At 2/10/09 03:12 PM, Sprite-harvester wrote:
GAH! let's take a vote shall we? whoever likes the first one better say aye. whoever doesn't say nay. Or I can just choose myself. (If i choose myself I'd go wit the second one)
I say the second one. The first one to me looks like he's about to dance or like he's greeting his gangsta homeboy :S
What I did notice however, and this could help make the second one more powerful, is that there are three frames like this:
Frame 1: Normal position
Frame 2: Arms move up and are halfway inbetween the original position and frame 3
Frame 3: Arms are up in the air, scared reaction complete.
I suggest that you change the position of the arms in frame 2. Here's why:
When you react like this, the speed of the action will change throughout the action. First, speed must be build up, so the arms won't move much. The speed increases midway and then comes to a sudden stop. Because there's a lot of energy in the arms, they'll slow down some more a few frames, but will hardly move.
Here's a chart that shows you the position of the arms. The chart below indicates where each frame is at what time of the action. For example, if you were to space all frames out evenly, frame 2 and 5 being inbetweens, frame 3 and 4 should be at 1/3 and 2/3 of the action.
Frame 3 would have his arms 1/3 up and frame 4 would be 2/3 up.
Now, the frames are shown different. The middle of the action where his arms are halfway isn't shown at all. Instead, you have a build up to the swing of the arms (frame 1,2,3) and the end of the action (4,5,6).
The reason for this is that this is a fast action. In order to show people what is about to happen, you build up (anticipation). But you also have to show them what you've done by ending it.
The reason why we don't show the middle frame is that the action is fast. So if you were to draw that, it sticks out because the change is too big. Adding an inbetween wouldn't help because that would slow down the action, losing it's force and power.
I've spaced out all the frames on the right so you can take a closer look at how they look. To the left is how they look when animated and you can clearly see that there isn't a lot of change between frame 1, 2 and 3, as well as 4, 5 and 6. Of course, the color of the numbers correspond with the color of the frames above.