Things i've given my gf:
-Plush stuffed puppy
-Food
-Silver turtle thingy
-Plush Strawberry Shortcake doll
-Anonymous little stuffed animals
-Handmade stuff, this stuff works good if you wanna get your gf happy.
If you're going to get her something get her stuff you know she likes. My gf likes Strawberry Shortcake so that's why I got her the little dolls. She also likes turtles alot so I gave her this little silver one I found when cleaning the other day. I don't know why but girls just really love it when you give them something too.
Things she's given me:
-Stuffed teddy bear (medium size I think)
-Pajama pants
-Food
-Handmade stuff
-CD with pictures of us on it
As you can see i've kinda not recieved that good of gifts back. The pajama pants are good I guess. She just has given me nearly as much stuff as i've given her and she gives me stuff I wouldnt normally like. When I give or make her something I try to make it fit with her style or things she likes. She is getting me a dragon keychain soon though, lol. Anyways, I think that i've been typing this enough. Dunno if this helped you at all though......