At 9/10/09 02:36 AM, Dawnslayer wrote:
If there's anything to be gleaned from the civil rights movement, it's that an oppressed people are most empowered not by outside help, but by their own faculty
No one said achieving equality would be easy; but if it's worth dying for, then surely it's worth a little extra effort.
And who says minorities DON'T give *any* effort? I think it's highly ignorant for people to assume that just because there are AA policies that this equates to hiring the unqualified.
Furthermore, this notion that a mere 45 years of legal recognition of Civil Rights is enough to erase hundreds of years of systematic institutionalized prejudice and ecnoomic impairment is indicative of just how ingrained majority privelage is, i.e. racial majorities still get to decide whether or not discrimination is *actually* occurring.
Is there a problem with underachievment? Absolutely yes, and I completely agree with you that the greatest asset a person can develop is an intrinsic sense of self-worth in education and occupation. Not to get too political, but this is precisely what Obama (as well as MANY others) have been saying about education--that the government (including AA policies) can only do so much, but the real change and success is up to the individual to make that effort.
Affirmative Action, while sound in principle, does have flaws in its application, hence the court cases like the New Haven FD being used to analyze and correct the areas where AA is not living up to its intentions of equality. However, to dispense with it entirely is dangerously ignorant of the long road we as a nation and society have in addressing the explicit and implicit inequalities that occur because of unfound prejudices.