnt do. best metallica album was ride the lightning. although i do love ... and justice for all.

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


None

Mr-Money

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:05 PM

Mr-Money NEUTRAL LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 11/05/05

Posts: 2,781

The new Metallica definitely sucks.


None

2hot2rock

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:05 PM

2hot2rock NEUTRAL LEVEL 01

Sign-Up: 05/22/09

Posts: 99

At 5/25/09 04:59 PM, TheSporkLord wrote:
At 5/25/09 04:49 PM, Tabascork wrote: Your friends hate Death Magnetic because they grew up listening to that bullshit album St. Anger. St. Anger is hands down the worst Metallica album of all time. Death Magnetic falls back on Metallica's original style that made them insanely popular in the 80's and 90's.

best metallica album was ride the lightning. although i do love ... and justice for all.

ride the lightning is pretty cool but i just think its a clone of kill em all


None

Rucklo

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:06 PM

Rucklo NEUTRAL LEVEL 30

Sign-Up: 10/11/04

Posts: 15,830

Hey, this is like the third or fourth time Metallica are labelled "new" metallica?

get with it fools, a band that plays for that long is bound to evolve their sound, othervice they'd suck donkeyballs. fuck the whole metal mentality of being "true" to one sound or whatever, it's just so fucking gay... really really really REALLY gay. it's all just another general opinion some metalheads have that is based on the whole "belonging to this group" mentality, though they'd never admit it themselves. conservative motherfuckers, take of that fucking leatherjacket and at least fucking wash it, it smells like you died a couple of times innit. fucking disgusting piece of insecure donkeyball.


Happy

Skulsta

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:10 PM

Skulsta DARK LEVEL 05

Sign-Up: 03/06/08

Posts: 1,181

Metallica is one of the most popular bands around and one of my favorites. The new album doesn't suck, it's one of their best in years. Their last few albums went downhill, and so was the band until they came back with Death Magnetic. I actually prefer All Nightmare Long and Master of Puppets more than most of their older songs.

I went to a Metallica cover band concert a few weeks back and throughout the show, the crowd would shout "play Master of Puppets!!" until eventually the band decided to play it for the crowd, and throughout the song, the audience would sing along in the chorus lol.

If Heavy Metal is so evil, why would God create it? BECAUSE I FUCKING TOLD HIM TO, BITCH!!

BBS Signature

None

2hot2rock

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:12 PM

2hot2rock NEUTRAL LEVEL 01

Sign-Up: 05/22/09

Posts: 99

At 5/25/09 05:10 PM, Skulsta wrote: Metallica is one of the most popular bands around and one of my favorites.

yeah fucking awesome man lol. the only thing i cant stand now is Jame's haircut, he looks like a douche. :(


None

XtremeofParanoia

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:13 PM

XtremeofParanoia FAB LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 03/03/07

Posts: 511

At 5/24/09 08:16 PM, 2hot2rock wrote: im not gonna fight but, what is wrong with slipknot. they're amazing musicians and heavily underrated. their drummer joey is fucking insane, way better then overrated people like neil peart who play that gay 70s music and stuff.

I really hope you're a troll. But I doubt it... so...

Slipknot is the reason metal sucks today. Everyone in the band is a sub-par musician. Corey Taylor can't sing. The guitarists play power chords. There are two members who run around on stage and hit kegs with baseball bats (INTENSE MUSICIANSHIP THERE, EH?). They have a DJ... I mean normally, I wouldn't have to say anything more than that, but then on top of a guy who occasionally scratches a record, they throw some guy with a spiked mask in the mix to press a button to make creepy noises. The bassist does not even exist. I can't think of a single Slipknot song where the bass even comes close to pushing out of the rest of the noise.

And then theres Joey Jordison. The most over-rated drummer of the last 20 years. If you honestly think that Joey Jordison is one of the best drummers out there then you need to expand your horizons. Vitek from Decapitated, may he rest in peace, could drum faster and more cohesively than Jordison ever could, from his grave. For that matter, most death metal drummers could. And then you have drummers like Mike Mangini, Mike Portnoy, and Brian Mantia who absolutely shit on Joey Jordison without breaking a sweat.

