Okay, so I know this girl. Lucy. Lucy had a boyfriend, James. Okay so James asked out Lucy a while back, Lucy said no, so James went out with Lucy's friend Laura, then Laura broke up with James and convinced Lucy to go out with him.
This is where it all began.
Lucy and James dated for ages, altogether about a year and a half, with about two or three break-ups. During one of these break-ups, James ran back to Laura and dated her again for a short while while Lucy dated Tim. But they always got back together because they really liked eachother. So James dumps Lucy two years after on-off relationships. Lucy is really upset and just wants to go and hug James, but she can't. She was really upset. She was virtually in love with James.
Furthermore, James then asks Lucy to go and find out if another girl, Shana, likes James, just a few days after their terrible break up. Lucy is heartbroken, but obliges because she still likes James so much. To her dismay, Shana likes James. So James asks out Shana, and Shana agrees. Then James starts spreading horrible things about Lucy, calling her ugly and weird and a bitch and more. Lucy is even more heartbroken. To top it all off, Lucy learns that James fancied Shana whilst dating Lucy.
So finally after a while Lucy gets over James, and dates a boy who she was close to, Daniel. James and Shana split up after a short while, as do Lucy and Daniel. We all thought it would be another on-off thing, but after what James did, months pass and they don't get back together, nor show any sign of doing so.
Eventually we learn that James has asked for Lucy back, and Lucy has told him he has to prove he likes her in order to have him back.
Now I think Lucy is being a bit of a mug, because it's clear she wants him back, after all he did to her. What do you think, NG? Do you think Lucy should even CONSIDER taking James back? I need opinions from strangers to hopefully convince Lucy.