At 4/1/07 05:44 PM, Imperator wrote:
"There's also the question of "Good" and "Evil" inherent in this line of discussion, since an atheist perspective effectively negates such an existance of such notions.
Morality is a secular concept. We don't need a magical man in the sky to tell us what's right and wrong, our intuition does finely by itself
Hitler's behavior can be described and analyzed through scientific discovery, moreover it can be understood and even justified in some instances, since without such a polarization, one's behavior as "good" or "bad" is simply a matter of perspective."
...No. Hitler's motivations were not for the purpose of science. Hitler was motivated by hatred and greed.
Besides, what scientific discoveries were made as a result of the Holocaust other than "how many times can you hit a child on the head with a hammer before it dies"? Serious question, it'd be interesting to know what the Holocaust did for our current knowledge of science.
What do you hope to gain? If there is no gain (or no perceived gain), by what logic do you do these actions."
I honestly don't know what you're referring to here
"If you say your end goal is simply helping people, there comes the question of why that would be your end goal as to any other, what circumstances did that goal arise within? For religion, it's the moral code, the Golden Rules.
For atheists, there is a moral code, but it's not clear where that arose from, or how it differs from the religious code."
Conscience is a society-forming instinct, thus anything which is inherently damaging to a society (or individual) is considered "bad", and anything which benefits a society / individual is considered "good".
I'm not entirely sure how helping people and societies in other cultures links into it (unless the motivation is just for praise and recognition by other people). However, conscience is definitely a physical thing which doesn't have to be related to religion, hence why damage to certain areas of the brain (for instance, in the frontal lobe) during child development negates any morality they would have otherwise had in later life.
Here's an interesting article which could probably answer your questions better than I can