The thing about the AP is attention.
Everyone who submits songs wants attention in some way, be it by votes, or reviews. Most people probably appreciate the reviws most.
Not everyone who reviews votes, and vice versa.
Problem is though, that high overall score is one way to get attention, since u´ll be high on the list, and thats as I see it the main reason ppl vote 0, so their own songs will "get a boost".
So, when my songs are voted 0 for, I get pissed, like everyone else. Just the fact that someone has "dissed" my songs of no other reason than to make their own shit climb the lists. That is simply not fair to the songs that gets fucked over, and the rated song is in the top with dirty methods. Very often its a song noone really likes too, by some new music maker who just realised he/she can reach the top of the lists that way.
So still, attention is the word, that´s what everyone is after. One other big problem is, that not as many ppl as in the flash portal are visiting the ap, still there are tons of new songs every day. Ppl simply dont have time to reckognize them all.
There are lots of shitty songs popping (pooping) out too, and that too is a problem. The ap dont get the credability it deserves due to this fact, it is difficult to find serious made stuff sometimes. And the hell with the A-Bot´s Weekly Top Five , that shit´s just pathetic. we all know how it works, the one with highest score when page is updated reaches it.
Maybe the blamming system would be a good idea, and i do have something creative to contribute wtih here, not only critisism;
If blamming system would be added to the AP, the song might be on the page for an amount of time, so it can be viewd (listened to) by more people. And to avoid the constant 0 voting, there should be a vote-obstacle, so that u either have to download the song to be able to vote, or listen THROUGH the song first!
This is an example of how it might look, so that people actually would get atteniton, and to me it sounds more exciting :D
Just gonna say that no, i seriously dont like the new graphic either, i want a better overview of the songs that there is now. Maybe better solution of my screen is the ansewer to that tho ;)
If anyone have more examples of how to make the AP better, write them down here, and maybe someone can take them all and send them to Tom or whoever.
Personally i think the whole voting system (scores when reviewing vs simple voting) should be carefully considered, if it really suits the AP at all.
End of essay.
/Rucklo