At 6/24/08 05:01 PM, Memorize wrote:
How does that not fit in with "public safety"?
I'll assume that you have already sourced that info. I'm not saying that we should just let these people loose into the world. I'm saying that they should have a jury composed of normal humans who review evidence and hear two arguments and make a decision, like any one of us would expect from an opposing country.
I'll also assume you support McCain for teh prez. What did the enemy do to him? This is the US. If we want to call ourselves some great moral power, we cannot throw people in prison when they don't even know why.
And the Trials? If our clown of a leader would have left our troops out of a country with no WMDs and no desire to have a platitude forced upon them, then maybe we'd be putting Bin Laden himself on trial.
But I digress. The importance of morality and human decency is greater than any one man will ever possess.
You first use a SC decision against Lincoln on Habeas Corpus to justify the SC decision today, but then turn around and defend Lincoln because you deem it as "more serious"?
I have trouble conveying my thoughts into interweb-ese. I was trying to say that if the Confederate army didn't cut it, these guys really don't.
For one, they could argue that Lincoln over-stepped his bounds because they were fighting his very own country-men while he was attempting to maintain control of the Union.
Well, that would be speculation, and speculation upon historical events can absorb hours upon hours. (see also: Dan Carlin) There are many things I could say they could have argued, too.
Also, the foreign enemy combatants today are not being held on US soil and are also not granted the same "rights" as you would typically find because they do not fight a sovereign nation, but rather as a terrorist organization who directly violates all of the laws of warfare concerning UN regulation.
So you're saying that to fight their evil, we must become evil ourselves? Granted, less evil, but still, dude!
And you've apparently failed US Constitution and History/Government classes.
Go back under your hole.
Alright Mez, I have to be straight with you. saying things like this (which is by the way, one of the least offensive snide remarks you've thrown my way) does not make you more intelligent, it doesn't make you a better debater, and it doesn't faze me one bit.
Feel the Love