At 11/7/03 09:33 PM, Newgrundling wrote:
I just saw the Matrix III (Revolutions) a few hours ago, and my opinion differs from yours. I haven’t seen Elf, so I didn’t bother reading that commentary, nor do I plan to respond to it.
As I've been saying, we're all entitled to our own opinion. No opinion is wrong.
Your biggest problem with this movie seems to be that it’s not the same cookie-cutter “kung fu” choreographed fighting movie as the previous two. I wouldn’t expect nor enjoy a movie that simply was a “formula movie” intended to please movie-goers such as yourself who don’t want to be surprised, merely to get exactly what they have gotten before. That’s a real pity.
Now now, you're interpreting what I said very incorrectly. In fact, most of the movies I enjoy thoroughly (Memento, Pulp Fiction, Pi, Fight Club, The Singing Detective - which just got released yesterday in a limited amount of theatres... I highly recommend it for the gonzo arthouse filmmaking that it is) follow a very skewed formula that audiences have a very hard time to grasp. Not only that, but the movies I love have unexpected endings or circumstances, and pose interesting questions. It's a pity I've been misinterpreted. But, to continue, you didn't think the second and third movies were formula movies? I think they followed a strict formula: Man and machine fight, but grapple to understand each other. Yes, ultimately, there seems to be some understanding on the machines part at the end, but the only person who truely understood the machines is now dead. The first film showed the struggle, but asked many more questions (as I've mentioned before): Why are we here? What if this whole universe is an elaborate dream? Et cetera. The second and third felt forced... a way to get more money. Hollow.
There are only two major “kung fu” fight scenes, and of course the “fight scene” for Xion, but that’s a different style. You seem to enjoy the Matrix movies for these fight scenes, and that’s really a pity. You’re missing the best part of the movie: The allusions, religious implications, predictions, warnings, technological possibilities, and other thought-provoking, debatable concepts.
You are missing the things that make the movie horrible. The plot holes. Before I jump into that pool, let me re-iterate: I'm not into the Matrix strictly for the fight scenes. As for the fighting scenes in the Matrix: I didn't like a lot of the Matrix battles in Reloaded. And Revolutions, the in-Matrix fighting had verve, like I said. Verve I felt was lost in Reloaded in most scenes. The fight for Zion was... How shall I put this... boring. Graphically, it was a feat to behold - but it got boring quick... but I digress, the main part of this paragraph is the plot holes: and there are many.
-spoiler alert-
Example - The machines have a truce with the humans at the end of revolutions. Now, Neo is dead, but the humans just assume the war is over (which it's not, it's more of a truce) because of Neo. Okay, I'll roll with that. But the machines still need energy to survive. The machines are still harvesting humans for energy. It's loose ends like that... that really sting. Okay, so let's say Germany and the world during WWII had a truce, but they were still putting Jews in internment camps. What's the point of the truce? Nobody dies, but you still have thousands if not millions of prisoners. That's a gaping plot hole, if you ask me. (A small plot hole was: Neo shouldn't have been stuck in the train station. Yet the train conducter was "God" there. Okay, he created the train station... but Merovingian created his part of the Matrix too. We're to assume Merovingian is stronger than the trainman (as his part is credited) - since the trainman follows Merovingian's orders. Didn't Neo escape Merovingian's castle, simply by flying? Why didn't he attempt to fly out of there? He didn't try at all. Neo is in the Matrix, can fight Agent Smith... can fight hordes of baddies... but one trainman punks him out with one punch? Jeez, why aren't we seeing a big fight scene with this guy?
-end spoiler alert-
I'd be curious to know what, specifically, the Matrix 2 and 3 brought to the table for you. What new philosophies it posed.
[split into a second message due to the limit on message size]