At 10/14/08 04:51 PM, JoS wrote:
If you go to university I am sure you have heard of some group advertising meetings for a group about the "Israeli Apartheid" . hell I am sure most of us have heard this term before. However, am I the only one who finds this to be racist and bigoted?
No, the comparison is neither racist nor bigoted. It's completely apt.
First, apartheid is generally defined as a system of segregation or discrimination on the grounds of race.
Pointing out that Arab-Israelis are allowed to vote does not prove your point Rugby. The apartheid comparison is directed towards Israel's treatment of Palestinians in the Occupied Territories. They don't get to vote in Israeli elections - only shams of elections via the Palestinian Authority, an administration organization, not a government. Saying that Palestinian disenfranchisement is OK because they are not citizens is circular logic. In apartheid S. Africa, black disenfranchisement was OK because they were not considered 1st class citizens. Israel is still in de facto control of both the West Bank and the Gaza Strip. Palestine is not an organized state, and Israel actively works to prevent a functioning state from emerging.
Egypt blocking refugees from entering their borders has nothing to do on this topic.
The fact that many home demolitions are justified on the basis of "permits" does not condone these demolitions. Israel has in the past used three main justifications for demolitions - as retribution for "terrorism," national security reasons, and the houses were built without permits.
During the Second Intifada (2000-current), Israel has demolished 5000 homes, nearly 2000 excused because of permits, more than 600 as retribution. Israel has stopped the retribution justification, but still demolishes based on the second two. Israel makes obtaining building permits by Palestinians in the Occupied Territories virtually impossible. In addition to housing, Israel has also targeted Palestinian Authority ministry offices, infrastructure, and cultivatable land.
Israel controls all borders and access points (ports, airports), collects taxes and duties for the Palestinian Authority (and withholds said taxes on political grounds), continues to build a segregated highway system running throughout the Occupied Territories, constructs illegal walls, settlements, and checkpoints preventing Palestinians from moving freely throughout the Occupied Territories. All of Israel's actions have reinforced and exacerbated conditions in the Occupied Territories, where 2/3s of Palestinians are impoverished and unemployment sits around the 50% mark. Since the '06 elections, Israel has withheld the taxes and duties owed to the PA, which now runs almost entirely on foreign aid. This money goes toward basic infrastructure like schools, police and fire stations.
Pointing out these facts does not make me an anti-semite. Calling Israel's actions in the Occupied Territories "apartheid" does not make me racist. Condemning the actions of the government of Israel has nothing to do with Judaism.
"How I experienced a deja vu when I saw a security check point which Palestinians had to negotiate most of their lives that I was reminded so painfully of the same checkpoints in apartheid South Africa, when arrogant white policemen treated almost all blacks like dirt, or, when someone pointed to a house in Jerusalem and said that used to be our home, but now it has been taken over by the Israelis, which made me recall so painfully similar statements in Cape Town by coloureds who had been thrown out of their homes and relocated in ghetto townships some distance from town."
-- Desmond Tutu