OK lets just say I was slightly irritated at the volume of cheesy A-minor based piano pieces that were clearly meant to be in death scenes of take-a-name-out-of-the-hat anime films and sound like they were whipped out in a couple of hours by playing some arpeggios and octaves then quantising, correcting erroneous notes, moving some of the melody and bass lines to other instruments and finally saving as a suitably loved up mp3. Lets just say that. Im not saying they're bad (a lot of them are nice listening), just...samey.
Now if I were to submit a solo piano piece that was all those things minus the quantising, correction and other instruments how would it go down? Does writing this post make any difference? If I submit a song and say, "I spent literally 10 minutes making this" and it turns out to be the most holyshitwtf piece youve ever heard (LOL never happen, Im not Yanni :P) would it make a difference to the judgement? Clearly there are some submissions which have taken many hours to refine. If I were to submit two pieces, one of which was the aforementioned lazybones route and one was a step in a completely different direction, what would be the judges feeling towards both?
I might not submit anything Im just curious in an evil kind of way. Also, I feel pretty sorry for the judges on this one a few of the songs (great as they are) really are that similar...will it come down to sample quality? Woot Im naughty.