/rage


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:14 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

At 5/25/09 05:12 PM, 2hot2rock wrote:
At 5/25/09 05:10 PM, Skulsta wrote: Metallica is one of the most popular bands around and one of my favorites.
yeah fucking awesome man lol. the only thing i cant stand now is Jame's haircut, he looks like a douche. :(

good metallica= awesome hair?...... its gotta be. once they cut there hair it went downhill
^ thats a joke just in case you took that seriously

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:21 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

At 5/25/09 05:13 PM, XtremeofParanoia wrote:
At 5/24/09 08:16 PM, 2hot2rock wrote:
Slipknot is the reason metal sucks today. Everyone in the band is a sub-par musician. Corey Taylor can't sing. The guitarists play power chords. There are two members who run around on stage and hit kegs with baseball bats (INTENSE MUSICIANSHIP THERE, EH?). They have a DJ... I mean normally, I wouldn't have to say anything more than that, but then on top of a guy who occasionally scratches a record, they throw some guy with a spiked mask in the mix to press a button to make creepy noises. The bassist does not even exist. I can't think of a single Slipknot song where the bass even comes close to pushing out of the rest of the noise.

And then theres Joey Jordison. The most over-rated drummer of the last 20 years. If you honestly think that Joey Jordison is one of the best drummers out there then you need to expand your horizons. Vitek from Decapitated, may he rest in peace, could drum faster and more cohesively than Jordison ever could, from his grave. For that matter, most death metal drummers could. And then you have drummers like Mike Mangini, Mike Portnoy, and Brian Mantia who absolutely shit on Joey Jordison without breaking a sweat.

/rage

i.love.you. i would've put dave lombardo on that list too, but whatever. and @ 2hot2rock: neil peart is amazing. and you dont understand what overrated means. neil peart is amazing and lemme guess, you dont like him because he doesnt do blast beats right? you probably judge drummers on how fast they go when theres much more than that. i.e. joey isnt even fast at all, its called ghost pedals. all he does is double bass, snare, cymbal. and the 70's had some of the most influential andm musically talented bands of all time. it didnt suck, if anything most bands of today suck.

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


None

igott

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 05:26 PM

igott NEUTRAL LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 12/30/07

Posts: 5,671

At 5/24/09 06:56 PM, BlueFlameSkulls wrote: Metallica was once good?

Wait, what? Someone said that? They must be stupid.

Click on the albums to see an extended version of the signature.

BBS Signature

None

2hot2rock

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 06:31 PM

2hot2rock NEUTRAL LEVEL 01

Sign-Up: 05/22/09

Posts: 99

At 5/25/09 05:13 PM, XtremeofParanoia wrote:
At 5/24/09 08:16 PM, 2hot2rock wrote: im not gonna fight but, what is wrong with slipknot. they're amazing musicians and heavily underrated. their drummer joey is fucking insane, way better then overrated people like neil peart who play that gay 70s music and stuff.
I really hope you're a troll. But I doubt it... so...

Slipknot is the reason metal sucks today. Everyone in the band is a sub-par musician. Corey Taylor can't sing. The guitarists play power chords. There are two members who run around on stage and hit kegs with baseball bats (INTENSE MUSICIANSHIP THERE, EH?). They have a DJ... I mean normally, I wouldn't have to say anything more than that, but then on top of a guy who occasionally scratches a record, they throw some guy with a spiked mask in the mix to press a button to make creepy noises. The bassist does not even exist. I can't think of a single Slipknot song where the bass even comes close to pushing out of the rest of the noise.

And then theres Joey Jordison. The most over-rated drummer of the last 20 years. If you honestly think that Joey Jordison is one of the best drummers out there then you need to expand your horizons. Vitek from Decapitated, may he rest in peace, could drum faster and more cohesively than Jordison ever could, from his grave. For that matter, most death metal drummers could. And then you have drummers like Mike Mangini, Mike Portnoy, and Brian Mantia who absolutely shit on Joey Jordison without breaking a sweat.

/rage

dude are you fucking serious? i mean you dont have to like them but dont bash on their musical skill. im not saying they're the best musicians in the world because this would obviously be untrue. but they are one of the most skilled metal bands musically. death metal is nothing but horrible strumming of minor notes and some guy screaming or growling sounding like hes trying to fit in to the safari or something.

corey has like 20 differnet voices in some songs he screams and others he sings slow, very good at it too. joeys awesome, you gotta hear his double bass drumming then you'll understand. now neil peart doesnt suck be he's highly overrated. hes mediocre id say.

just listen YYZ all he does is go "bum bum bum ba bum bum bum bum" or Tom Sawyer. im just saying joey would blow him out of the wind anyday. not to mention their singers sounds like a woman and add gay sound effects to their songs and stuff.

yeah maybe id listen to rush if i was taking a hit, but not rocking out, raging, and laughing about how much society sucks which is a mindset only slipknot can induce.


