At 11/9/09 11:28 AM, amaterasu wrote:
The bottom line is, by stereotyping all religious as closed minded and uncaring individuals, you are making yourself no better than the zealots who believe stereotypes about all nonbelievers.
Nah. Nonbelievers are not necessarily collectively united by anything, as opposed to people of collective religions, who necessarily are.
How different is that from the racists, who have had a few bad experiences with [insert ethnicity] people in their lives and therefore accept all the stereotypes and prejudice, and make similar assertions? "All [insert ethnicity] are bad, screw 'em, my race is better.".
Totally disingenuous thing to say.
The religion of a person is not some inseparable, unconditional quality they are born with, as race is. There is always a choice for them to believe their bronze-age myths, or not, or believe other bronze-age myths. Furthermore the actions of a person have an intrinsic relationship with their beliefs, which often provide a motivational role, whereas race does not necessarily dictate anybody's actions; especially in such an exact, direct manner.
Utter stupidity.
What is actual utter stupidity is people like you failing to acknowledge that the actions of this camp are dictated by their belief in their religion. Instead, you constantly play the other side as the bad guy by playing the 'generalisations' card again and again, like that somehow absolves religion as the motivator for religious people's actions.