Forum Topic: Ign: Good Gaming Source Or Garbage?

(361 views • 35 replies)

This topic is 2 pages long. [ 1 | 2 ]

<< < > >>
Questioning

puddinN64

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/26/08 11:29 PM

puddinN64 LIGHT LEVEL 25

Sign-Up: 07/05/06

Posts: 4,345

Hey Newgrounds. I've recently been going on IGN.com to get some of my gaming news, but several people I know have told me that the site is crap (They keep bringing up the God Hand review..). So I just wanted to ask you guys if any of you had problems there.

Also, why would anyone want to pay for a subscription to the site? Is the content that amazing?

Please give some love to The Great One. He's Awesome.

I am neither a Wii, PS3, or 360 fanboy. I personally support Mattel and their Intellivision.

BBS Signature

None

seahawk95

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/26/08 11:35 PM

seahawk95 NEUTRAL LEVEL 10

Sign-Up: 02/01/08

Posts: 439

generally ign is pretty good review and news wise. but when u think about all gaming sites have flaws or a review contorversy. and no it's not worth the suscribtion unless u want to waste 15 bucks.

PS3 online username: seahawk95
add me if your good at hq in cod4 multiplayer, want to play co-op or competitive on resistance 2 or want tips or help in fallout 3 me bored?


Resigned

ParadoxVoid

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/26/08 11:37 PM

ParadoxVoid EVIL LEVEL 25

Sign-Up: 10/12/07

Posts: 4,074

I don't think it's that bad if you want to find a general opinion of a game, and they're pretty thorough on covering the features of games.

I would advise you take the scores and overall opinion of their writers with a grain of salt however. Their scoring and such can be a little erratic, and personal bias shows through in some reviews. Overall I find them competent enough as an online game site though.

But I would not pay for a subscription... idiots.

SSBC@_@TF2 Crew@_@TJPPC
Friend Codes
Steam ID, Xfire ID : ParadoxVoid

BBS Signature

None

KeithHybrid

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/26/08 11:39 PM

KeithHybrid LIGHT LEVEL 03

Sign-Up: 05/02/04

Posts: 2,925

Sometimes, IGN is good. Sometimes, it sucks. Either way, it's still hella better than Gamespot.

BBS Signature

None

BananaBreadMuffin

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/26/08 11:44 PM

BananaBreadMuffin FAB LEVEL 38

Sign-Up: 07/08/03

Posts: 43,177

IGN Writing >>>>>>>>>>> gamspot.com writing.

I usually go to IGN.

BBS Signature

None

MetalDart

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 12:16 AM

MetalDart LIGHT LEVEL 31

Sign-Up: 08/26/05

Posts: 9,518

Wii Baby Games scored higher than Mirror's Edge.
I shit you not.

Ign: Good Gaming Source Or Garbage?

http://www.newgrounds.com/bbs/topic /777777
http://metaldart.webs.com/ My freewebs website. Check it out dog.
My old NG profile ID: 1321019

BBS Signature

None

AshfordPride

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 02:21 AM

AshfordPride NEUTRAL LEVEL 28

Sign-Up: 07/09/05

Posts: 16,926

Internet gaming journalism.

Ha.

Aha.

Ahaha.

Ha.

BBS Signature

Expressionless

Sasorisama

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 01:03 PM

Sasorisama EVIL LEVEL 06

Sign-Up: 11/25/07

Posts: 4

Ok IGN is good for info on movies and games that are coming out soon (the ones you have to wait at least a year for they have nothing on it so don't try). The reviews suck terribly no one on IGN knows how to review anything. IGN still has nothing on the new batman game ( they still only have two chars listed while colse to 6 have been anounced). IGN is an alright sight still it is good as long as you don't go back every day.


None

xscoot

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 01:43 PM

xscoot FAB LEVEL 29

Sign-Up: 03/18/06

Posts: 3,788

IGN is good for getting info on upcoming games, so much so that they hye the shit out of everything.

But that's about it.

to give you an idea baout how bad theri revies are, Dead Or Alive: Xtreme Beach Volleball got a 9.2. That means that everything that they rate less than 9.2 is worse than some crappy boob physics.

My PSN ID is xscoot. Crazy, huh?

BBS Signature

None

Deadly-Shadow

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 02:49 PM

Deadly-Shadow EVIL LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 06/08/04

Posts: 8,002

I used to hate them, but now I think that they're pretty good. They arn't my favourite review site, but I still like to see what they say about certain games. Overall I usually trust Game Rankings the most, seeing that they give you an overall score made up from all the reviews the game has received.


None

Grubby

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 03:07 PM

Grubby FAB LEVEL 18

Sign-Up: 02/18/06

Posts: 7,238

I wouldn't ever pay for any subscription for any gaming site.

