Wow, ok. So I skimmed the last few pages of the abusive review thread. Serious business indeed.
Moving on to this thread:
At 8/16/08 07:17 PM, Solraczeravla wrote:
After some time, we notice that the review wasn't deleted, what's worst, we lost whistle points for flagging it.
I don't see how that's possible to know for sure. Although I will compromise by saying this seems to be a more common problem for users lately.
So we need to solve this problem, the controversy is getting greater and greater, since flagging an abusive review actually destroys your whistle, we have a modding problem, and it must be fixed as soon as possible.
If there is a problem with a mod or a group of mods, why post it here? Why not contact Wade about it? In fact that's exactly what I'd suggest. If it's a case of bad modding, you don't complain on the BBS--you contact an admin (and if it's a legitimate concern and not whiny complaining, then he may get back to you).
I assume the reason why you shouldn't flag it is because those reviews are not legit, and are cheat reviews. The main goal of that spam account would be achieved if anyone got whistle points. In order to discourage this, you are rewarded negative whistle points instead.
Don't consider it rule, just keep it in mind.
That incident (which happened a while ago) was indeed a mistake by a mod. The flags shouldn't have been cleared on those reviews. Thus, you shouldn't be "punished" anymore (rather, the reviews just won't be deleted before the account is, or the flags will be cleared without any penalty and THEN they'll be deleted--at least that's how I see it).
So this thread was created to fight this problem, everyone is invited to contact someone important (honestly I don't think Tom or Wade would attend you, but it can happen) and report him what's going on.
How is this fighting the problem? All you're doing is complaining about the review mods in a place where you won't get much more than speculation and complaints from users who went down a whistle level.
At 8/16/08 07:30 PM, C-Hawk wrote:
3) All 24 reviews are deleted.
4) Everyone who flagged those 24 reviews are punished with negative whistle points
if the reviews are deleted, how are you tying the two incidents together? Or are you thinking the flags were cleared and THEN the reviews were deleted, which seems completely asinine of an idea for anyone to do. Seems to me that these are two separate incidents.
If it is some kind of "rouge mod" clearing the flags, there's no way for any user or mod to know who it is and/or what their specific actions are. Even if it's some kind of "glitch", there's no way any mod or user could give evidence of this or explain it properly.
Since you're so concerned, why hasn't an administrator been contacted? I saw someone posting a link to the staff page here, but did anyone take action? I don't think this is a problem with the review mod team, since there really haven't been any more new review mods lately. If an account was compromised, the "hacker" would do a lot more than clear your flags.