At 6/25/09 08:27 AM, IamWeird33 wrote:
At 6/24/09 05:49 AM, Aci6 wrote:
It wasn't one of his first reviews, anyway this conversation died with me when I typed 'watch this space'. Sigh, if only I could find some time to actually get a stack load written sometime speaking of reviews. Besides, he IS only 13, hands down improvement will surface some time.
Since I am only 13 that gives me a lot of time on my hands and probably gives me the potential to write more reviews than you.
I really don't think your reviews ar bad, IamWeird. You have shown great progress. Your first reviews definately lack some elaboration and such, but it seems like now you include many different aspects in your reviews. But seriously, the argument about writing all of these "crappy" reviews should end.
But I do have to stick with Molotov on Ray80's reviews. I am totally contradicting what I said above, but he does something I really hate. He gives a submission something less than a perfect score and doesn't say what the author needs to improve on. I sound like a nerd about this, but I find that as a way similar to +1 posting. Granted, I started out that way, my orignal reviews are terrible, but Ray80 has seen other reviews from members on this list, he has to realize the lack of information his reviews contain.
To whoever said it above, I agree that El-Syd and Molotov are some of the best reviewers on this site. I use some of the attributes that they put in their reviews. They model what good reviews should be, I also think the members of the Review Request Club, i.e. Corky and Coop, write polite and well thought out reviews. I try to write as much as I can about a flash so the author doesn't have any questions after they read my review.
Anyway, conditioning for football started at my high school so I'm going to be busy again for the next couple of weeks, so I'll try to stop by and check out what's happening here on occasion. It looks like Ericho could be reaching up in the higher ranks soon, he keeps up a constant review pace and his reviews are moderately well written. Alright, keep up the good work reviewers!