How long did it take you to make your first flash game, while learning the ins and outs of flash?
It didn't take long, there was always lots of experiments, I would try making a game, fail at it but then learn something from it and refine how I did things. To get my first flash out onto NG took a while (months and months) because I was just 13/14 so I couldn't really keep myself on the same project for long.
It sounds like you're a college student though, so you should have no problem with this, I would expect you to be able to concentrate and spend your time more wisely.
Ideally I would want the game to be something simple. Perhaps a single level, of a classic platformer or sidescroller. I'm also tossing around the idea of a tower defense game.
Assuming it's all from scratch:
A platformer can be very hard, depending on how smooth you want it because of the collision detection (if you go with a platformer, please don't make the jump a full animation, let the script move the player). A sidescroller would be much simpler. A tower defense is simple if you learn the concepts involved, like arrays and tile-based maps, stuff like that.
But you can get an average game of any of those types finished with just tutorials on the internet.
I mainly ask these questions because, I'm an art student and for my project i was asked to make a toy or a game. And for my final I can continue the toy or game. This means I have about 5 weeks until the deadline for the project. I'm not worried about the art aspect of the game, it's mainly the programming I am worried about.
Essentially, what could I make in this time period? Is a game too ambitious (when I have a 4 other classes to worry about as well?). And what more difficult to create (in terms of programming), a tower defense game or a platformer?
In 5 weeks time? It really all depends on how commited you are, if you've got some passion for learning this besides getting a good grade then you'll be totally fine in whichever you choose. It's all dependent on how much time you actually sit down with flash learning actionscript..
I would say a platformer is harder to make than a tower defense, but I would probably go with doing a platformer because it's much nicer than a tower defense and you can go as far as you want with it. There's SO many tutorials on making a platformer, just be logical and follow them and you'll have your platformer..
All comments and feedback are greatly appreciated! :D
Good luck with this, just commit to it.