I say it's a waste of money.

But I personally think that IGN is a good source for gaming, just like Gamespot, Gamepro, and Game Informer.


None

Ultor

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 04:15 PM

Ultor NEUTRAL LEVEL 39

Sign-Up: 12/30/03

Posts: 9,282

I believe that sites like this are payed to give shitty games good ratings at least thats what gamespot proved themselves to be

Ultor- ''A brighter future and a better life''

BBS Signature

None

Blaze-Heatnix

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 04:22 PM

Blaze-Heatnix FAB LEVEL 06

Sign-Up: 02/06/06

Posts: 7,121

They add tons of hype and yet give the game a bad review when it comes out as if they didn't EXPECT anything.

Also since they're on a tight schedule they play like 5 minutes of the game before reviewing it.

Also their site navigation is fucking retarded. Different sites for each console.


None

ninjaman9000

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 04:43 PM

ninjaman9000 DARK LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 12/26/08

Posts: 495

some times the ign network has there facts wrong i would rather go to gamespot


None

ninjaman9000

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 04:45 PM

ninjaman9000 DARK LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 12/26/08

Posts: 495

some times the ign network has there facts wrong i would rather go to gamespot

Ign: Good Gaming Source Or Garbage?


None

WilliWowza

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 04:56 PM

WilliWowza LIGHT LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 01/29/04

Posts: 18,880

At 12/27/08 02:21 AM, AshfordPride wrote: Internet gaming journalism.

Ha.

Aha.

Ahaha.

Ha.

Everything sucks, I am right.

Ign: Good Gaming Source Or Garbage?

He'd Look Just Like You'd Want Him Too, Some Kind of Slick Chrome American Prince.
Tweet//LastFM//Qwantz//Blog

BBS Signature

None

xscoot

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/27/08 05:28 PM

xscoot FAB LEVEL 29

Sign-Up: 03/18/06

Posts: 3,788

I suggest using a site that has an aggregated score. That means that a bunch of people gave their thought on the game, and you are looking at the average.

That's why I kinda like gamefaqs. For current games, and some classic older ones, you can usually see 10-15 reviews, so you can make a better choice.

My PSN ID is xscoot. Crazy, huh?

BBS Signature

None

Blaze-Heatnix

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 02:16 PM

Blaze-Heatnix FAB LEVEL 06

Sign-Up: 02/06/06

Posts: 7,121

At 12/27/08 05:28 PM, xscoot wrote: That's why I kinda like gamefaqs. For current games, and some classic older ones, you can usually see 10-15 reviews, so you can make a better choice.

IGN has a user-review section.


None

Jerkapotamus

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 02:45 PM

Jerkapotamus LIGHT LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 10/10/05

Posts: 5,589

At 12/27/08 04:22 PM, Blaze-Heatnix wrote: They add tons of hype and yet give the game a bad review when it comes out as if they didn't EXPECT anything.

Different people write previews and reviews. More importantly, the demos the developers show to the press are meant to highlight the best parts of the games, so of course the previews will contain mostly positives. Since the game isn't finished, it's difficult to really criticize a game, because issues can be ironed out later in development. Basically, previews should highlight the promise a game has, which is what IGN previews generally do, and reviews should give the final word on how everything turned out.

Also since they're on a tight schedule they play like 5 minutes of the game before reviewing it.

You surely know this as fact and are not just pulling this out of your ass. Please, IGN has a pretty large staff relative to other gaming sites. If you listen to any of the IGN podcasts, they generally mention which games they've completed and when the review is going up.

Also their site navigation is fucking retarded. Different sites for each console.

Or you can go to the main page which combines all three. I like their setup since it lets me find the news I care about (360, PS3 mostly) without having to sift through everything else.

IGN is probably my favorite video game website, though I like 1UP's podcasts more. Everyone brings up the God Hand review, but it's really time to let that go. Every site has an odd review here and there.

PS3 ID: Jerkapotamus
Sig by Akula

BBS Signature

Questioning

AshtonNextGen

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 08:37 PM

AshtonNextGen DARK LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 06/25/06

Posts: 1,106

It's hard to really trust their opinion alone, if your thinking of buying a particular game I would use IGN then compare their review with Gamespot just to be on the safe side, you'll often find they have to have opposite opinions but once you've read both you can decide for yourself.
IGn are mainly harsh on particular franchises though (aka next gen sonic the hedgehog games or Spiderman sandbox games) where as gamespot tends to be a little easy on games that may deserve a lower rating, but sometimes they can be harsh too.

Its like PTA Mom vs Fun Aunt
At 12/27/08 12:16 AM, MetalDart wrote: Wii Baby Games scored higher than Mirror's Edge.
I shit you not.