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 06:37 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

ok if you want good death metal listen to opeth, they own slipknot 100 times over. and you proved my point, all joey does is double bass and even then he cheats at it, reference to ghost pedals.also proved my point on neil peart, yes he does drum slow but it doesnt have to be super fast to be good. slipknot is also nu-metal not deathmetal so quiet. as for deathmetal sounding like growls mikael from opeth is 10 times better at singing than corey will ever be. people think slipknot is good because they have 9 people, so i could make a band with TWENTY people and everyone would think my band was good. in end slipknot is too simple, monkeys could replace that band.

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


None

2hot2rock

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 06:38 PM

2hot2rock NEUTRAL LEVEL 01

Sign-Up: 05/22/09

Posts: 99

At 5/25/09 06:37 PM, TheSporkLord wrote:

wow, youre so ignorant. go say that to a slipknot fans face


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 06:39 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

At 5/25/09 06:38 PM, 2hot2rock wrote:
At 5/25/09 06:37 PM, TheSporkLord wrote:
wow, youre so ignorant. go say that to a slipknot fans face

really? i have listened to every slipknot album so therefore i have every right to criticize them

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


None

BlackPlastic

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 06:59 PM

BlackPlastic EVIL LEVEL 24

Sign-Up: 02/28/06

Posts: 3,687

At 5/24/09 07:05 PM, InsertFunnyUserName wrote:
At 5/24/09 07:04 PM, 2hot2rock wrote: ok of course its just an opinion which you are entitled to, but how could anybody who likes metal not love metallica? they fucking rock. unless your some mainstream bullshit eating dumbass who likes hip hop, wtf?
Metallica has been mainstream since the Black Album.

They were mainstream before The Black Album. Hell, they were nominated for a grammy with ...And Justice For All.

BBS Signature

None

MegamanZero360

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:00 PM

MegamanZero360 FAB LEVEL 11

Sign-Up: 06/11/06

Posts: 1,191

I think someone should ban this queer, in his blog and now in the BBS all he's doing is attracting flamers and its pissing me off. Go fuck yourself, "2hot2rock".


None

2hot2rock

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:01 PM

2hot2rock NEUTRAL LEVEL 01

Sign-Up: 05/22/09

Posts: 99

At 5/25/09 07:00 PM, MegamanZero360 wrote: I think someone should ban this queer, in his blog and now in the BBS all he's doing is attracting flamers and its pissing me off. Go fuck yourself, "2hot2rock".

nobody here can ever have a conversation without fighting, not my fault douche


None

MegamanZero360

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:02 PM

MegamanZero360 FAB LEVEL 11

Sign-Up: 06/11/06

Posts: 1,191

At 5/25/09 07:01 PM, 2hot2rock wrote:
At 5/25/09 07:00 PM, MegamanZero360 wrote: I think someone should ban this queer, in his blog and now in the BBS all he's doing is attracting flamers and its pissing me off. Go fuck yourself, "2hot2rock".
nobody here can ever have a conversation without fighting, not my fault douche

People CAN have a conversation without fighting. It's called MAKING USEFUL AND NOT STUPID POSTS.


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:06 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

At 5/25/09 07:01 PM, 2hot2rock wrote:
At 5/25/09 07:00 PM, MegamanZero360 wrote:

nobody here can ever have a conversation without fighting, not my fault douche

ummm just look at your home page. its all one giant flame.

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


None

NeonFlame126

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:07 PM

NeonFlame126 NEUTRAL LEVEL 32

Sign-Up: 05/29/06

Posts: 6,267

AC/DC has done the same things for almost 30 years. They're still popular, and they sound great.

Gamertag: NeonFlame126
You can't spell FÜHRER without Ü
You know you fail in life when you fail to end your failure [Best Profile Ever]

BBS Signature

None

2hot2rock

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:33 PM

2hot2rock NEUTRAL LEVEL 01

Sign-Up: 05/22/09

Posts: 99

At 5/25/09 07:07 PM, NeonFlame126 wrote: AC/DC has done the same things for almost 30 years. They're still popular, and they sound great.

nah the ac/dc singer sounds more like a wannabe Dio


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:36 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

this isnt meant to start another arguement but since you're 13 this makes more sense. i've noticed that every slipknot fan i know eventually grew out of liking them. i too liked slipknot, then i listened to other bands and thought " dear god slipknot is bad" you may grow out of it, you may not.

