At 1/19/09 01:38 AM, djconnect wrote:
What do you think the best movie made from a book was? I say The harry Potter movies were the best. The followed the book almost perfectly, and had great production quality.
I'm sorry, but I couldn't follow the hype that came along with this series of books. I think that it started off alright, as the kids were getting into reading. I tried to read one myself once, but found them incredibly hard going to sit through, so I stopped. I watched the first Movie and found it poor. My parents wanted to go and see the second one, so I agreed - the most entertainment I got from it was when I spilled my popcorn over my brother.
Good movies made from good books. Look to Lord of the Rings, though they did miss things like Tom Bombardil (Would have made it slow and boring for Fellowship) and the Scouring of the Shire (That would have added something to the movie, I don't doubt) - you were never going to end up with a film that was totally faithful to the original text, considering how epic it was.
Now, I've watched Shogun, a TV adaptation of the book of the same name, made in the 1970s - it stayed faithful to the text, didn't have a massive budget for special effects, though being set in feudal Japan, it didn't really need much of one. Here is something that portrayed the life of the Samurai and the Bushido code better than Tom Cruise could possibly hope to in The Last Samurai