AHAHAHA, that cracked me up! X3

If I ever became a ganster, I wouldnt go anywhere without Spartan Armour and a freakin Mini-Gun, man! I gotta protect myself!
http://thecrimsonemo.deviantart.com

BBS Signature

Expressionless

RiuTenshin

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 09:05 PM

RiuTenshin NEUTRAL LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 09/05/07

Posts: 1,595

It's all opinions.

Gamertag: Behindrails, add me.
Also, Free Lockerz.com invites. PM me for details.
Once you can shoot a ball of flame out of your hands, tell me to stop playing games.

BBS Signature

None

Algorithm

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 09:06 PM

Algorithm NEUTRAL LEVEL 05

Sign-Up: 12/28/08

Posts: 66

Personally. For Gaming News I go to Screwattack.
Great gaming podcasts
http://www.screwattack.com/


Angry

RiuTenshin

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 09:20 PM

RiuTenshin NEUTRAL LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 09/05/07

Posts: 1,595

At 12/27/08 12:16 AM, MetalDart wrote: Wii Baby Games scored higher than Mirror's Edge.
I shit you not.

Mirror's edge deserved that rating. After i beat it, guess what? NOTHING TO DO!

Gamertag: Behindrails, add me.
Also, Free Lockerz.com invites. PM me for details.
Once you can shoot a ball of flame out of your hands, tell me to stop playing games.

BBS Signature

None

KillerGoose

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 09:29 PM

KillerGoose DARK LEVEL 02

Sign-Up: 09/27/08

Posts: 256

Well... IGN beats the shit out of Gamespot any day.

BBS Signature

Mad as Hell

kirbykiller4

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 09:39 PM

kirbykiller4 EVIL LEVEL 12

Sign-Up: 07/09/06

Posts: 2,290

At 12/26/08 11:29 PM, puddinN64 wrote: (They keep bringing up the God Hand review..)

Well after reading it i can see why

A fucking 3/10?!

Fuck you ign,fuck you.

I'm a dragon
BoshansStudios made this awesome sig.
My gamertag is Kirbykiller13,add me,we'll go hard and kill some scrubs.

BBS Signature

None

Blaze-Heatnix

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 09:44 PM

Blaze-Heatnix FAB LEVEL 06

Sign-Up: 02/06/06

Posts: 7,121

At 12/27/08 12:16 AM, MetalDart wrote: Wii Baby Games scored higher than Mirror's Edge.
I shit you not.

Lolololololololololol.

Seriously. Imagine? Why the fuck?


None

Jerkapotamus

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 10:08 PM

Jerkapotamus LIGHT LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 10/10/05

Posts: 5,589

At 12/28/08 09:44 PM, Blaze-Heatnix wrote:
At 12/27/08 12:16 AM, MetalDart wrote: Wii Baby Games scored higher than Mirror's Edge.
I shit you not.
Lolololololololololol.

Seriously. Imagine? Why the fuck?

Because they review games for the audience intended. If a mom is looking for a game for their kids, they're saying that the baby game is above average. Mirror's Edge, which is made for the hardcore, is similarly above average for the hardcore audience.

PS3 ID: Jerkapotamus
Sig by Akula

BBS Signature

None

Jerkapotamus

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 10:08 PM

Jerkapotamus LIGHT LEVEL 33

Sign-Up: 10/10/05

Posts: 5,589

At 12/28/08 09:44 PM, Blaze-Heatnix wrote:
At 12/27/08 12:16 AM, MetalDart wrote: Wii Baby Games scored higher than Mirror's Edge.
I shit you not.
Lolololololololololol.

Seriously. Imagine? Why the fuck?

Because they review games for the audience intended. If a mom is looking for a game for their kids, they're saying that the baby game is above average. Mirror's Edge, which is made for the hardcore, is similarly above average for the hardcore audience.

PS3 ID: Jerkapotamus
Sig by Akula

BBS Signature

None

Najjo-Rulez

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/28/08 10:10 PM

Najjo-Rulez LIGHT LEVEL 18

Sign-Up: 12/07/08

Posts: 502

yeah, I recommend IGN. Although you would have to be stupid to get a subscripion cause the "insider" stuff really is not that good

Thanks to QuikFox for the sig.

BBS Signature

None

Fezz

Reply To Post Reply & Quote

Posted at: 12/29/08 12:16 AM

Fezz EVIL LEVEL 27

Sign-Up: 02/12/06

Posts: 4,353

Garbage would be an understatement.


All times are Eastern Standard Time (GMT -5) | Current Time: 04:24 AM

<< Back

This topic is 2 pages long. [ 1 | 2 ]

<< < > >>
You need a Grounds Gold Account to post on the NG BBS! If you don't have one, click here to sign up now! It's fast, free, and easy — and opens up tons of great NG features!