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


None

evil-clown-12

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:37 PM

evil-clown-12 FAB LEVEL 16

Sign-Up: 06/30/06

Posts: 2,024

As much as I dislike Metal, I have some respect for Metallica in that their name doesn't scare me like the majority of metal bands.

PM me for free lockerz invites.

BBS Signature

Goofy

IamJJFishTruck

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:39 PM

IamJJFishTruck EVIL LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 05/23/05

Posts: 242

Metallica just plain sucks it hard, don't get me wrong I love metal, but Metallica is highly overrated.
But thats my opinion.
Don't like it? Suck it bitch, suck it dry.

~ And Cue the Freight Train ~


None

TheSporkLord

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:42 PM

TheSporkLord EVIL LEVEL 08

Sign-Up: 04/19/09

Posts: 1,001

At 5/25/09 07:39 PM, IamJJFishTruck wrote: Metallica just plain sucks it hard, don't get me wrong I love metal, but Metallica is highly overrated.
But thats my opinion.
Don't like it? Suck it bitch, suck it dry.

while i am not going to flame you i am just saying you dont hate metallica now. its just that there are heavier bands to like. that doesnt make metallica bad heavy metal.

" You're never really one with nature until you're smashed against the ground hiding under a bush."- Me
" I'm NOT A FISH, I'M A SASQUATCH " - Me
GUITARISTS


Winking

IamJJFishTruck

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:55 PM

IamJJFishTruck EVIL LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 05/23/05

Posts: 242

At 5/25/09 07:42 PM, TheSporkLord wrote:
At 5/25/09 07:39 PM, IamJJFishTruck wrote: Metallica just plain sucks it hard, don't get me wrong I love metal, but Metallica is highly overrated.
But thats my opinion.
Don't like it? Suck it bitch, suck it dry.
while i am not going to flame you i am just saying you dont hate metallica now. its just that there are heavier bands to like. that doesnt make metallica bad heavy metal.

Yeah I don't actually hate Metallica I was just being a typical smartass. While I dont hate Metallica I never go out of my way to listen to any of their songs.

~ And Cue the Freight Train ~


None

Fawktt

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:57 PM

Fawktt EVIL LEVEL 09

Sign-Up: 05/10/08

Posts: 516

I dont find any metallica to be good. Cut off my ears, i really dont care. Ive never thought metallica was all that good, i only like 1 song which is One only because the video Johnny with a gun is cool with that.

Boy: hey dad last night i had sex with my teacher ! Dad: Good job son are you ganna do it tomarrow Boy: no im ganna wait for my ass to heal.

Fawktt*


Questioning

UltimateAxl

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 07:59 PM

UltimateAxl LIGHT LEVEL 30

Sign-Up: 08/04/06

Posts: 3,738

I admit something I haven't expressed in a long time. Metallica have bunches of skills, and I'm not going to name Metallica "new", quite frankly, they're old. Metallica is Metallica, they all have the original members except the bassist.

I only own four albums, Master of Puppets, Black Album, Load, and Death Magnetic. I prefer Master of Puppets way more than those other three. I had a problem with Death Magnetic's quality, it was too compressed or some shit. The drums weren't very good.

Also, there is only one thing I don't like. It's the length of their songs, sure I can hear a story through the music, but not every song. I just can't listen to my iPod for one and a half hours listening to an album.

Go FAQ yourself new users! This cloudless night smells of fear... Keep my soul - dark and cold..

BBS Signature

Crying

sweaty-troll

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 5/25/09 08:12 PM

sweaty-troll LIGHT LEVEL 06

Sign-Up: 05/26/07

Posts: 11

unfortunately, new metallica does suck, they just lost their spark, and quite frankly after master of puppets (which is all genius btw) they started going downhill! When they play their old songs, from kill 'em all etc. They're not the same! They just...aren't. They arn't greasy acne riddled teenages anymore, they're old thrashers past their time!

Click HERE To visit my bands MySpace!

BBS Signature

All times are Eastern Standard Time (GMT -5) | Current Time: 10:20 AM

<< Back

This topic is 5 pages long. [ 1 | 2 | 3 | 4 | 5 ]

<< < > >>
You need a Grounds Gold Account to post on the NG BBS! If you don't have one, click here to sign up now! It's fast, free, and easy — and opens up tons of great NG features!