1. We allow all submissions in now. There is no more barring/excluding/weeding
with that said.
A competition is aimed at a goal. It's a challenge set forth from a source with reward to those who can tackle the challenge the best (best being subjective via collection of judge votes here). We never said that this particular MAC was that open ended. The challenge was, and quite simply is, make a joyous song that reflects love you'd feel for somebody else. To use the fact it's based on Valentines and make a sad song and then assume you can win when the challenge is so obviously different, is foolish.
That's like taking a test on math and then writing an essay on elephants on the sheet. Brilliantly written maybe, but irrelevant to the question at hand.
Which is why I said, do you want to make the song to win, or to express yourself? Because yes you can express your sorrow and submit to the MAC and we WILL allow it in the judge list (and you just know a bunch of flash animators are going to be looking for sad songs ;D), but don't expect to win this MAC with it.
Am I saying something wrong here?